I think the most interesting market and the best predictor for eventual dominance may be neither China nor the US, but the rest of the world. Chinese companies like Alibaba are investing heavily in the South-East Asian tech scene, and this market alone has twice the population of the US. However, to date the market has largely been the domain of homegrown players (Grab, Gojek, Tokopedia, Lazada, Shopee etc) that remain basically unknown in the region.
India: Same, more drama.
Italy: Same, historically more corruption & drama. Elegance.
France: Same. More chic.
Their active military engagements and large nuclear arsenal make them perfect for that.
If one reads Anna Lee Saxenians "Cultural Advantage" and the "New Argonauts", you see a lot more missing pieces that are hard to replicate and cultural.
Even in the US, Route 128 was usurped by the culture from the SF Bay Area, which has spread to Seattle, Austin and NYC, but at the end of the day these markets are all extensions of the SF Bay Area not challengers presenting a new model detached from SF Bay Area culture, money and networks. Even strong international markets like Taiwan and Israel are extensions of the SF Bay Area.
I also would not discount the fact that all tech that matters globally ultimately is written by engineers communicating in English regardless of what country the engineer is from or resides in. That goes a LONG way to establishing tech dominance in the US. China would have to de facto move all its tech even within its borders to English first if they want to usurp that. Not that English guarantees success (see England and other English speaking countries), but it's absolutely a barrier for non-english speaking countries. Every programming language that matters has keywords in English and all the best learning materials are in English. Same for all other tech and science that matters outside of programming as well. All English.
This seems like FUD. Like it or not, China has made key contributions to industry standards including 5G.
I didn't say China wouldn't contribute. Chinese people have and they will. Just like people from many nations. And like people from many nations, they will contribute to things that extend the dominance of western institutions. After all the ITU is based in Geneva.
I'm not even from the US or Europe yet all my engineering contributions are here in the US. None of my contributions do anything for the country I'm from.
R U serious?
edit: I mean in the U.S. of A.
Is there something quantifiable you're referring to?
Your argument is true with most countries in general https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_Chinese. Are you saying Myanmar does a better job of putting talents to use than China?
The current administration seems to be trying hard to change this via travel bans etc. The one actually good idea that Trump floated in his campaign was meritocratic points based immigration ala Canada, but it seems that topic got dropped in favor of more attention drawing stunts like the border wall.
> technology investment funds being used to further inflate the property bubble in disguise
Same thing in Silicon Valley, and to a lesser extent many other US cities with good tech jobs.
Employment based immigration has been up year on year for the past 5 years: https://travel.state.gov/content/dam/visas/Statistics/Annual...
Also your link is meaningless because the most common way to get an employment green card is by adjusting status in the US (from eg H1-B status to green card), not by getting an immigrant visa, but that table only counts immigrant visas.
this is one of the main ideas that Ted Cruz has promoted.
(I am talking about government and policies. I don’t have any problem with Americans actually and gave quite a lot of American friends).
By not treating me right I am talking about for example:
1) At that time they were talking about imposing tax for graduate students. That could have had devastating effect on grad student life.
2) Right now they are talking about removing OPT.
American tech dominance is also predicated upon having a huge domestic market that is relatively uniform in terms of the business environment and easy to navigate. Start here and you have access to 330M potential customers. This is something that the EU/EEA is only struggling to become: it's mostly still separate national markets there. China has the same advantage America had as well, and an even larger population to start with.
America has well-oiled financial markets that are good at allocating capital. In China it's the government doing the allocation, and the results have often been abysmal, e.g. technology investment funds being used to further inflate the property bubble in disguise. However, historically, many of the biggest technological breakthroughs in the US were associated with government-funded military projects. No reason why China could not replicate this in principle.
Not sure where the "American values" fit here, it depends what you mean by that. If you meant entrepreneurial spirit and individualism then the Chinese are entrepreneurial and individualist too. If you mean liberty/freedom then these aren't only American values but more broadly the values of the European Enlightenment, and this is indeed another differentiator between China and the cultural West. Would be interesting to know what values you had in mind.