News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are There Laws of History? by Tainnor on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:56AM (#23190495)
How is the French revolution an example for this? That went from a somewhat absolutist monarchy (maybe we could call that "tyranny"? but the king never had sole power) to something that looked like it could have been a constitutional monarchy to mob rule relatively quickly, and then back to tyranny (and then back to monarchy, then to democracy, then to tyranny, then to democracy, then to occupation, then to democracy).

I mean obviously it is somewhat easier for a monarchy or a democracy to change in character (monarchy->tyranny) than in essence (monarchy->democracy), but a) that model doesn't account for changes in essence at all (especially not in the context of revolutions), b) there have been countless examples of monarchs that had to cede power instead of gaining it, c) I can't think of that many historic examples of actual mob rule that remained stable over a longer period.

More fundamentally, it's even questionable that we can come up with clear criteria to distinguish, say, monarchy from tyranny.

There are no comments on this comment yet.