I know there have been cases where startups have decided to shut down and return their remaining cash to investors (including some YC companies, I think); what happens in the case where a convertible debt holder thinks a startup should take that option but the founders aren't ready to give up?
Or is it standard practice when a company raises a second round of convertible debt to extend the maturity of the first round?
In your experience, would most startups survive if their angel investors with convertible debt wanted out, even if the cash wasn't there to repay it anyway and there were no tangible assets to sell?
Adeo's post reads to me as being a warning about the potential fallout in a context where people want out. I don't think there is much argument that the Angels wouldn't recoup much anyway. But neither is that the case when people sell public stocks that they've acquired at the top of the market when it hits the bottom. But even professional investors do that too with predictable regularity.
YC companies are likely to be in a stronger position for debt to get converted or extended than most startups. They're more likely than the general market to be good quality companies in a stronger negotiating position, and Angels aren't likely to burn YC. Plus it's fair to say that they have the cream of Angel investors, who are likely to act in a reasonable way.
I think Adeo's argument is about what happens to the bulk of the market - so applies more to all the others. YC companies have been the exception to many a rule.
I hope it proves to be wrong. But if there is a panic/bubble-burst and a herd mentality develops to rush out of the market, it's reasonable to expect many individual angels will lose their nerve and want out, at least beyond the top end of the market represented by the YC startups.