News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by peterwwillis on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:14AM (#2327836)
However, I will suggest that his various missives, rants, and other statements contribute positively to the general fabric of discussion around software freedom and personal privacy.

ESR stated in Revolution OS that RMS's 'wholesale attack' on (was it software patents or intellectual property? i don't remember now) was one of the reasons it was hard to convince businesses this wasn't just a hippie pipe dream.

The OpenMoko runs all Free code, afaik, so the whole "being tracked by Big Brother" deal sounds like tinfoil hat syndrome. This particular rant only points out that most cellphones run on proprietary software. Why don't we just shout about anything that uses proprietary software like cars or industrial manufacturing equipment? We know it's proprietary, but comparing it all to a fascist regime isn't going to contribute positively to a discussion to make it more open.

Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by snippyhollow on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:45AM (#2327991)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think that a fully free cell phone OS is preventing you from being tracked. Even if free software was bug/backdoors free (I'm not sure about it). How do you connect to the network? Through a SIM-card, with an ID, linked to your cell-phone contract. And whatever goes on the broadband/network of your cell phone contract provider is free to read for him. You don't initiate your phone calls with an exchange of GPG keys with your contact, nor do you register your contract with a fake name. The only solution for that is the combination of a prepaid SIM in cash with encrypted VOIP on 3G+.
Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by peterwwillis on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @01:58PM (#2328626)
You can be tracked anywhere there's a communications infrastructure. It is required for things like law enforcement as well as being part of the protocols that run the network. Since basically every country on the planet does this, comparing it to a Stalinist order seems retarded, and I don't think it will ever change.
Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by TheAmazingIdiot on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @06:17PM (#2329722)
Better yet, if you are transmitting anything, there's these wonderful devices called "Radio direction finders".

We dont need to know how GSM is transmitted, or what encryption schemes they're using. If you are outputting a signal, you can be found. Hell, there's competitions for RDF.

Now, just not carrying a cell phone is a good idea on not being tracked. Next best is taking the battery out of the phone. "Off" does not mean off, even in airplane mode. Some GSM frames are still transmitted, as per what my fellow ham geeks have told me (I'm one as well).

Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by count on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:37AM (#2327954)
The OpenMoko does not run all free code, and neither does any other shipping cellular device. The code in the baseband processor is very specifically NOT open on anything. In most cases, neither is the GPS. This is because, iirc, that the FCC requires it to be that way, for spectrum licensing and usage reasons.
Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by peterwwillis on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:02PM (#2328646)
Ok, this is a good point. The code encrypting/decrypting the GSM is not open, which means it'll eventually be cracked, and until then we have to just assume nobody else has figured it out. But does this have anything to do with being spied on?

Other than the government decoding your GSM communications (which it can just ask Ma Bell to tap without a warrant and get away with, according to the W.Bush-era abuses) I don't see that particular un-free code helping in tracking or spying on you.

Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by count on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:20PM (#2328713)
Well, it's not open, and all comms go through it - we have no idea what it actually does?
Re:Richard Stallman: Cell phones are 'Stalin's dream' by indrax on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:34PM (#2328200)
It's not "tin foil hat" it old news that's just being ignored.

http://news.cnet.com/2100-1029_3-6140191.html

Tin foil hats wouldn't be quite as silly if mind control rays were real and already used in the field.