News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by DanielBMarkham on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:13PM (#2314941)
I've been a member of Quora for a while, but I never got around to participating. There was always something about it that struck me as strange.

I think the problem is that there is an assumption that asking a question and receiving an answer is somehow a valuable experience in itself, and for basic bits of factual information it is. But much of what constitutes "interesting" questions, like the one in this article, do not fit that pattern.

I teach teams how to be agile. For many, an honest question they have is: why do we need you? Can't we just read the book and know all we need to know?

It turns out the answer to that question is very interesting, because mostly no, you probably can't. At least not in the way you think. There is factual information and then there is mastery of a complex skill. I look at it this way: I can show you a movie of a great piano player, you can meet him and get his autograph, we can even read books on how to play the piano.

Will any of that make you a piano player? No, it will not. So when you ask a seemingly straightforward and honest question like "How come I can't play this Bach piece?" I'm unable to give you a straightforward answer that you are going to find helpful. It's going to sound something like "Because you don't know what you are doing. First you must do all this other stuff". Of course, you don't want to do all that other stuff, you want to play the Bach piece. And so there we are.

This touches on another problem -- not knowing what you don't know. When I learned to fly, I found a good instructor and told him about the things I would like to do.

"We're not doing any of that," he said, and then explained what we would be doing. You see, I didn't know what questions to ask first. I simply had some goal.

The worst problem I can see is folks getting answers they are not ready to process. For example, sticking with my agile coach example, somebody might ask me why a team takes so long trying to figure out what it's doing. The "answer" might be something like "Because you've restricted their machines and tools in such a way it's taking ten times longer than it should." but good luck in giving it to somebody in that direct a fashion. They'll throw you out of their office -- especially if they were the ones all along pushing for more controls and complexity. This is a case of wanting a solution to one thing, but having a second thing that cannot be touched. And of course, the second thing is directly involved in the first thing. In situations like this you have to help people figure out for themselves where their own internal model is flaky. Sometimes that takes a while. (Interesting side note: many technologists ardently refuse to believe they could be this way, saying things like "just tell me bluntly". I have found that these folks are the worst to deal with, because instead of seeing life as a journey, they are caught up in black-and-white reasoning. So they are the last people you want to treat that way, because to do so you're basically telling them their thinking is broken -- a concept many cannot process)

Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by zby on Friday March 11, 2011 @06:54PM (#2315433)
Comparing viewing a piano player and getting his autograph to learning from a book is not fair at all. It is a straw man constructed to ridicule all autodidacts.
Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by ricefield on Friday March 11, 2011 @09:16PM (#2315758)
No, he isn't comparing the two, he's grouping them together. Watching a piano player, meeting him and getting his autograph, _even_ read a book. (roughly paraphrased).

I think he's trying to point out that besides "just reading the book" (as was given in his example with his customers) there are other ways people think they can learn and master complex skills - talking to famous, successful people, or watching how they work. While there's certainly value in doing so, his point is that that is probably not what you really need to improve.

Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by zby on Saturday March 12, 2011 @04:21AM (#2316444)
Let's take the quote:

"Can't we just read the book and know all we need to know? It turns out the answer to that question is very interesting, because mostly no, you probably can't. At least not in the way you think. There is factual information and then there is mastery of a complex skill. I look at it this way: I can show you a movie of a great piano player, you can meet him and get his autograph, we can even read books on how to play the piano. Will any of that make you a piano player? No, it will not."

Isn't that comparing learning from a book to watching a movie of a great piano player? This "we can even read books on how to play the piano" is just a minor addition. It should be the main point, but it is not because the other example is more ridiculous and scores more points. He puts forward an obviously stupid example of learning on your own and insists that it explains why learning on your own in general is stupid.

Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by arbitrarywords on Saturday March 12, 2011 @09:56AM (#2316835)
Trolling? Performance irony? Confusion?

"Reading the book" of your text, I just can't tell, but if we were face to face I could probably feel out what you were doing. Some things, especially assisting learning, require intense feedback loops, which happen much better in person. You can learn heaps from books, but a book can't notice when you've gone off track...

Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by zby on Saturday March 12, 2011 @01:06PM (#2317125)
I do agree that learning from a teacher does have benefits - I just don't like comparing learning from a book to watching a piano player and getting his autograph. What is really the point of getting the piano player autograph - who ever would think this is a legitimate learning procedure?
Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by SMrF on Saturday March 12, 2011 @11:01AM (#2316918)
"In situations like this you have to help people figure out for themselves where their own internal model is flaky. Sometimes that takes a while."

If you are any good at this, please write a book. I would pay a handsome some for even just incremental improvement in this skill.

My day is filled with people going around acting as if 2 + 2 = 5. Thus far my only strategy is to say, "Are you sure it's 5? I'm pretty sure it's 4." Repeat over and over for years until people adopt the new "2 + 2 = 4" mental model and forget I'd been saying it for years...

Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by zwieback on Saturday March 12, 2011 @09:32AM (#2316805)
I think there's also a big difference between learning as a team and learning as an individual. You can probably become a very good pianist on your own if you follow lesson books from start to finish. It's harder as a team because the social interactions are too many and too varied so you need an outside observer.
Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by barista on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:26PM (#2314982)
Given how long it took to load the link, I think he should instead say Hasta la Vista to Posterous.
Re:Hasta la Vista, Quora by nhebb on Friday March 11, 2011 @08:59PM (#2315726)
I didn't have any problems with page loading, but I did notice that he linked to the https version of the page, which could have affected load time.