News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Year of the Startup Default by pg on Saturday March 12, 2011 @10:02PM (#2318164)
No one could "rush out of the market" even if they wanted to. Adeo's article is about the case where the startup doesn't have the cash on hand to pay back the angel. At best (or rather worst) a panicking angel could get the startup's IP, and good luck selling that without the people.
Re:The Year of the Startup Default by cperciva on Saturday March 12, 2011 @10:16PM (#2318185)
You seem to be assuming that startups will run out of cash at exactly the moment that their convertible debt becomes due -- maybe this sometimes happens, but I can't help thinking that it would take exceptionally good planning (or a lot of luck).

I know there have been cases where startups have decided to shut down and return their remaining cash to investors (including some YC companies, I think); what happens in the case where a convertible debt holder thinks a startup should take that option but the founders aren't ready to give up?

Re:The Year of the Startup Default by pg on Sunday March 13, 2011 @01:18AM (#2318517)
In practice it usually amounts to that, because the term of a typical convertible note is a bit longer than the amount of time a typical funding round is expected to last.
Re:The Year of the Startup Default by cperciva on Sunday March 13, 2011 @11:34AM (#2319365)
Ok, but what if a company takes two rounds of convertible debt? Wouldn't the first one expire while the company is still burning through the second round?

Or is it standard practice when a company raises a second round of convertible debt to extend the maturity of the first round?

Re:The Year of the Startup Default by AdeoRessi on Sunday March 13, 2011 @02:28PM (#2319837)
Two rounds of convertible debt does not really happen, practically, since debt is the most senior security in a company. An investor doing more debt at a later point would not have much advantage over an investor that did debt in the first place. As a result, there is no premium for coming in earlier, when it is more risky. Early debt holders block issuing more debt, generally.
Re:The Year of the Startup Default by jedwhite on Saturday March 12, 2011 @10:21PM (#2318198)
As cperciva mentioned too, it's about the potential desire to cut losses and get out, and the damage that could do. I don't disagree that the Angels trying to cut their losses would get little back and there would be no value in rushing out. But in a panic logic is seldom the driver.

In your experience, would most startups survive if their angel investors with convertible debt wanted out, even if the cash wasn't there to repay it anyway and there were no tangible assets to sell?

Adeo's post reads to me as being a warning about the potential fallout in a context where people want out. I don't think there is much argument that the Angels wouldn't recoup much anyway. But neither is that the case when people sell public stocks that they've acquired at the top of the market when it hits the bottom. But even professional investors do that too with predictable regularity.