News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by suyash on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:37AM (#2312545)
Is this post appropriate for HN?
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by coderdude on Friday March 11, 2011 @03:49AM (#2312715)
50 crap articles get front-paged every single day and you choose the one about breaking news from a national disaster to start whining about what's right and wrong for HN? Sheesh.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by cosmok on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:44AM (#2312563)
Not according to the guidelines:

    "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or        sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic."
But, I don't mind it all as I get to read views and firsthand accounts from fellow hackers that is much different from what I see on TV.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by rdl on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:50AM (#2312581)
I was particularly interested in "is patio11 ok?" (and, are there any transpac fiber cuts?)

I think it's fair to post stories which are headlines in ~all news simultaneously, even if not "hacker news" -- nuclear explosions, assassinations of G7 leaders, major wars, etc.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by patio11 on Friday March 11, 2011 @03:03AM (#2312606)
I'm touched, but there are several dozen HNers in Japan who I've met personally (just an FYI) most were closer to it than I was.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by Sandman on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:45AM (#2312567)
No, it is not. From the HN guidelines: Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.

And unlike cosmok, I do mind it, because this type of news is slowly turning HN into something it shouldn't be. There's a reason for this particular guideline, and I think we should honor that.

EDIT: I don't mind the downvoting, but please, if you do that, at least post a comment on why you think my comment deserved to be downvoted.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by mechanical_fish on Friday March 11, 2011 @07:59AM (#2313146)
They may be downvoting you because they are emotional. Or they may be downvoting because you are wrong. ;)

This story violates neither the letter nor the spirit of the rule against "video" of a disaster; aka cheap sensationalism. Rather, much of the thread is the opposite of sensationalism: e.g. patio11 on the average state of Japanese disaster preparedness.

This story has all sorts of HN community relevance, ranging from how are community members experiencing this on the ground to how do otherwise abstract geology papers manifest in real life to hey, wait, my startup is sitting in a prime earthquake zone; how should we prepare?

And, you know, this is a magnitude 8.9 earthquake. They don't happen every year. We can afford a handful of threads on each one. It's nice to try to have an interesting news site, but if this isn't news one has to question the entire concept of news. Which is fair: News is not for everyone, and perhaps news is not for you. It's just not to your taste. Have you tried an exclusive diet of decade-old paper books?

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by erikpukinskis on Friday March 11, 2011 @07:01AM (#2313056)
I agree it's important that we maintain a culture of curation here, but some events are big enough that they eclipse cultural mores.

With respect to the kind of exceptions we make every day, I agree with you. But once or twice a year, a lot of people die, and everyone kind of stops what they're doing and pays their respects, wherever they happen to be, whether you're in line at the bank, or on the floor of the senate.

We all happen to be on HN 24 hours a day, so this is where we all stop and take notice.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by htp on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:21AM (#2312777)
I didn't down- or up-vote you, but my immediate response to your comment was: "is this really the time to worry about what HN is or isn't turning into?"

If your downvoters think the same way I do, they're downvoting because they don't think right now is a good time to worry about the future of HN, no matter what the guidelines say. This isn't to say your opinion is invalid (it's a perfectly legitimate thing to worry about); it just seems ill-timed in the face of potentially catastrophic disaster, and downvoting is an easy way to express disapproval.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by grammaton on Friday March 11, 2011 @12:47PM (#2314159)
While I agree with what you're saying, there's an exception to every rule. Normally I'd be one of the first to point out something is off topic. I've done so in the past.

However, the strongest earthquake to hit Japan in three centuries, causing loss of who knows how many lives and how much damage?

This is news worth looking beyond the "hacker" moniker for.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by younata on Friday March 11, 2011 @03:03AM (#2312605)
it shouldn't be downvoted anymore than cosmok's (which as of now, is sitting at karma 0).

I upvoted you to keep you closer to cosmok's comment.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by vijaydev on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:48AM (#2312571)
May be, may not be. But I'm sure there are people out there who got some updates from this post. For them, yes it is.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by intended on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:07AM (#2312751)
Fair enough. Maybe there is something people can come up with here which will help/inform people?

Edit: I mean this in earnest, we can and should help.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by flyt on Friday March 11, 2011 @02:49AM (#2312575)
probably not. oh well.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by oldstrangers on Friday March 11, 2011 @03:13AM (#2312626)
I wish I had enough karma to downvote you.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by ramchip on Friday March 11, 2011 @03:43AM (#2312703)
Why would his post deserve being downvoted to hell without so much as a discussion? You and I may disagree with him, but he has a valid point and doesn't appear to be trolling.
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by oldstrangers on Friday March 11, 2011 @03:50AM (#2312719)
I would like to think that HN had some compassion for their fellow users (HN has a lot of Tokyo based startups/hackers), not to mention humans in general.

In a scenario like this, who gives a fuck if it's off topic? And for the record, I saw the story here first, so I am thankful for that.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by Sandman on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:25AM (#2312784)
There are plenty of sites for general news. HN is not one of them.

The reason you saw it here first is because somebody posted it here despite what the guidelines say, and you happened to come at the right moment, before you checked other news sites you usually do.

The fact that you saw it here first does not change the fact that the article is, according to guidelines, off-topic.

Oh, and FYI, not posting this article on HN != not having compassion for fellow hackers.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by mdpm on Saturday March 12, 2011 @07:57AM (#2316719)
Just because you're sitting in a gentlemen's club in the midst of erudite conversation doesn't mean you're not going to point out that the place across the road is currently on fire.

Absolutes are silly.

Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by sw007 on Friday March 11, 2011 @08:36AM (#2313238)
I find it strange that you and others question whether this article should be on HN - the fact you and others are commenting must mean that the topic grabbed you enough for you to want to read and comment on what people are saying on the subject.

Also the fact that the post has over 300 points and is comfortably the most talked about thing within the community is proof enough that topics like this should be allowed to remain within HN

[deleted]
[deleted]
Re:8.9 earthquake hits Japan by htp on Friday March 11, 2011 @04:29AM (#2312796)
I feel the same way you do, but I'll hazard a boilerplate "don't feed the trolls" statement here.

It's clear emotions are running a bit high in this part of the comments.