For example, Chinese services are still available beyond the firewall, just not catered to the average non-Chinese.
To the consumer, most don't care, for most purposes; c.f. TikTok's popularity.
Facebook has also been working hard on their translation features to reduce language barriers.
It's not. US Population is maybe ~1/4th of India. Apple has a huge market in the US and is relatively niche in India.
Both France and California have a GDP of about 2.7 trillion USD. Interestingly, India's GDP is also at about this level.
Hasn't the same thing happened with respect to copyright in the other direction? Any online business with proper revenue already needs to abide by laws to take down copyrighted material, and the same arguments had been made when enforcement of them became a thing. I don't see that the burden with respect to hate speech is fundamentally different, arguably even lower.
We saw it happen with GDPR already. Though we also see many companies play ball with censors, e.g. in places like China. If suddenly a Winnie-the-Pooh cartoon is judged to be "hate speech", it's easy to just censor the cartoons. Most users won't exactly care, there's plenty of government-endorsed content that they're still allowed to access.
1. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3278912
If every country with an economy the size of 1 or 2 large US states start making up their own censorship laws and trying to force companies to enforce them, at some point this causes huge inefficiencies.
I can see two end states to this:
1. If the censoring country has enough international legal influence, companies will probably have to block users from that country from using their services.
2. If the censoring country does not have enough international legal influence, the company ignores them and the government has to explicitly censor its citizens' internet connections.
I kind of prefer the second because it's more visible and dramatic - I think a lot of people probably aren't even aware when their country has censorship laws.
This also creates economic opportunities for two classes of alternative content distribution:
1. Content distribution based out of legally friendly countries, a la the Sultanate of Kinakuta. Expect to see the media start using terms styled after "tax haven", like "cybercrime haven", for countries that don't enforce US/EU censorship/copyright laws.
2. Content distribution based off of peer-to-peer networks that are harder to wage lawfare against. Bittorrent, IPFS, etc. fit the bill here.