I totally agree with your dad. The HN community likes to dis Malcolm Gladwell (for example) but reveres Harari and Diamond. They’re creative smart people, with interesting and sharp ideas.
They like to lean on history or sociology to support their sharp instincts. Their books are good to get a sense for their instincts, and how they’ve occasionally played out through history. But you should never read them as an authoritative account of history or sociology, and you should not seriously consider their historical references to draw conclusions about the inevitability of the future.
I‘ve recently been reading primary sources of intellectuals living in Russia in the immediate months and years before WW1. None of them saw the war coming. None of them saw the revolution. Each of them made bold, evidence-based predictions about the near future, and they were all wrong. Same with (brilliant) Soviet economists in the 80s.
I recommend reading these books for fun if they please you, but please do not think that they’ve given you a comprehensive or correct view of history, even for the specific events they describe.
As a subject though it was badly taught in my youth (no idea if it’s improved).
We learnt about the Romans then basically nothing till the victorians and the WWII.
Might have perhaps been worth mentioning oh the empire in a UK school you would think.
It’s value is an inoculation against black and white interpretations of anything. This is good for free thinking, but arguably bad for people who want to influence you to think in black and white terms. Maybe that’s why our study of history in secondary school is so superficial! :) (just kidding)
In all seriousness, it’s really hard to cover history at the breadth of a primary and secondary school curriculum, and get to spend any time on depth. The curriculum seems more interested in arming us with superficial facts, than improving our way of thinking, but I’m sure it’s not the same everywhere.
Also bit of a sidebar, but the saxonizing of England, and the whole story of Oliver Cromwell and Scotland is so damn fascinating! It’s a shame they didn’t teach that. So many lessons to learn and interesting counterfactual thought experiments that teenagers would eat up. Although, I guess talking about nationally divisive topics isn’t super palatable. American classrooms are still trying to figure out how to teach slavery in 2020, and it’s been 150 years since emancipation.
For example, Polybius’ Anacyclosis. It originated with Plato and Aristotle, and Polybius codified it - and it influenced thinkers such as Machiavelli and Kant.
To a modern reader, or at any rate to this modern reader, it holds water.
Yes, there are counter-examples, but they seem to be vastly outweighed by examples which follow the form. See the French and American revolutions, the glorious revolution, the arc of the Roman Empire, for a few.
I would say (as an absolutely unqualified observer) that we (much of the world) are currently in an ochlocractic state, moving towards monarchies.
I’d be interested in his/your take on an idea that had persisted and influenced for several millennia - I wouldn’t call it a flash in the pan.
I mean obviously it is somewhat easier for a monarchy or a democracy to change in character (monarchy->tyranny) than in essence (monarchy->democracy), but a) that model doesn't account for changes in essence at all (especially not in the context of revolutions), b) there have been countless examples of monarchs that had to cede power instead of gaining it, c) I can't think of that many historic examples of actual mob rule that remained stable over a longer period.
More fundamentally, it's even questionable that we can come up with clear criteria to distinguish, say, monarchy from tyranny.
If you want to predict the future, your analysis should be about 98% detailed study of the present, and 2% history. Much as you would consult mostly this week's weather forecast when deciding to go for a picnic, but maybe adjust slightly based on historical error rates in weather forecasting.
The real usefulness of history research in prediction/policymaking often seems to be in debunking popular myths that shape/bias how we analyze the future and present. The conduct of the Iraq War, for example, was substantially a result of a popular American myth/narrative about how other cultures are, deep down, like us, and democracy is the equilibrium every society gravitates towards. In hindsight those are both obviously false, but at the time a lot of people believed them. Historians help identify and make us cognizant of those narratives.
can you please elaborate on this? it sounds like you're proposing the offensively wrong notion that the Iraq War was noble and well-founded, truly aimed at restoring democracy to Iraq, but went wrong because the Iraqi people are simply allergic to democracy
There's an assumption in what you're saying that the "Iraqi people" is a meaningful entity with a collective will that is expressed through collective action. We use that kind of thinking to reason about liberal democracies where there is a meaningful entity (a voting public with a storng shared national identity) and a mechanism (elections) for expressing preferences and a means (representative government, civil society) of taking collective action. It's not a very useful way to analyze a bunch of people who have none of those things.
My point wasn't that "Iraq is allergic to democracy." It was that thinking in terms of societies being drawn to or repulsed by democracy is an error in itself. The way to avoid those errors is to study lots of societies over a long period of time. That's where history helps you identify and understand the narratives and categories you unconsciously use to understand the world.
I think that Bush was sincere in his belief that bringing democracy to Iraq was a (if not the) primary goal of the Iraq War, and that doing so would be beneficial to the Iraqis. And I could believe that he felt a "white man's burden" and obligation that, because he could do so, he ought to do so.
[And to be clear: my belief is that the notion of "white man's burden" is incredibly racist and offensive, and I do not condone actions taken in such a manner.]
While I wouldn't call it "allergic to democracy", I can also entertain arguments that successful democratic regimes have preconditions for their success that Iraq simply did not have. I can even entertain arguments that democracy is not the best form of government, and it strikes me as mildly offensive to presume that democracy is automatically better than whatever form of government exists.
I think OP's point is that the Iraq War was undertaken in the [racist] belief that they were bettering the Iraqis by bringing democracy to them, and the failure is that, well, we were racist in the first place to believe that "bringing democracy" to another people is "bettering" them.
I believe that Bush probably stroked himself thinking this way, as did virtually the entire media and political class. However I don't think it was anywhere close to a primary goal, as you say. More to the point: their actual conduct in the war does not indicate in any way that this was a genuine goal as opposed to a piece of propaganda.
> While I wouldn't call it "allergic to democracy", I can also entertain arguments that successful democratic regimes have preconditions for their success that Iraq simply did not have.
Any citations for this notion? But to restate a point I made in another comment: the discussion of whether Iraq is ready for democracy is almost offensively inappropriate and nonsequitur, because the U.S. military does not aim to install democracy, it aims to install regimes that are friendly to U.S. military and business interests, regardless of the wishes of the local people who are governed.
To put it another way, we have no way of knowing whether Iraq is "ready for democracy" based on the Iraq War because the U.S. military did not act in a way to actually try to install democracy.
I don't recall if Why Nations Fail specifically covered democracy, but at the very least, you can definitely see why nations caught in the vicious cycles it outlines might suffer more because of democracy.
> because the U.S. military does not aim to install democracy, it aims to install regimes that are friendly to U.S. military and business interests
No. The US military does not aim to install any regime, it aims to defeat the enemy's military. That's the big thing of what went so horribly wrong in Iraq: the US kept pushing military solution after military solution to fix very-non-military problems and was confused as to why it didn't work.
If you look at U.S. foreign policy (covert and overt, CIA, military) over history, one consistent goal is to install regimes that are friendly to the U.S. and to topple regimes which are not. Defeating the military of the hostile regime can be part of that. But if that were it, then the U.S. would just leave once that had been accomplished, and that's not what happens.
The U.S. generally sticks around and tries to install a replacement, often undemocratically. On the occasion that they do implement democratic elections, any winner that is not sufficiently friendly to U.S. interests is undermined or even couped and a (usually right-wing) government is installed undemocratically.
Occasionally the U.S. will even undermine the democratic government of a country it hasn't even officially militarily engaged with, because the leader is threatening U.S. business interests. The history of U.S. relations with Latin America is littered with this type of illegal covert warfare, most recently in Bolivia with Evo Morales who was nationalizing natural resources that U.S. business wanted access to.
That is exactly what the US military planned with Iraq, Rumsfeld had outlawed any talk of Phase IV (nation building). The generals wanted out of there as quick as possible because they knew it would be a clusterfk regardless of Rumsfeld, Bush, Cheney thinking State, USAid and the UN would just manage Chalabi’s flowering democracy.
Of course, that fantasy lasted as long as it to blow up the UN HQ in Baghdad.
A racial purist would adopt one of two positions - invade and extract value - or don't waste our money on those people. It's true from the left side they see rightists but this is an optical illusion. It's as how I used to believe a democrats were secret Maoists.
They have 50% cousin marriage, which predicts high levels of clannishness and low support of democracy.
It looks like if you want to bring democracy to the middle east, you first have to stop cousin marriage then try again in a few generations time.
This would also reduce genetic disease and raise IQ. There are no charities or programs to pick this low hanging fruit as it's very un-PC to talk about this.
(Minor point: his wife Ariel was a co-author.)
Historians fill in a whole lot of gaps based on consensus acceptance of a narrative. There’s never an objective measure of reality. I can read the writings of the dead just fine if they’re in English. Thanks for your the context though, mr historian. How foolish of me
Not just a historian thing.
What’s that? They knew metal smithing and made hand tools? Because they exist? And they did song and dance?
Well those dead humans sure were a thing! Never heard of such a thing before now!
There's always two parts to his response:
1. $bigIdea is not a result of serious historical research; it's a reflection of laypeople projecting their preferred narratives onto history
2. literally dozens of counterexamples that he can cite on the spot from across different continents and historical eras
My takeaway: laws of history are the stuff of cranks and oversimplified history popularizations.