News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by mbesto on Sunday March 13, 2011 @11:13AM (#2319330)
Hmmm, in the context of modern day tech companies, you could only come up with 37signals?

Facebook, Groupon, Google, Dropbox, Mint, Heroku...dare I go on?

The methodology goes beyond just web tech companies and I'm afraid us in the tech industry fail to see that. Xerox once was a "lean startup".[0]

[0] - http://tbmdb.blogspot.com/2009/12/business-model-example-xer...

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by ConceptDog on Sunday March 13, 2011 @12:46PM (#2319555)
Zynga.

Zynga continues to implement Lean with it's products. They don't develop any new feature in any product without concrete proof of user interest. Put up the "store" sign, make it clickable, if enough users click it, develop the feature.

Simple, straight forward, validated.

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by mattmanser on Sunday March 13, 2011 @01:28PM (#2319677)
I think you're misunderstanding what a lean startup is.

Google: They built the product first and scaled massively before they had a business plan. Not a lean process.

Facebook: Product first and scaled massively before they had a business plan. Not a lean process.

Dropbox, Mint, Heroku, I can't comment but I suspect you're massively misunderstanding what a lean startup is.

A lean startup is not starting in a garage on a shoestring, it is poorly named. The point of a lean startup is to identify a profitable product using a very low burn rate. Google and Facebook's burn rate was massive. It is a methodology, finding a winning product by using an iterative feedback loop of customer, prototype, adoption. Only once you have a profitable product that provably sells do you scale. That is definitely not Google or Facebook.

This diagram illustrates the concept:

http://steveblank.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/lean-startup-2...

Again, that does not at all describe the process that Google or Facebook went through. I'm not spending time researching the other companies you mentioned but for example I'm pretty certain Dropbox was written without the first three stages, so again can't be classifed as a lean startup.

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by mbesto on Sunday March 13, 2011 @02:52PM (#2319905)
Actually, I'm not at all.

>It is a methodology, finding a winning product by using an iterative feedback loop of customer, prototype, adoption.

Ok fair enough.

Google: What were gmail, gmaps, gdocs doing in BETA for several years?

Dropbox: You do realize the online course on the lean start-up uses dropbox as an example right? http://www.socrated.com/user_courses/226?content_item_id=168... (you have to click start learning first and then use this link to go directly there)

> I'm not spending time researching the other companies you mentioned but for example I'm pretty certain Dropbox was written without the first three stages, so again can't be classifed as a lean startup.

Which is why I'm shocked your comment is upvoted more than mine...

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by mattmanser on Sunday March 13, 2011 @04:33PM (#2320151)
Dropbox, fair enough, I didn't know they'd done that.

The big red flag for me was you calling Google and Facebook lean start ups when they weren't. I didn't have to do any research for that. Google's entire 20% thing flies in the face of lean methodology.

None of the other google prdoucts you mention are lean anyway, gmail was built for internal use and then made public. Gmaps and Gdocs were bought, so no lean methodology by Google there.

I'm also not sure what you mean about them staying in beta for so long? Google's beta's are practically meaningless. Was there anything special about them taking the beta off gmail?

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by mbesto on Sunday March 13, 2011 @08:06PM (#2320657)
I think we can both agree that bootstrapped companies != lean start-up.[0] Cool. However, it irks me that you think these largely successful companies didn't innovate based on lean principles and therefore couldn't be considered lean start-ups.

> I think you're misunderstanding what a lean startup is.

It also irks me that one of the most well-known cases of MVP/Pivoting discussed on HN has been by Dropbox, and yet you were completely unaware of it. I'm sorry if I'm coming off crass but the lack of research on your part doesn't help your argument. If I've goofed somewhere I'd like empirical evidence. It's important I understand this fully.

> The point of a lean startup is to identify a profitable product using a very low burn rate. Google and Facebook's burn rate was massive.

Really? When was the burn rate massive? From Steve Blank:[0] The key contributors to an out-of-control burn rate is

1) hiring a sales force too early,

2) turning on the demand creation activities too early, [1]

3) developing something other than the minimum feature set for first customer ship.

Google:[2]

1) Google hired their first head of sales nearly 7 months after it incorporates. I wouldn't really call that hiring a sales force (nor is one guy a force) too early.

2) AFAIK Google wasn't out there actively promoting with their 8 member team. They continued to develop the product.

3) I'm pretty sure there is nothing more minimal than this: http://web.archive.org/web/19981111183552/google.stanford.ed...

Gmap - Yes, they bought a very early staged mapping software and transformed it into their own. But it was very much the baby project of Lars, whom they acquired. They continued to reiterate through the development of it, with sometimes weekly, if not monthly updates.[3] Yet, the source of revenue for gmaps has continued to evolve (adwords, enterprise, premiere-api, and now featured listings)[4] gmail was built for internal use and then made public. And how is that not lean? They had zero burn rate and they developed a product with the minimum features for the first customers. CLASSIC case of lean principles, if not THE BEST.

Facebook:[5]

1) Did Facebook even need sales people? It spread word of mouth.

2) Read #1

3) "Membership was initially restricted to students of Harvard College, and within the first month, more than half the undergraduate population at Harvard was registered on the service."[5] - It literally was minimal for several years. Do you know how many features they've added over the past 7 years? Too many to count, I could write a book on it.

Other notes: Facebook wasn't available to the mass public. You needed to have an EDU e-mail. They did a MASSIVE pivot making it public to anyone.

[0]- http://steveblank.com/2009/11/02/lean-startups-aren%E2%80%99...

[1]- http://www.quora.com/What-is-the-definition-of-demand-creati...

[2]- http://www.google.com/corporate/history.html

[3]- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Maps#Development_history

[4]- http://blumenthals.com/blog/2009/05/13/google-maps-developme...

[5]- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by 6ren on Sunday March 13, 2011 @11:46AM (#2319394)
"Disruption" often involves a low-cost business model, which fits with lean.

I'm intrigued by the Xerox example, because it seems like a disruption, but in fact it was much higher performing than the incumbent technology. It reminds me of how the iPhone beat the Nokia with a better product (instead of a worse one, which is usually how disruptions start).

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by ippisl on Sunday March 13, 2011 @08:21PM (#2320704)
Apple's disruptive path started with the ipod. they gained control a great supply chain , the itunes(and some basis for the app store) and it's users , a great mobile brand , and a lot of experience , which enabled them to execute well on the iphone.

In short , the path from the first mp3 , via the ipod to the iphone is a disruptive path. there's no motivation for nokia to compete , until it's too late.

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by krakensden on Sunday March 13, 2011 @12:24PM (#2319492)
> It reminds me of how the iPhone beat the Nokia with a better product (instead of a worse one, which is usually how disruptions start)

Unless you're measuring battery life ;)

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by fedd on Sunday March 13, 2011 @01:02PM (#2319612)
being lean helps us not die from unbearable debt and regret for wasting too much time of our lives, when we were wrong.

are these the examples of startups that when being early stage proved their concepts with minimum viable products, pivoted, failed, 'reiterated', etc?

maybe they were lean, but didn't they hit the right target from first attempt? (it's a question, not a statement)

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by mbesto on Sunday March 13, 2011 @01:23PM (#2319666)
I think you are misinterpreting "lean" with "bootstrapping". Being lean is a mindset that you don't put 100% of your resources and thought into believing that your first attempt will be successful (but it certainly can be the case). Just because a start-up gets it right the first time doesn't mean they aren't being lean. Lean is about developing the product/market fit during the development of the product/service.

Maybe it would be better discussion to talk about companies who aren't lean?

Re:If Lean Works, Prove It by fedd on Sunday March 13, 2011 @01:44PM (#2319730)
i agree; that's why i wondered if these examples (google, dropbox etc) would convince the blog poster that 'lean works'