News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by antirez on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @06:56AM (#2326839)
Enough articles "everything is fine" for my tastes circulating onto Hacker News, while instead the facts created more and more concerns. I think it's better to just wait, and hope, instead of blabling about things that even the top experts of the world are having an hard time to figure. There will be a time, in a few weeks, and hopefully after a disaster was avoided, to speculate about the real security of nuke power.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by dublinclontarf on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @07:43AM (#2326971)
Sadly within a few weeks, armies of anti-nuclear campainers, writers, and politicians will have jumped on this and pumped it so through the roof that, even if everything in this article is correct most people won't listen. Look at Chernobyl or Three Mile Island (study after study found no major exposure by anyone).

The hysteria over this is caused by the anti-nuclear people and groups trying to use this as a case against nuclear power, blowing everything out of proportion before any facts are known.

I think a few articles calling for calm balances the shrieking cries of "meltdown imminent".

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by kmfrk on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @08:46AM (#2327174)
>Sadly within a few weeks, armies of anti-nuclear campainers, writers, and politicians will have jumped on this and pumped it so through the roof that, even if everything in this article is correct most people won't listen.

NYT, Guardian, Spiegel, Mother Jones, The Atlantic (every online publication there is), every news TV channel (except Al Jazeera). Greenpeace are all over the place with their campaigning.

The hysteria isn't imminent - it's happening right now. If people don't fight the campaign to stop nuclear energy, the factoids are going to dominate the discourse in many years to come.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by timr on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @01:27PM (#2328471)
"If people don't fight the campaign to stop nuclear energy, the factoids are going to dominate the discourse in many years to come."

I don't think it's fair to characterize the opposition's arguments so flippantly (as "factoids"). I'm far from an opponent of nuclear energy, but there are a lot of damned good reasons to be contemplative about a system where one bad day can injure thousands of people, and simultaneously make thousands of square miles of land unfit for human habitation for hundreds of years.

We (humans) seem to have a remarkably bad ability to correctly estimate the likelihood of "improbable" events. When that unfortunate trait crosses with the potential for out-sized, long-term impacts on the environment, it's right to be wary. It isn't totally irrational to argue that an extremely conservative position on risk is appropriate in that situation.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by serichsen on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @05:02PM (#2329375)
That was a pretty bad day, right? However, no armageddon has occurred.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by nakkiel on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:25AM (#2327905)
I deeply agree with that. At the same time, I believe it's time to forcefully put other energy sources to use, make them work and more generally give them their chance. I'd go as far as saying this would draw a lot of economical activity world-wide and get us out of the economical crisis for good.

In a way, I see this event as an opportunity. It's just been demonstrated that Nuclear Energy is safe enough (at least, that's how I see things) but I still believe we deserve greener energies.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by Robin_Message on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:26PM (#2328168)
Hang on, I'm confused. If you think nuclear energy is good, why should the others get a chance? Surely we should go with the best option (which obviously includes diversity, but ought to have the overall best as its main component.)

I don't mean to be rude, but this isn't a playground. Solar power will not get a complex if nuclear is chosen instead. Our way of life depends on energy, and just hoping other sources will work out seems naive at best.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @04:30PM (#2329229)
>Solar power will not get a complex if nuclear is chosen instead.

I think we'll run out of economically extractable ore deposits of nuclear fuels a little before Sol goes supernova. Perhaps that's it.

Also, unless he edited, he said that Nuclear was "safe enough" not that it was the best option. Even if it were the best primary option I wouldn't want to rely on it exclusively; personally I consider that "renewable" sources are better. Fusion would appear to be the best if we can get it to work effectively but I'd still look to diversify to some extent.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by hartror on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @07:49AM (#2326993)
I consider myself a leftie greenie politically, and I am pro nuclear (with some small reservations). It pisses me off no end to see the same people campaigning for action on climate change campaigning against the one proven at scale technology that can help us out of the climate change mess.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by billybob on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:35AM (#2327618)
I'm not an environmentalist, but as a technology person, I'm extremely skeptical of claims that nuclear power can be safe, however well-designed the reactors are today. It's hard enough to tell whether my web server will be able to handle next year's traffic.

Nuclear power produces waste that is dangerous for thousands of years. How can anyone say, with a straight face, that they have a plan for that? All of us will be dead and every government in the world will have changed. Our current languages won't be spoken anymore. The location of the waste deposits will likely be forgotten. There is absolutely no way to predict what will happen to the waste, and it seems awfully selfish to foist that kind of problem on people in the future to solve our very short-term energy needs.

If there is a form of nuclear power that completely expends its fuel to the point where its demonstrably not dangerous TODAY, or if we can launch the waste into the sun, I'm all for it. But lets not pretend we can control the damage from things that will persist for thousands of years after we're dead.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by natnat on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:39AM (#2327970)
Before saying that nuclear power isn't safe enough, consider where we get most of our electricity from today: coal. Coal may have been around a long time, but it is far more dangerous than nuclear power. The fly ash produced by coal burning often contains substantial concentrations of uranium (not too bad) and radium (very bad), as well as all sorts of other toxic but non-radioactive chemicals like lead.

Although there is a lot more net radiation coming from all the fly ash we produce that there is from our nuclear reactors, the EPA doesn't bother to treat fly ash as hazardous waste, so most people don't think it's scary. This means we already have a bunch of radioactive waste dumped into our landfills without much oversight at all.

While nuclear waste is very dangerous, there isn't a whole lot of it, and it's quite safe when it's stored properly in a radiation-sealed container. It doesn't end up in our landfills, or our air supply. It's a point source of pollution, which makes it much easier to take care of, and it is much nicer to leave future generations some concentrated, shielded radioactive waste in remote areas than to leave them tons of low-level waste in their water supply.

I'm an advocate of solar energy, and nuclear power is a hell of a lot less safe than I'd like. But as long as we're burning coal, we should be worried more about the risks of that, even though they may be less scary-seeming, because they truly are more dangerous.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by lukeschlather on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:26PM (#2328164)
I would also add that a lot of what we call nuclear waste in the US could be re-used as fuel if we built processing plants and modern reactors.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by billybob on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:15PM (#2332868)
Excellent point. :)
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by amalcon on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:53AM (#2327715)
That sets the bar too high, though. It doesn't need to be perfectly safe. It need only be safer than the alternatives.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by knieveltech on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:43AM (#2327666)
The thing is, it doesn't take hordes of engineers nearly a decade to design your web server.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by whyenot on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:21AM (#2327870)
If his webserver goes down he doesn't need to evacuate everyone in a 30km radius.

Apples and oranges.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by knieveltech on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:19PM (#2328708)
We're in violent agreement here.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by sutro on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:00PM (#2328054)
Good point. It took hordes of engineers almost two decades to design his web server. http://httpd.apache.org/ABOUT_APACHE.html
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by hartror on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @09:05PM (#2330224)
Sure, but those hordes who designed it didn't spend time training him to set it up and run it correctly. Just face that it is a horrible analogy and move on.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by easp on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:49AM (#2328015)
Yes, advocates are over promising on safety, but the incumbent alternatives (burning fossil fuels) have their own downsides with global impact.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by mort on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @04:33PM (#2329245)
"I'm not an environmentalist" What exactly do you mean by this?

I don't understand how someone can make such a bold denouncement about something as crucial the system that keeps us alive...

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by natnat on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:58PM (#2330521)
I think it's something like saying, "I'm not a feminist, but I think women are people too.". Environmentalism, like feminism, tends to be associated with a lot of fringe people who believe crazy things, even if the mainstream of the movements are totally reasonable things. A lot of people see organizations like the Earth Liberation Front or whatever and thing that's what environmentalism is about, when it's really just about giving a shit about something we all need.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by tomjen3 on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:46AM (#2327681)
The reason they campaign against that is that they don't want us to continue running around in this stage of sin (technological development), but to return to grace (in this case back to working 18 hour days with a single failed harvest killing us).

Much of the hardcore environmental movement is using it as a substitute for religion, except in an even more insane way.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by michaeldhopkins on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:34PM (#2328772)
More like 4-12 hours per day depending on the age of the farm (startups take work), the quality of the land and the crop season. More hours during planting and harvesting, and almost nothing during the winter. The number didn't really depend on technology past a certain point of desperation (passed well before recorded history.) For example, the gothic cultures farmed before they borrowed the plow from the Romans. Post-plow they became richer instead of cutting back hours. No different than today.

There were many provisions for crop failure, including crop variety, raising animals, preserving food, fishing and trading with luckier regions. Like today.

Pro-agrarian looking to set the record straight. I'm also in favor of nuclear power!

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by gmac on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:46PM (#2328259)
I'm not advocating a 'return to grace', but you picked a rather selective definition of 'grace'. Looking further back (or elsewhere) than subsistence agriculture, hunter-gathering is potentially a pretty leisurely lifestyle: the 'original affluent society' (http://www.eco-action.org/dt/affluent.html).
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by sunchild on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @01:21PM (#2328440)
Yes, turn on CNN or MSNBC right now, and all you will hear about is an imminent meltdown, and what it means for US nuclear power. This article is a drop of sanity in a sea of stupidity.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by marshray on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:45PM (#2329056)
Correction: It's not an imminent meltdown.

It's an ongoing meltdown.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by Robin_Message on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:21PM (#2328151)
I agree that balance is good, and that in truth, nuclear power is very safe, but consider what happens if there is a major release of radioactivity. How is this article going to look then? I think you'd agree it would weaken the credibility of pro-nuclear campaigners.

Lying for the sake of truth is a bad idea.

As it stands, a meltdown is a definite possibility (not necessarily probable.) Perhaps a better stratergy would be to say "It might meltdown. In which case the reactor will be ruined, but no radioactivity will be released. Or the primary vessel might be damaged, in which case this would be a Chenobyl style disaster, except we have already evacuated the area as a precaution, so the estimated death toll would be 10 (or 100 or whatever.)"

I'd say people fear what they don't understand; having lots of people, especially scientists and politicians, say "there's nothing to worry about" only increases peoples' worry – especially when bits of the plant keep exploding.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by dublinclontarf on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:36PM (#2328209)
>Lying for the sake of truth is a bad idea.

This isn't lying, it's accurate according to the information that we have acquired over the last 60 years on the use of nuclear technology. Should these predictions turn out to be incorrect then the information we have needs to be updated. I'm hoping it turns out well, there are of course no guarantees but the chances of things going even further south are low.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by bluedanieru on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @07:50AM (#2326996)
Just a quick point of order: study after study on Chernobyl found major exposure by just about everyone. It was serious business. This is where, without any containment vessel at all, the fuel caught fire and the radioactive ash spread all over the place.

But you are right about Three-Mile Island.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by dublinclontarf on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @08:40AM (#2327155)
Yes there was exposure, certainly those 4000 children recieved high enough levels. However this is a far cry of hundreds of thousands of dangerous exposures, massive increases of cancer rates and birth defects that are still happening that most people think of.

I myself thought just that until recently after investigating it.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by sterling on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:12AM (#2327500)
I was studying in Russia when Chernobyl occurred, and I dated a woman from northern Ukraine who was a teenager at the time of the accident. I saw the results of the accident firsthand - basically everyone under the age of 10 was affected - hair loss, skin rashes and nausea in the immediate years after, cancer and early death later. But even so it isn't fair to judge the safety of nuclear power by Chernobyl. Chernobyl happened because the Soviet system had become incredibly incompetent, and technical decisions were being made by thugs.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by brazzy on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @04:52PM (#2329333)
The capitalist system quite often also becomes incredibly incompetent and has its technical decisions made by thugs. Tepco, the company that runs the Fukushima plant, has a long history of corruption, faked security reports and blatant incompetence.

What makes nuclear power unsafe is human error more than technical failure. That's the aspect the naive technocrats (like the guy who wrote this article) always ignore.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by jshen on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:09AM (#2327803)
Are you saying that only 4000 people were affected?
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by dublinclontarf on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:52AM (#2328025)
Read the reports.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by jshen on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:09PM (#2328096)
You didn't answer the question, nor did you link any reports. Are you saying that only 4000 people were affected?
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by dublinclontarf on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:30PM (#2328184)
I'm saying what the reports are saying.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2326129

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by pella on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:39PM (#2329034)
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ijc.22037/full

"Models predict that by 2065 about 16,000 (95% UI 3,400–72,000) cases of thyroid cancer and 25,000 (95% UI 11,000–59,000) cases of other cancers may be expected due to radiation from the accident, whereas several hundred million cancer cases are expected from other causes. Although these estimates are subject to considerable uncertainty, they provide an indication of the order of magnitude of the possible impact of the Chernobyl accident. It is unlikely that the cancer burden from the largest radiological accident to date could be detected by monitoring national cancer statistics. Indeed, results of analyses of time trends in cancer incidence and mortality in Europe do not, at present, indicate any increase in cancer rates—other than of thyroid cancer in the most contaminated regions—that can be clearly attributed to radiation from the Chernobyl accident."

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by jshen on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:10PM (#2328667)
What SOME reports are saying. You are cherry picking the lowest counts.

"But other reputable scientists researching the most radiation-contaminated areas of Russia, Belarus and Ukraine are not convinced. The International Agency for Research on Cancer, another UN agency, predicts 16,000 deaths from Chernobyl; an assessment by the Russian academy of sciences says there have been 60,000 deaths so far in Russia and an estimated 140,000 in Ukraine and Belarus.

Meanwhile, the Belarus national academy of sciences estimates 93,000 deaths so far and 270,000 cancers, and the Ukrainian national commission for radiation protection calculates 500,000 deaths so far."

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by vegai on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:02AM (#2327455)
Then again, I've understood that the worst casualty of Chernobyl was the roughly 200 000 babies who were needlessly aborted because of fears of radiation poisoning.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by OpieCunningham on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:25PM (#2328742)
But you are right about Three-Mile Island.

He's not right about TMI, either. The results of TMI are debated to this day with some studies claiming minimal or no adverse health affects and some studies claiming significant adverse health affects.

Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by serichsen on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @05:09PM (#2329403)
Just because someone disagrees, an issue is not necessarily controversial. You have to take the substantial merit of the arguments into account.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by OpieCunningham on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @05:16PM (#2329429)
Of course you're right. But there is no indication in the OP that he has done that in any way. Nor amongst the literally dozens of identical claims regarding TMI I've seen on HN in the past few days.
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by beefman on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @01:53PM (#2328600)
People deserve to know if anything is currently wrong, throughout this event. If a public health problem does obtain, that doesn't make people who suggested it obtained before it did correct!
Re:Fukushima is a triumph for nuke power: Build more reactor... by beefman on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @08:29PM (#2330133)
Downvoted, really? Please explain.