News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by sliverstorm on Saturday March 12, 2011 @01:51AM (#2316226)
Can they not simply ship in extra batteries, or are they batteries too large to be moved?
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by ubernostrum on Saturday March 12, 2011 @02:21AM (#2316276)
Well. The datacenter across the street from my office has backup batteries which weigh in at half a ton apiece. Arranged in groups of eight.

And I'm betting they're positively puny compared to what you'd want for a nuclear plant's cooling system, so simply "shipping in" some extras may not be all that feasible...

Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by sliverstorm on Saturday March 12, 2011 @04:07AM (#2316425)
I'm sure they are large; I was thinking mostly that as 20% of Japan's energy and a nuclear reactor are on the line, they'd be able to move many tons of batteries. Also remember, modern cars weight 1.5-2 tons, and are carried in sets of 8-10 cross-country by truck.
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by cheald on Saturday March 12, 2011 @02:12AM (#2316257)
(insert bad joke about non-user-replacable iNuke battery here)

I rather suspect the batteries are not easily replaced - they're a tertiary system, designed to be a short-term stopgap to get your primary and secondary systems back online. I'm sure that if just cycling batteries was an option, and the battery systems are operational, they'd do that - it's a heck of a lot cheaper than pulling the killswitch on the whole plant.

Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by neutronicus on Saturday March 12, 2011 @02:16AM (#2316265)
The batteries may also be someplace a workman really doesn't want to go.
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by gaius on Saturday March 12, 2011 @03:05AM (#2316339)
I'm sure the Japanese have robots capable of it, they are the best in the world at that.
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by JanezStupar on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:35AM (#2316757)
Well not any robot will do in high radiation environment, since radiation tends to fry their circuits...

They tried it in Chernobyl but it didn't really work, so they had to use humans to do it. Every soldier got to run in, move an item, run out and be dismissed from this nuclear cleanup duty, due to irradiation received in this one try.

Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by jarek on Saturday March 12, 2011 @03:12PM (#2317377)
I would expect robots in Japan in 2011 to be able to withstand a bit more than robots in the USSR in 1986.
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by rdl on Saturday March 12, 2011 @02:16AM (#2316264)
They could probably fly or ship or truck in some smallish diesel generators to accomplish the same thing -- they're just pumps, so I find it hard to believe any individual load is bigger than your average transportable diesel genset. It shouldn't be too difficult to divide a load connected hydraulically vs. electrically across a bunch of generators quickly (switchgear is otherwise fairly custom).
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by nathanhammond on Saturday March 12, 2011 @03:09AM (#2316347)
The backup diesel generator at Oconee Nuclear Station (Oconee, SC) is fashioned out of a pair of modified diesel train engines ... it isn't exactly a simple "throw more power at it" problem. Even if it were trivially possible to add power as if you were filling up a tank of gas the bigger problem would be mating the power output and frequency of these generators with the rated values for the plant's electric system (on the fly, in an increased radiation environment, under high stress, with damaged basic infrastructure).

The people on the ground do not have an easy task in front of them.

Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by gonzo on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:59AM (#2316775)
the generators in question are used to run pumps. you wouldn't need to phase match them to the plant's electric system, per se. (you would need to phase match them to the other generators, but that is straight-forward)
Re:Cringley: Japan may have just permanently lost 20% of its... by fraserharris on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:29PM (#2318007)
If your goal is to provide electricity, you would ship in generators and diesel (, gas, etc). Batteries are useful because you can store the energy being generated onsite, but their energy to weight ratio is an order of magnitude smaller than combustible fuels.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density