News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @01:10AM (#2326079)
I have a right to choose what I put in my body.^ Companies that make drugs have a right to sell what they make, as long as they don't lie or defraud me. Simply by doing what it was created to do, the FDA is violating my rights as a patient, as well as the rights of all of those whose rights give rise to the drug companies (i.e., employees and shareholders).

Suppose that a new regulation passed that eliminated off-label prescriptions. Many will agree that the suffering and death that would result would be immense. (Just ask anyone who has a friend or relative that's benefited from an off-label drug.) Yet off-label prescriptions fly in the face of what the FDA does. What's going on here?

What we choose to do when we're sick ultimately rests on each of us, individually. We all need to be free to do the research ourselves or to delegate this responsibility to whomever each of us has trust in (a particular doctor, for example). The inevitable consequence of losing this freedom is that far more of us suffer and die today than would otherwise.

The valid function of the FDA (valid insofar as it is a source of scientific information) should be performed by a private organization like Consumer Reports, which has a great deal of authority, but is completely independent of both companies and the government. Consumer Reports doesn't use violence or the threat of violence to back itself up: the one thing that keeps it in business is trust.

Certainly, Consumer Reports doesn't offer its products or services for gratis. But many people find the service valuable enough to pay, and with our bodies, the stakes are much higher. Most people will pay for such a drug-vetting service, either directly or through the professional they delegate health decisions to.

We all want safe drugs, and the market is capable of producing and selling safe drugs to us. All we need is to be left free (meaning that the government does one thing only: prevent force and fraud), and verification organizations that pride themselves on true independence will arise.

^This right over your own body really is absolute (so long as you're not hurting someone else). I don't use or advocate for the use of illegal drugs, but it really is no one's business but your own. Yaron Brook recently summed it up best when he said, "You know you're in trouble when you declare war on inanimate objects."

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by ramanujan on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:20AM (#2326423)
Indeed. The genomics community is currently very angry at the FDA, as a senior official (CDRH director Jeffrey Shuren) appears to have been caught red handed lying under oath:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=YI-m2Cucdoo

His stated rationale is that increased FDA regulation against startups will help the"traditional manufacturers". No, really. Watch the whole thing.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @04:16AM (#2326547)
I watched the whole thing. I think that most people would be shocked by the things Shuren and Latta said, if only they had heard them.

Thanks for posting this!

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by barrkel on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:55AM (#2326370)
That's all wonderful etc., but unfortunately it's Utopian pie in the sky which can never come to pass in a democracy. When people die owing to other people making mistakes, the people demand the government takes action, and it does, and there goes your libertarian wonderland.

To the downvoters out there: if you're serious about this problem, you need to live in the real world. That would be more productive.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:12AM (#2326410)
Well, that's why democracy must be limited by individual rights. Remember, an unlimited democracy voted Socrates to die when it ordered him drink hemlock. It was his punishment for "corrupting" the youths of Athens.

America was founded as a republic limited by a constitution, and it existed that way for a long time. It wasn't an unachieved pie-in-the-sky wonderland (nor was it perfect: I think the civil war was a just and necessary war).

You can make this world better. It's just a matter of understanding things well enough to argue rationally for the right thing. After all, how did the Rennaisance happen, or the American revolution? The people that lived then were just like you and I in this respect, and they didn't even have the benefit of the Internet to communicate.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by jpulgarin on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @06:06AM (#2326736)
How is this getting upvoted? It reads like an entry in the Atlas Shrugged essay contest.
Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @01:34PM (#2328500)
How is your statement any different from "I can't believe that several people don't agree with me"?

Or could it be that there really is something to these ideas? There is a strong intellectual foundation here, and while the novel you mentioned describes much of it, a much fuller explanation can be found in her nonfiction work.

As an intellectual movement, we're gaining steam. Here's a recording of a debate held in NY between Yaron Brook (aynrand.org) and Miles Rapoport (demos.org) just five days ago: http://www.archive.org/details/FirstPrinciples-Government_Wh...

Here's a link to the debate site (WNYC is New York public radio): http://www.wnyc.org/articles/its-free-country/2011/mar/02/de...

Right now, most people don't agree, but when they hear these ideas out out, they do realize that they constitute a respectable argument (and one that they haven't heard before).

Twenty years from now, our ideas will be mainstream in the sense that most people will have heard them and have some idea of what they are (and how they're different from conservativism and libertarianism). Obviously, people will never agree with everything that anyone has to say, but that isn't the point. The point is to get people to think about this stuff in a productive way. The more people that do that, the better.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by alnayyir on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:14AM (#2326259)
Stow the politics, this isn't the place for it. Take it to Reddit.

A few points:

1. Consumer Reports messes up, your dishwasher might break down before the end of the warranty.

2. A drug company messes up, hundreds, potentially thousands die or have their lifespans severely curtailed in terms of quality of life or length.

That's the last I'll say on it, the magnitude of what's at stake should be otherwise self-evident.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @02:17AM (#2326267)
The common case isn't the drug company messing up. It's that the FDA gets in the way of a new drug (stopping it forever in some cases), and the patient with the incurable disease dies because there is no legally available treatment. With the FDA, his right to pursue what remains of his life is sacrificed to the FDA's illusion of safety.

Human life is so important, and the needs of each individual body are frequently so diverse from one another, that we can't trust decisions like these to a one-size-fits-all regulatory body.

This is yet another case where ethics and politics is a life-and-death matter (and for more people than you'd ever care to think about).

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by barrkel on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:02AM (#2326394)
A death owing to a mistake by a drug company is worth at least 100 deaths owing to lack of drug innovation and experimentation. It's psychology in the large, and it's very difficult to counteract. It's simply much easier for the free media to demonize the evil profit-grubbing soulless corporations killing babies than an abstract notion of opportunity cost.
Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:23AM (#2326431)
I voted you up.

But I think that we can make a difference against ignorance, just by speaking up. In years past, I used to make the mistake of just being quiet when political or moral topics came up, just because I didn't think it would be of any use.

I don't think that's true any longer because I realized that if you can state your case clearly enough, and it's a rational position, at least some people will listen. You don't have to immediately convince everyone, or even the majority of people. Just making the correct argument shifts the debate toward a better direction, and that's a powerful thing.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by ramanujan on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:24AM (#2326433)
That's why you need to interview all the people who had family members die during the seven year average FDA induced lag between drug submission and clearance.

That dramatizes opportunity cost.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by ck2 on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:26AM (#2326440)
Big pharma screws up ALL THE TIME. They simply escape liability.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/12/29/60minutes/main7195...

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:39AM (#2326468)
This makes my point exactly. The cure is to oppose the FDA. (Copied from my post below, just like the OP.)

Immoral businesses love regulations because they provide huge barriers to entry for new competitors. Observe how GSK uses the FDA and other regulatory agencies to shield themselves. From the article you linked:

"GSK's manufacturing division has a strong track record of quality and compliance with current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP) requirements. Various regulatory agencies - including the FDA - conduct an average of more than 100 inspections each year at over 80 GSK manufacturing sites located in over 30 countries. The FDA has raised no material issues as a result of its very thorough inspections. ... GSK worked to bring the Cidra facility to a high level of operating performance that satisfied both GSK and the FDA."

We need to separate the state from economics, just like we separate it from church. Unscrupulous companies (not all of them are this way) use and promote regulations to keep their competitors down, and to escape legal reprecussions that they should properly face (just as your article demonstrates). Remember that Enron lobbied for strict price controls on rates charged for access to power grids. (http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/2002/04/orourke....)

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by ck2 on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @04:49AM (#2326597)
The solution is not to remove government regulation, the solution is a "death penalty" for corporations and prison time for dangerous decision makers in corporations.

That does not exist in the USA for ANY kind of industry, it's the nutshell of the problem for our entire country.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @05:05AM (#2326617)
I once interviewed with a company that wrote medical imaging software. He explained that if anything ever went wrong with their product, their CEO would end up in jail (his words), and I'd be fired. This is for a product that didn't drive any medical equipment, but is regulated by the FDA anyway. Needless to say, I didn't take the job!

Your proposal would kill the last ounce of innovation that hasn't been already crushed by the vast number of regulations already in place.

When someone is injured or their property is damaged, that's what civil courts are for. When someone is killed intentionally, or by many instances of negligence, we have criminal courts to see that justice is done. All we need is to eliminate the regulations that people (and groups of people) hide behind and let the appropriate court do its job. And in some instances, bad precedent has to be overturned. At any rate, this is a much better idea than legislating and regulating more (which is like trying to dig your way out of a hole.)

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by khafra on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @09:00AM (#2327220)
I'm confused as to why holding, say, Bayer responsible in criminal court instead of merely civil court for knowingly infecting thousands of people with HIV[1] would stop all medical innovation.

[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/06/03/health/main556653....

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:32AM (#2327942)
If this happened today, you wouldn't need to go after Bayer in this case, just the individuals at Bayer that are responsible. If John, Mike and Jane all belong to the same club, and Mike murders someone while in the bathroom at the club, do you collectively punish the whole club, or do you go after Mike? A corporation is not essentially different in this context.

In this case, it's up to a court to decide if people knew enough about HIV in 1984 and 1985 to make the right call. HIV had only been discovered in 1983, and that very little was known about it at the time. It's easy to look at this in hindsight and think badly of them, with everything we've since learned about it, but that's not the standard by which they must be judged because omniscience cannot be the standard of knowledge by which we judge anyone.

Putting people in jail outside of this context (e.g., when there isn't any evidence that they've done anything wrong) kills innovation because it severely punishes any risk-taking (which is another word for innovation).

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by Sisyphus_of_IT on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:37AM (#2332166)
But - a corporation is held to be a person. If your left finger pulls the trigger, the whole body is guilty.
Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:44PM (#2333012)
No.

A corporation is only a group of individuals. The individuals that constitute a coroporation have rights, and the corporation is simply a legally optimized recognition of those rights.

Remember, rights are negative, in that proper rights can only prohibit one from initiating political force (violence and fraud) against another. Proper rights do not impose obligations on anyone to create anything for anyone else, because that would be a form of slavery.

No sensible person has ever claimed that a corporation is the same thing as a person.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by khafra on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:15PM (#2333173)
> A corporation is only a group of individuals.

The wikipedia article on corporate personhood might make some illuminating reading: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood_debate

Unless you already know about it, and are minimizing it for rhetorical reasons. When natural persons break criminal law and go to jail, they are deprived of the product of their labor for a period of time. When a corporation breaks the law, whether you want to attribute that to "evil employees" or to an internal incentive structure which encourages profits above legality, some analogue of jailtime makes sense.

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by Sisyphus_of_IT on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:36AM (#2332156)
I believe the corporate death penalty has been a long time coming - there are several 'too big to fail' corps that should face this penalty
Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by ck2 on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:23AM (#2326432)
The thing is, big pharma escapes liability ALL THE TIME.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/12/29/60minutes/main7195...

Re:On the 100x Price Rise of a Formerly Generic Drug by maxharris on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @03:29AM (#2326450)
This makes my point exactly. The cure is to oppose the FDA.

Immoral businesses love regulations because they provide huge barriers to entry for new competitors. Observe how GSK uses the FDA and other regulatory agencies to shield themselves. From the article you linked:

"GSK's manufacturing division has a strong track record of quality and compliance with current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP) requirements. Various regulatory agencies - including the FDA - conduct an average of more than 100 inspections each year at over 80 GSK manufacturing sites located in over 30 countries. The FDA has raised no material issues as a result of its very thorough inspections. ... GSK worked to bring the Cidra facility to a high level of operating performance that satisfied both GSK and the FDA."

We need to separate the state from economics, just like we separate it from church. Unscrupulous companies (not all of them are this way) use and promote regulations to keep their competitors down, and to escape legal reprecussions that they should properly face (just as your article demonstrates). Remember that Enron lobbied for strict price controls on rates charged for access to power grids. (http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/2002/04/orourke....)