News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wayland Architecture by praptak on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:30PM (#2314539)
Interesting quote by James Gosling (of NeWS fame, among others):

"I think that a more viable solution in the long run would be to replace the X protocol with a very simple pixel copying protocol that uses the user-level rendering libraries in the application to render to a local image buffer, then copies the pixels over the net in something that looks vaguely like a video stream.

There are a variety of compression hacks that make this surprisingly efficient – this is essentially what the SunRay product does. Some analysis has been done that shows that this uses essentially the same bandwidth as the X protocol, if done well."

From "Window System Design: If I had it to do over again in 2002."

Re:Wayland Architecture by wmf on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:53PM (#2314636)
Here's the paper that led to Sun Ray:

http://labs.oracle.com/features/tenyears/volcd/papers/nrthcu...

http://labs.oracle.com/features/tenyears/volcd/papers/Nrthcu...

Their argument is "A simple pixel encoding protocol requires only modest network resources (as little as a 1Mbps home connection) and is quite competitive with the X protocol."

Re:Wayland Architecture by mansr on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:49PM (#2314620)
This may work fine on a dedicated gigabit network, which is where SunRay lives, but it does not work at all on a slow, possibly high-latency, link. To see for yourself, try running any gtk or qt app over an ADSL link or even a local wireless network, and enjoy the slide-show. Apps using server-side font rendering, on the other hand, work nicely under these circumstances.
Re:Wayland Architecture by lmz on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:56PM (#2314644)
"A pixel copying protocol" would describe VNC and RDP as well, wouldn't it? By running any GTK / Qt app over ADSL you mean running them using the X11 protocol?