Re:Neofeudalism: The End of Capitalism?
by abdullahkhalids on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:59PM
(#23216321)
Haven't personally seen you do a critical takedown of an unsubstantiated comment before, rather than a polite reminder of the rules.
Its good. You should it do it occasionally to remind people that you know your stuff.
Over the past decade, “neofeudalism” has emerged to name tendencies associated with extreme inequality, generalized precarity, monopoly power, and changes at the level of the state.
This seems sound. I paused at "precarity" but it's obviously a reference to economic insecurity. The only thing I can really fault this sentence for is that "changes at the level of the state" is vague. I'd hope that the article delivers on that with some details later, or else this bit shouldn't be there. (Edit: though...the other three things sound more like 19th century capitalism than feudalism.)
You guys need to do a better job of critique. Denunciatory dismissals are what we don't want on HN; they're cheap, nasty, and uninteresting. Note the site guideline: "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
In case anyone's worried: I'm not siding for or against the article ideologically. I don't know if I agree or disagree with it; I don't even know what it says. I just know that (1) it clears the bar for an interesting discussion; and (2) commenters also need to clear that bar, or not comment. It's not that high a bar!
If you don't like that I'm saying this about a left-wing article (which I guess this is?), there have been just as many right-wing ones we've treated the same way. Every time it happens in either direction, someone assumes bias, since on the internet, any data point is dispositive.