News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by olivermarks on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:06PM (#23217120)
'Some believe that it is access to NHS data, among the most lucrative data sets in the world, that is the real attraction here'.

...“We must beware Palantir – and any other data mining company – bearing gifts during a pandemic,” says Ioannis Kouvakas, legal officer at Privacy International.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by instagraham on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:29AM (#23219377)
This is the most IRL Lord of the Rings dialogue I've ever heard
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by prox on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:25AM (#23219793)
“Not everyone in Palantir is accounted for, we don’t know who is watching!” - Gandalf probably
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by v4dok on Monday May 18, 2020 @05:01AM (#23220077)
Or a Privacy guy in UK. Could be both nowadays.
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by jackpeterfletch on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:10PM (#23217146)
TBF - NHS barely has access to NHS data, so good luck with that.
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by lmeyerov on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:14PM (#23217175)
Yeah the bigger issue is similar to US Health and Human Services, where the basic consulting model was to take ownership of the core data pipelines & tools and ultimately own the org's data future. We basically don't engage with any org where palantir bought out the decision making. IMO most CIO/CTOs are losing the long-term relevance of their parents org if they give away their data future.

Not just a problem with Palantir; the biggest consulting orgs all lobby hard to displace internal ownership with themselves. Nowadays often a revolving door. Where NHS is on that journey, no idea.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by nojito on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:56PM (#23217392)
US health data is very transparent and has been publicly available for years.
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by lmeyerov on Sunday May 17, 2020 @10:01PM (#23217413)
Some of it is, but unfortunately, not what I'm talking about. I'm less worried about spying (funny enough, I bet Palantir has better data privacy than most orgs) and FOIAs and more about IT collapse based on the digital transformation strategy lobbying.

US gov data pipelines are often managed by big private contractors, and in cases like Palantir, build them as well. The result is lock-in that's way worse than say Oracle DB's: both the DB + SW + projects end up owned by the contractor. Ex: a gov team once had to sue Palantir for the ability to get interop across some data/projects. Having been involved in seeing how sw gets selected, once a big consulting firm (and worse, one with custom sw) gets in, they grow and its hard to do anything that's not them. They bring in quick digital transform, but with the side-effect of slowly suffocating the org.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by nojito on Monday May 18, 2020 @09:43AM (#23222180)
Most if not all of the useful data is publicly available.

It’s just painful to collect, organize, and make use out of.

Which is why there are always startups and companies like palantir that come along once in a while before the us realizes they are a waste and moves on.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by lmeyerov on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:07PM (#23227000)
That's not true at all:

- data: most data for anything at the level for fraud investigations isn't open, open is very coarse. Operational is generally closed.

- tools: these orgs then own the tools ecosystems, which further completes practical low-level layers of the lockin

I'm not sure why the effort to misrepresent, or maybe you come from a special use case..

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by PaulWaldman on Monday May 18, 2020 @12:50AM (#23218479)
They may have access to it, but how can they monitize it beyond services directly for the NHS? Is it wrong to assume that just having access to the data does not mean Planatir can use it to benefit parties other than the NHS?
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by madaxe_again on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:26AM (#23219361)
Based on the parties involved here, it’ll be used to control the outcome of elections to ensure the Tories keep in power forever. The guy running it, Mosley, is the grandson of Oswald Mosley - founder and leader of the British Union of Fascists - “Hooray for the blackshirts” and all that. He’s a “Tory activist”, which basically means he would like to see a fascist white ethnostate. I’m not exaggerating. This is who the Tories have become - the party of brexit, of isolationism, of eugenics, of corrupt in-dealing, arbitrary justice, and “hostile environments”.

Literally every name in there is someone associated with the far right.

There’s also prior form to this end - see the as yet unresolved and probably never to be resolved hoo-hah over Cambridge analytica.

This smells like Cummings and his gang.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by chimprich on Monday May 18, 2020 @05:26AM (#23220226)
I'm a lefty so perfectly open to believe bad things about the Tories, but this criticism is ridiculous.

> The guy running it, Mosley, is the grandson of Oswald Mosley

Sharing about a quarter of your genes with a leading fascist from two generations previously in a very different social and cultural time doesn't mean you're a fascist yourself. To say that who your grandfather was defines your views is a kind of genetic fascism itself.

A quick look at his Twitter feed shows retweets of Guardian articles and Labour MPs' posts. Hardly definitive, but he doesn't look like an extremist.

> He’s a “Tory activist”, which basically means he would like to see a fascist white ethnostate.

I'm sure there are a great many Tory activists with unpleasant views, but this doesn't follow at all.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by Angostura on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:53AM (#23219561)
> I’m not exaggerating

He said, exaggerating.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by madaxe_again on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:09AM (#23219680)
No. I went to school with plenty of the clade now in power - one is a cabinet minister, another just an MP, others are Tory activists or were Tory MPs until the last election. The cabinet minister was the most profoundly racist and bigoted person in my year. I won’t repeat the kind of slurs he routinely came out with here, but I will say that he was kicked out of history, repeatedly, for saying “they got what they deserved”, when discussing the holocaust. The MP was suspended for a term for sexual assault. Yes, that’s anecdotal, but it speaks of the character of the type of person attracted to their ideology.

In more concrete terms, if you look at what is being said, privately and publicly, what is becoming policy, which dead cats are being thrown at the press, it is extremely worrying.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by Angostura on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:10AM (#23219686)
Feel free to name names
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by madaxe_again on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:14AM (#23219714)
I like breathing, so no.

My godfather spoke out against them a few years ago when told to preside over a secret court. They destroyed him through the press. Cameron went on national TV to condemn him for being a paedophile apologist, when he’s absolutely no such thing, and the court transcripts from the supposed incident clearly show that the remarks ascribed to him were actually made by a police constable. His wife committed suicide in the aftermath, and his children fled the country as they were being threatened by the public and hounded by the gutter press. He is a shadow of the man he was.

So no. I won’t name names.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:31AM (#23219842)
I can't find any relevant comment by cameron accusing/condemning anyone for being a 'paedophile apologist'. Or anyone being a godfather so accused. It's difficult to evaluate such accusations without more info, but it's equally important to know this stuff if what you say is accurate. These are very serious claims indeed.
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by jacobush on Monday May 18, 2020 @06:13AM (#23220517)
That incident, putting aside for a second whether it was right or wrong to so publicly and forcefully condemn him - there certainly would not have made much difference if Cameron would have mentioned it or not.

The prosecutors wording and presentation was ill-advised and he would have get gotten a lot of flak regardless.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by RobertKerans on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:26PM (#23227241)
"far right" and "literally" breaking free of the constrictive confines of dictionary definition in some style there
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by jjgreen on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:54AM (#23219566)
"Hurrah for the Blackshirts" was actually a piece in the Daily Mail

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rothermere_-_Hurrah_...

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by madaxe_again on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:05AM (#23219649)
Yes, writing about Oswald Mosley and his Blackshirts.
Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by harryf on Monday May 18, 2020 @05:16AM (#23220161)
There's been rumours of the NHS being privatised and that the UK adopts a more US based healthcare model - https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/dec/11/nhs-us...

Having access to NHS data could potentially help you do things like;

- build lists of potential customers to target with insurance - combined with their medical histories you can assess who the profitable customers might be - that you could sell nicely to insurance companies

- identify how drugs and treatments are being priced and used - useful market data if you want to launch drugs on the UK market that might be competing

- identify which parts of the NHS are valuable / profitable as part of selective privatisation - what's worth buying in other words. Leave the unprofitable parts un-privatised...

I'm sure there's plenty of money to be made selling that kind of data.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by cturner on Monday May 18, 2020 @07:29AM (#23221042)

    There's been rumours
The notion that anyone is steering the UK towards the quirky US model is simple fear-mongering.

Even the partisan article you cite only talks about privatisation of elements of the NHS.

A mixed public/private health care model can be effective policy. The Australian system serves as an example of this.

The NHS is an inefficient mess, despite the efforts of so many of its staff. It is reasonable that we should be able to debate policy models. The tone of the Guardian article does not assist reasonable debate.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by DanBC on Monday May 18, 2020 @08:21AM (#23221410)
We already have a mixed private / public model. Billions of the NHS budget is spent on NHS patients in private providers.

> The NHS is an inefficient mess

Mostly caused by the incoherent Lansley reforms and years of austerity from Hunt.

Re:How Palantir embedded itself in the NHS by grey-area on Monday May 18, 2020 @01:56AM (#23218859)
Sell the data to spy agencies?