News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by sremani on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:04PM (#23188416)
Welcome to USA. Smart Move TSMC and Taiwan. You have earned a friend for life.

For the doubters, this is just the beginning of Re-industrilization of America.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by megaframe on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:35AM (#23188937)
Re-industrialization of America*

*With extreme automation and minimal employees. Modern Fabs have very few assembly line employee's. They use positive pressure rooms, overhead rail car system, robotic arms, and machines drop down from the fab floor to a maintenance floor when a human is actually needed.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by modeless on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:31PM (#23188559)
The US has lots of advanced fabs already. This isn't the part of the supply chain we're missing. This does nothing to reduce our dependence on China for manufacturing.

Edit: and this isn't actually a cutting edge fab. By the time it opens in 2024 the cutting edge process will be 3nm or beyond.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by m0zg on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:24AM (#23188888)
There's no guarantee there will ever be "3nm and beyond".
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by huonpine on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:04AM (#23189059)
Any marketers know what happens once the 1nm name is taken? Dose it go negative, go to decimals, start counting back up or just a new naming convention?
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by brnt on Friday May 15, 2020 @03:38AM (#23189846)
I think we started speaking of nanometers around the 100nm point. Before that we had eg .25, .13 microns cpus. And that is of course where the microcomputer got its name, initially ICs had features of a few microns.

Of course, the angstrom being the size that it is (.1nm), makes it unlikely there ever will be another scale. Whatever is next, it won't be silicon.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by RandomTisk on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:15AM (#23189114)
I wouldn't shed any tears for the industry if some lawsuits got filed against misleading claims regarding transistor feature sizes. That probably won't happen because feature size isn't a spec requirement for anyone per se, but it would be nice to see on principle.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by noway421 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:17AM (#23189121)
Go down to picometre. 1000pm, etc.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by wallacoloo on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:40AM (#23189251)
But 1000pm looks larger than 1nm. How about “-3 nm”?
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by sremani on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:34PM (#23188593)
I understand, but fabs are realm of competition with China and their 2025 plan.

I am big fanboy of Robert Lighthizer, and with Phase 1 effectively ripped we are going to see a lot of moving things. May not happen immediately, first it will be slow then sudden.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by arcticbull on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:50PM (#23188714)
Fabs aren't really a realm of competition with China. Leading fabs are in Germany (GlobalFoundaries in Dresden), Taiwan (TSMC's primary fabs), South Korea (Samsung) and even the US (GlobalFoundaries) and Singapore (GlobalFoundaries).
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by wtallis on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:56PM (#23188745)
GlobalFoundries isn't really "leading"; they got out of that race a while ago and are now focusing all their R&D on niche fabrication technologies that aren't in competition for building CPUs, GPUs, or smartphone SoCs. And you didn't mention Intel, which is the only serious competition to TSMC when it comes to advanced fab technology for those kinds of chips.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by arcticbull on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:02AM (#23188768)
Yeah, I didn't mention Intel, I know they have fabs domestically but they're also moving to TSMC after 10nm [1] so I figured they were getting out of the game.

Good call-out re: GF.

[1] https://wccftech.com/intel-abandoning-10nm-after-dg1-plannin...

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by wtallis on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:08AM (#23188796)
That's a bullshit rumor from a bullshit site that you're misinterpreting anyways. Intel might plausibly use outside fabs for their new discrete GPU product line, but they are absolutely not getting out of the fab game in any meaningful way. They are capacity-constrained at the moment and don't really have room to make big GPUs in-house without subtracting from their manufacturing capacity for their well-established CPU product line.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by blahblah12 on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:08AM (#23188797)
That’s definitely not verified. I’ve read that rumor multiple times and each time, it hasn’t happened.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by fermienrico on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:06AM (#23188792)
Having worked in the semiconductor industry, manufacturing specifically, I can attest that this is a false statement - US technology in semiconductor manufacturing is not simply from running the fabs, but building fabrication equiment that fabs purchase to process and package wafers. The US (Teredyn, Applied Materials, Entegris, KLA Tencor, Lam Research), Netherlands (ASML) and Japan (Daifuku, Hitachi, TEL, Advantest) are the top leaders of the semiconductor equipment [1]. The ones I just listed account for over 90% of the semiconductor equipment.

Most of the deep tech in a fab is the equipment. The rest of the stuff is a giant box that's super clean and maintains that clealiness.

All of these Fabs[2] buy their equipment from the aforementioned companies.

Here is what an example supply chain looks like:

NVidia(US) has the IP and "soft" tech, they use software tooling(US) to make layouts, then contracts out the manufacturing to TSMC(Taiwan) who then buys their equipment from KLA/AMAT/LAM/TEL/ASML. TSMC(Taiwan) processes the wafers which are packaged at OSATS(OSATS are a collection of many companies[3]). The final product such as a graphics card is then further made accessible by writing insanely deep software driver stack (CUDA drivers for example) that are all developed by NVIDIA(US). For CPUs, there would be ISA and other "soft" tech involved which is Intel(US), AMD (US), ARM(UK, owned by Softbank(Japan)), Qualcomm, Broadcom, Microchip and Apple (all US, its a long list). I didn't even touch storage/memory. In addition to US, a lot of software and hardware talent and manufacturing comes from the EU, Germany in particular. I used to get on the call with a German company in the late morning and the Germans would be working their ass off at 9pm in Germany. We had an amazing team. It is not uncommon to pay $20k for a motor made in germany.

Somewhere in the middle to low end of the supply chain (motors, wires, connectors, may be even steel, copper, precious metals, chemicals) probably has Chinese involvement. You can imagine how a graphics card's supply chain gets very complex and deep.

Back to the central point - Semiconductor is a massive industry with complex supply chain. Depends on the level we are talking about. Also Global Foundries is not considered as among top dogs when it comes to semicon tech, although that's also debatable.

Edit: added tooling

[1] Source of the data (2011, old but still relevant): https://www.vlsiresearch.com/public/cms_pdf_upload/706001v1....

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_semiconductor_fabricat...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_device_manufacturer

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by Cyph0n on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:10AM (#23188815)
Good point about fab equipment.

The other side of the equation is EDA tooling, which is primarily US-based (Cadence, Synopsys, and Mentor Graphics).

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by remarkEon on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:43AM (#23188971)
Is there a document (or a book) somewhere that details who all these semiconductor equipment manufacturers are, and their history? I'm extremely interested in this space and would love to learn more about it.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by SXX on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:53PM (#23199375)
Here is one interview on history of Applied Materials which is largest equipment manufacturer out there:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7bwQxFyCs8Y

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by fermienrico on Friday May 15, 2020 @02:39AM (#23189567)
I don't know if there is one besides just Wikipedia.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by remarkEon on Friday May 15, 2020 @03:20AM (#23189766)
No problem, setting out on my own research expedition.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by dntbnmpls on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:23PM (#23188511)
> Welcome to USA. Smart Move TSMC and Taiwan.

They've operated in the US for a while now.

From the press release: "In the United States, TSMC currently operates a fab in Camas, Washington and design centers in both Austin, Texas and San Jose, California. The Arizona facility would be TSMC’s second manufacturing site in the United States."

> You have earned a friend for life.

What a bizarre comment. If they leave, are they your enemy for life then?

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by axaxs on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:57PM (#23188749)
> What a bizarre comment. If they leave, are they your enemy for life then?

I'm not sure that's fair. There's a lot of room between friend and enemy, here. When breaking up in a relationship under typical circumstances, the other person doesn't normally become an enemy, unless a person is not well adjusted mentally.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by masonic on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:13AM (#23189107)
Their Careers search engine shows zero jobs in all of USA (270 worldwide).
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by sremani on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:17AM (#23188855)
Thanks for making me aware of TSMC's existing foundry, I only thought they had design here.

As far as bizarre goes -- bizarre is better than boring!

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by splintercell on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:33PM (#23188580)
> If they leave, are they your enemy for life then?

(New) Relationship with strangers can be in one of the 3 categories:

- Neutral - Friend - Enemy

OP is moving the company into Friend category (from Neutral). I don't know what he'd do if they decide to move back, but if they declare the company as an "enemy" then that creates a perverse incentive where people in Neutral category would refrain from becoming friend because that risks them becoming enemy.

So to be prudent OP must move the company into 'Neutral' category again otherwise they won't get future 'Friends'

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by product50 on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:30PM (#23188550)
If you know anything about the geopolitics behind this, this was a forced move which TSMC wouldn't have otherwise done. If TSMC didn't do it, then US State Department would have funded Intel to produce their 5nm fabs here.

So yeah, educate yourself and then behave reasonably.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by dntbnmpls on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:34PM (#23188595)
> If you know anything about the geopolitics behind this, this was a forced move which TSMC wouldn't have otherwise done. If you know anything about the geopolitics behind this, this was a forced move which TSMC wouldn't have otherwise done.

I know. Where in my comment did I say otherwise?

> So yeah, educate yourself and then behave reasonably.

Okay, thanks?

Did you by any chance respond to the wrong comment? Such bizarre comments in this thread.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by x86_64Ubuntu on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:39PM (#23188631)
It's rampant nationalism all up and down this thread. Facts be damned.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by product50 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:08AM (#23189079)
What are the facts? That TSMC willingly and strategically made this move? The writing was on the wall on this one.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by ohyeshedid on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:52PM (#23188728)
What, exactly, is your own understanding of reasonable behaviour?
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by jlebar on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:33AM (#23189209)
> Welcome to USA. Smart Move TSMC and Taiwan. You have earned a friend for life.

Remember when Trump floated withdrawing from NATO?

Remember when Trump stopped funding the WHO in the middle of the worst pandemic of the past 100 years?

America First has no room for friends for life. Only friends for the moment.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by adventured on Friday May 15, 2020 @02:10AM (#23189408)
> Remember when Trump floated withdrawing from NATO?

I remember when Trump took no actions at all toward pulling the US out of NATO, and did nothing other than use it as a rather dumb prop to try to coax NATO allies into meeting their spending obligations.

> Remember when Trump stopped funding the WHO in the middle of the worst pandemic of the past 100 years?

I remember when the WHO cooperated with China to knowingly lie about the pandemic, including trying to forestall borders from being closed, trying to forestall the isolation of China, lying about the nature of the virus including the risk that it posed, and committed global genocide in the process.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by addicted on Friday May 15, 2020 @02:26AM (#23189491)
The US President lies on a daily basis.

And the previous president had already got the Europeans to commit to meeting their obligations over a period of a certain number of years which they were moving towards. Trumps nonsense achieved nothing other than making the Europeans and the rest of the world recognize that the US has become deeply unreliable and move further towards China.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by valuearb on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:21AM (#23193184)
European defense spending targets are laughably low, and their spending has been an embarrassment for decades.

A stopped clock is right twice a day, and sometimes an idiot gets an answer right. There is zero reason for any US troops to be in Europe or the US to remain in NATO. We’ve been burning our wealth for 70 years subsidizing European defense, and their economies.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by jlebar on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:06AM (#23189985)
>> Remember when Trump floated withdrawing from NATO?

> I remember when Trump took no actions at all toward pulling the US out of NATO

In times of peace, alliances exist only in rhetoric. NATO has strength only insofar as people believe that member states will come to each other's aid. Trump called his commitment to the treaty into question, and in so doing made the alliance less strong. Surely you see this.

>> Remember when Trump stopped funding the WHO in the middle of the worst pandemic of the past 100 years?

> I remember when the WHO cooperated with China to knowingly lie about the pandemic, including trying to forestall borders from being closed, trying to forestall the isolation of China, lying about the nature of the virus including the risk that it posed, and committed global genocide in the process.

I mean, if lying abut the nature of the virus or the risks it imposed was grounds for dissolving an organization, then surely the federal government and many state governments should be dissolved by now.

But for the sake of argument, let's stipulate that what you wrote was 100% correct.

The WHO does lots of things. Apparently one of them is facilitating "global genocide" (kind of harsh?). Another one is helping countries, rich and poor alike, survive this very disease we're stipulating it brought into being.

Is America or the world safer today because the WHO lost its biggest funder? What replaces it?

If we don't want the WHO being unduly influenced by China, how does defunding it advance that cause?

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by arcticbull on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:37PM (#23188615)
I don't really agree with any of the sentiment here...

> You have earned a friend for life.

The Trump administration has shown that "friend for life" means "for as long as I'm getting exactly what I want, or think I am, and otherwise you can see yourself out."

> For the doubters, this is just the beginning of Re-industrilization of America.

What benefit is there really? This fab will have about 5 jobs, and a bunch of robots who could be anywhere on earth.

I'm not sure this provides any more national security than a stockpile would.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by SlowRobotAhead on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:11PM (#23188461)
I’m not sure which brands TSMC makes for. But I can promise you if there is an option to buy an USA made AMD, I’d pay a premium for that.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by megaframe on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:31AM (#23188915)
Qualcomm/Broadcomm/Nvidia/AMD use TSMC

AMD does make chips in the US via their spun off Global Foundries, and so does Intel. AMD switched some production to TSMC because they had much better defect rates at 7nm. You can buy US made AMD today if you want it just won't be the latest GPU's.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by wtallis on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:10AM (#23189086)
> AMD switched some production to TSMC because they had much better defect rates at 7nm.

GloFo outright canceled their 7nm and smaller processes, back in 2018. All of AMD's leading-edge processors are now using TSMC 7nm, though the server and most desktop processors also incorporate a 12nm IO die. The days of AMD using GloFo are numbered.

Really, though, at this point it's easier to list what leading-edge chips aren't using TSMC: Intel's CPUs and FPGAs. All the other latest-and-greatest CPUs, GPUs, FPGAs and smartphone SoCs are made at TSMC. There's more diversity for memory manufacturing, and logic that doesn't need to be on a leading-edge process (eg. low-end smartphone SoCs, motherboard chipsets, SSD controllers).

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by remarkEon on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:15PM (#23188477)
Same.

"Manufactured by TSMC-USA in Arizona". Super exciting to be quite honest.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by arcticbull on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:41PM (#23188650)
> I’m not sure which brands TSMC makes for.

Basically all of them, to some extent.

> But I can promise you if there is an option to buy an USA made AMD, I’d pay a premium for that.

AMD spun off their own foundry years ago (GlobalFoundaries) and still uses the for some things.

FWIW though TSMC already has a US fab, but all their high-end processes are going to remain in Taiwan.

Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by valuearb on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:17AM (#23193127)
I always try to buy foreign, because free trade is what makes the US so wealthy.
Re:TSMC Announces Intention to Build and Operate Advanced Se... by rurban on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:30AM (#23188911)
Because you prefer US backdoors over Taiwanese backdoors? Sounds unreasonable to me.