News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by noad on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:48PM (#23197202)
Amazon and Facebook should be next. Break them all up with extreme prejudice and put strict new anti-trust laws around acquisitions in place for the future.

We're going to do this and open technology back up to innovation and progress, or just watch the tech giants continue to grow in power and abusiveness year after year while new startups continue to decline.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by yowlingcat on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:29PM (#23197685)
Ah yes, tech is the industry with the most insidious monopolies, not oil, telecom, or defense. And surely, the current government will enthusiastically move forward with the actual /legwork/ (rather than saber rattling) of killing its goose that lays the golden egg.

Let's be real here. None of these megacorps are getting broken up any time soon. We haven't had a trustbuster in office for a very long time. The megacorp/lobbyist/politico triopoly has ruthlessly, slickly snuffed out any perceived opposition for quite a long time.

[dead]
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by dang on Friday May 15, 2020 @07:38PM (#23198806)
Please keep canned arguments and name-calling off HN. It leads to much lamer discussion.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by md_ on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:11PM (#23198119)
I’m not sure that’s inherently disqualifying. When it comes to questions of law and justice, it seems entirely reasonable to ask about similar cases, simply to investigate the equal and fair application of law, no?

“Whatsboutism”, as I understand it, is a technique where one brings up ill-proven allegations that are unrelated to the matter at hand merely to distract.

Here, the claim seems much more on point: it’s that this is a political case, as shown by the failure to pursue similar cases against other companies.

(Is it? I don’t personally know. But it seems like a fair point to make.)

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by gfodor on Friday May 15, 2020 @07:00PM (#23198511)
Law especially at the federal DOJ level is as much about which cases to pursue as it is about what cases have merit. Either no monopolists should be prosecuted or a select subset worthy of the opportunity cost should be. How big the subset is a question, and the proper subset could be zero, but it's not a contradiction to see selective enforcement of anti-trust. The opposite, where many big, massive cases are opened on many fronts simultaneously is almost never the methodology of federal law enforcement afaict.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by md_ on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:27AM (#23201509)
Sure, but the claim here wasn't (as I read it) that this is unusual, but that it's unjust.

If prosecutors are selecting the highest ROI targets based on some calculation of which cases they can win and which cases have the biggest consumer or market impact (or are most egregious), that doesn't seem especially problematic. If they're selecting targets for prosecution based on who has political connections and who does not, however, that's very different.

Taken to the extreme, it's "whataboutism" to ask about racial disparities in criminal prosecutions; if a defendant is guilty, who cares if some other accused perpetrator of a different race wasn't prosecuted for a similar offense?

The impartial application of law--at least with respect to considerations like race or political connectedness--can certainly conflict with the pragmatic considerations of prosecutorial strategy, and I don't think it's simply "whataboutism" to question that tension.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by gfodor on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:51PM (#23205599)
Well, the burden of proof seems to be on the person making claims going after big tech vs other industries is politically motivated. I would prefer the DoJ step in to take actions against companies that are abusing their power to massively violate the world's privacy through surveillance systems which have unimaginable capabilities for shaping global human behavior. It's hard to think of a more worthy target of anti-trust law than the companies which are poised to control the minds and behavior of billions due to their market power.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by md_ on Sunday May 17, 2020 @03:37AM (#23210370)
Agreed. But I read the parent’s comment as being about the legitimacy of such a claim itself—that the claim of political bias is not merely lacking proof but “whataboutism” and thus illegitimate or irrelevant, even if proven. :)

Of course one might view these cases as legitimate, and bemoan that similar prosecutions don’t happen against companies in other industries, as well. The effect of political bias may be to suppress cases that should be brought, not to bring cases that shouldn’t be.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by filoleg on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:24PM (#23198229)
no, it isn't. The parent comment isn't saying "but what about those other things we should break up just because?". It is saying "you make it sound like breaking up big tech will accomplish a lot, even though, I think, breaking up those other things is a way higher priority that will accomplish much more, and here is why".
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by yowlingcat on Friday May 15, 2020 @07:09PM (#23198577)
100%. When I look at the level of regulatory capture from pharma (which I neglected to mention, sorry!), oil, defense and telecom, as well as the slickness that they engage with optics through PR, all I can say is that the way forward is anything but easy.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by yowlingcat on Friday May 15, 2020 @07:04PM (#23198538)
> Whataboutism, also known as whataboutery, is a variant of the tu quoque logical fallacy that attempts to discredit an opponent's position by charging them with hypocrisy without directly refuting or disproving their argument.

Oh?

You see, I was not charging the OP with hypocrisy. To the contrary -- I think that the desire makes sense and would be nice to see happen. But I just wonder about how the messy details of that would work. I mean, we have certainly failed to break up other industries because they compromised the antitrust apparatus through regulatory capture. To not engage with the elephant in the room of regulatory capture (when talking about antitrust) is to not talk about antitrust at all.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by ghastmaster on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:59PM (#23197331)
Ever wonder why innovation takes place? Wonder why we are not still reliant on locomotives for transportation?

Economic incentives for innovation and disruption are greater when a monopolistic entity is over charging for it's good or service. If they are not over charging then there is not as great an incentive to innovate or disrupt. If the latter is the case, why bust a monopoly that is providing a fair service?

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by eshamukhamedov on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:18PM (#23197551)
> Economic incentives for innovation and disruption are greater when a monopolistic entity is over charging for it's good or service.

Care to back that up, or are we supposed to take your, frankly, very unorthodox views at face value? Every industry I can think of with entrenched monopolies sees almost no innovation until things get so bad that they are finally disrupted: aerospace, energy, advertisement, telecommunications, and the list goes on and on.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by SamReidHughes on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:38PM (#23197796)
Amazon doesn’t really “have” a monopoly. Walmart just can’t compete online, but it’s because they suck, not because of a structural force stopping them.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by ghastmaster on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:56PM (#23197969)
> Every industry I can think of with entrenched monopolies sees almost no innovation until things get so bad that they are finally disrupted: aerospace, energy, advertisement, telecommunications, and the list goes on and on.

Intel's virtual monopoly of microprocessors has led to AMD's recent advancements: https://seekingalpha.com/article/4247790-intel-vs-amd-battle... https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-vs-intel-cpu-market-sh...

Check out the historical market shares in the links. Markets have changed in time with respect to computing. People are opting for mobile devices which use arm processors(even breaking into server space). Unless the behemoths in the industry adapt, their industry may not exist in the future. That is innovation and disruption happening right now.

Intel had in 2018 90.4% of the desktop/notebook/server market with 96.8% of the server market share. Maybe this is only Intel vs. AMD stats. Are servers run with other processors?

Standard oil(Arguably the most notorious monopolistic company in the history of the United States) by comparison: "At one point, it was believe that they controlled somewhere between 88% to 91% of all the oil in the United States"

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:50PM (#23197913)
> Wonder why we are not still reliant on locomotives for transportation?

Railroads still are. If you mean transport in general, it's because the government build a huge number of roads, waterways, and airports.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by ghastmaster on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:19PM (#23198186)
Good point. I did mean for commercial goods transport, but did not make that apparent.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by ascotan on Friday May 15, 2020 @07:13PM (#23198602)
Maybe I'm lost here but why is this a good thing? and what this is providing for the consumer. I am not harmed by Google price fixing (as far as I know) because I pay them exactly $0, nor do I want to see the days of the 90's again, when you needed a 'metacrawler' to search a bunch of search engines. Now if we were talking about my ISP, for which I have exactly 2 choices and both of them collude to increase my bill, then we'd be talking.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by jlbnjmn on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:47PM (#23199336)
> I am not harmed by Google price fixing (as far as I know) because I pay them exactly $0

You're not a Google customer. Advertisers are the customers. Your attention is the product.

Again, anyone who does not get an invoice from Google every month is not a customer.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by pb7 on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:06PM (#23197398)
Break them up into what?
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by maxwell on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:17PM (#23197536)
"Facebook could be forced to get rid of Instagram and WhatsApp, Amazon might divest Zappos and Whole Foods, Google may lose YouTube, and Apple could part with its App Store."

https://www.cnet.com/news/momentum-grows-to-break-up-big-tec...

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:30PM (#23197691)
> Amazon might divest Zappos and Whole Foods

Amazon Freight, AWS and marketplace, if one wishes to keep going.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by hannibalhorn on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:20PM (#23197576)
In Amazon's case, there's actually a lot of shareholders that would like to see AWS spun off into a separate business.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by adventured on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:19PM (#23197555)
If you were going to bother, you'd split Amazon and AWS. Amazon becomes mostly a retail company again. Without the AWS subsidy margins, they'll be down to retail margins and the ad business (with ads, it's plenty). They can perhaps keep the gadgets, splitting every major aspect apart might be going too far.

AWS is a $400 to $600 billion market cap company right now if it were trading on its own, based on its operating income and the insatiatable market demand for anything cloud. The ticker is even available conveniently. They'll get to $150+ billion in sales and $25+ billion in operating profit in the next six to seven years (average of 21% annual growth over seven years; very much within reach). It might approach being a trillion dollar company a decade from now (at MSFT type multiples).

You'd split Facebook and Instagram as the most obvious separation line (and then do something with WhatsApp, it can be spun off or go with either or; FB already has messenger, so it probably shouldn't go with that entity).

Instagram is a $100+ billion publicly traded company on its own plausibly. There is some question on erosion in both FB and Instagram once you detach them from eachother. They both lose a huge protective moat and cross promotion (Instagram has become a lot more mature at this point, it'll be more at risk to userbase erosion going forward, versus say five years ago; and FB is definitely at high risk for userbase erosion with fewer moats).

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by Mountain_Skies on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:34PM (#23197745)
They could also spin off Amazon's patent portfolio into its own company that would license the patents back to Amazon and anyone else who wants to compete in the ecommerce market.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by laluser on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:51PM (#23197915)
I think the sum of the parts would end up being worth more than the single entity. Which would make Uncle Jeff worth even more. Not that I care.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by missedthecue on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:47PM (#23198420)
Happened with Rockefeller so probably
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by burkaman on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:26PM (#23197641)
AWS, Amazon Studios, Amazon the online marketplace, Amazon the producer of goods sold on that marketplace, Whole Foods, Ring, Twitch, whatever else they own
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by Infinitesimus on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:57PM (#23197982)
I don't think all of those will be viable businesses on their own without VC money will they?
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by burkaman on Saturday May 16, 2020 @12:02PM (#23204543)
AWS is Amazon's most profitable division.

Amazon Studios would be the same business model as any other independent TV/film production company.

Amazon marketplace operates on very slim margins to stay competitive, but it's hard to believe it couldn't be profitable on its own. Maybe it would have to settle for slightly less universal domination.

Many businesses make money by exclusively selling through Amazon, so there's no reason they couldn't spin off a profitable business that sells Amazon Basics and whatever other store brands they produce.

Whole Foods is obviously a viable business.

I doubt Ring was profitable but it was clearly capable of getting VC money on its own. If it can't be a viable business, why did they start it? And why did VCs invest in it?

Twitch was profitable before acquisition.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by lucio on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:14PM (#23197494)
Maybe just force all social apps to a standard data migration format, and an easy UI to move, so you can move you data freely
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by mrep on Saturday May 16, 2020 @09:33AM (#23203243)
FYI, there is a project for that [0] of which Apple, Facebook, Google, Microsoft and Twitter are a part of. It's not forced and is still in development but it's something.

[0]: https://datatransferproject.dev/

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by blululu on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:34PM (#23197742)
Consider that Facebook has 3 different messaging apps, and Google has an unknown number of messaging apps. Both companies have strong internal incentives to consolidate their own messaging apps and yet these efforts have never succeeded. I'm not sure if having a single universal protocol is the best idea.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by glenstein on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:35PM (#23197755)
I was with you until the last sentence which I didn't understand.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:49PM (#23197896)
I believe the idea is that, if those companies can't do it, even though they want to, then it may be hard to do (or at least to do well/cleanly). Requiring it to be done may therefore be a bad idea.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by tombert on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:11PM (#23197465)
Well conceivably you could separate out the Facebook ad network and the Facebook social media, and possibly also maybe the IM systems (FB Chat/Whatsapp).

I know virtually nothing about antitrust law, and I'm not a lawyer, so I'm speaking largely out of my behind, but those seem like logical-enough divisions.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by pb7 on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:15PM (#23199072)
How would Facebook social media exist on its own with the ad network paying for it?
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by jlbnjmn on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:51PM (#23199366)
The ad network is for ads on partner sites, not on Facebook itself.

It's Facebook's version of Google's DoubleClick.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by walterbell on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:13PM (#23197490)
Some units are already separate companies below a holding company.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by a9entroy on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:54PM (#23197949)
What will breaking up Google accomplish? I think the individual orgs inside Google already act as separate businesses. So they are already split internally.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by jm4 on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:16PM (#23198160)
In my opinion, Microsoft became a much better company after their brush with antitrust. I don’t know how much had to do with the case and how much is just because of the quality leadership they have now, but I hope Google becomes a much better company in the future. They went from having great products to downright creepy and it’s difficult not to use any of their products or to be tracked by them. I’d like to see a different Google.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by tyingq on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:11PM (#23198123)
As one example, Chrome might act differently if it were separate from Google the advertising/search giant.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by mthoms on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:43PM (#23198383)
According to wiki, Google Shopping is now run entirely separate after a case in the EU (though it's not clear if that's just in Europe or not).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_vs._Google#Goog...

I think it's a good start. All ancillary Google businesses outside of search/ads should be required to run at arms length IMHO.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by riku_iki on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:16PM (#23199515)
If you split all datacenter operations into separate company (Alphabet Cloud), Search and Ads will not receive access to cheap resources on significant discount, but will pay fair market price, which is a big burden for other companies trying to enter the market.
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by throwaway4715 on Friday May 15, 2020 @06:42PM (#23198379)
What is Facebook a monopoly in?
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by nojito on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:23PM (#23197610)
How so?

Google is infinitely worse than Amazon and Facebook put together.

They just so happen to be an advertising company so they internet doesn't know about it yet.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by snazz on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:27PM (#23197655)
> Google is infinitely worse than Amazon and Facebook put together.

> They just so happen to be an advertising company so they internet doesn't know about it yet.

Could you share your reasoning for coming to that conclusion?

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by nojito on Monday May 18, 2020 @01:15PM (#23225288)
Sharing and collecting data to share between business entities with no firewall between the two unlike Amazon and Facebook.

Clandestine support of privacy researchers to publish favorable content.

Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by ianmobbs on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:27PM (#23197660)
Why do you say Google is worse than Amazon and Facebook put together?
Re:Justice Department, states likely to bring antitrust laws... by nojito on Monday May 18, 2020 @01:18PM (#23225325)
The amount of data that Google has on you is immeasurable. The fact that there is no firewall between Google business entities in terms of data sharing is absolutely insane.

They have normalized the concept of sharing your data to the internet and monetizing it. At least Facebook and Amazon are accountable for their actions.