News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ekianjo on Saturday May 09, 2020 @08:17AM (#23124127)
You have to consider the possibility that they were the only people who he could actually talk to. Not that he wanted to be in such channels in the first place.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by UncleMeat on Saturday May 09, 2020 @12:02PM (#23125862)
A while back I published some research that had implications about the us government’s treatment of digital privacy. A Russian media arm reached out to me for an interview.

I said no. Damore has the same choice.

Saying weird stuff about the kkk having cool uniforms was his own choice.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ekianjo on Saturday May 09, 2020 @10:52PM (#23129957)
> Damore has the same choice.

You mean he had the choice between:

- not speak at all and let all the media portray him as a misogynist and generally horrible person

- or try to explain himself with whoever was willing to hear him, knowing that he would also be judged "by association" in a negative light?

Sorry but it seems like there was no good choice for Damore anyway in terms of reputation.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by bsanr2 on Sunday May 10, 2020 @06:32PM (#23136933)
Or, he could have taken a step back, let the media do its thing, and then come back in a few months with his own view. This is actually the strategy many PR firms suggest, because it suggests moderation and makes people more likely to have cooled off and become ready to forgive. But he didn't do that, because his aim wasn't self-preservation, it was to grandstand. So he got what he got.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by UncleMeat on Sunday May 10, 2020 @01:00AM (#23130421)
His brief media appearances just doubled down. It wasn't about how he was trying to express himself more clearly. It was about how "the left" was out to sabotage him and tech is taken over by SJWs. The media appearances weren't going to do anything to repair his reputation even if they were on NPR.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by afiori on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:24AM (#23130693)
> It was about how "the left" was out to sabotage him and tech is taken over by SJWs.

Well, this part is true at google...

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by therealdrag0 on Saturday May 09, 2020 @03:55PM (#23127797)
There was an article about this, that said he went on some alt-right show/podcast and was really uncomfortable/disagreed with what the guy was saying but also isn't the kind of person who can charismatically argue on the spot like that (isn't he "on the spectrum"?). He had no idea what he was getting into.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by pas on Saturday May 09, 2020 @07:01PM (#23128949)
Well, he should have just stick to writing. Spectrum or not, recognizing that you're not great at talking, and you're not great at handling the fallout doesn't require special skills.

I'm not blaming him for going on those shows, but he should have recognized - after all he tried to argue a complex problem complexly - that supporting very biased simple platforms won't do him and his arguments any good, especially on the long run.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by manigandham on Saturday May 09, 2020 @10:17PM (#23129798)
That says more about the audience that can't listen and judge the content presented instead of who's presenting it.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ashtonkem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @11:20AM (#23125402)
Possible, but he also didn’t have to go on TV with them. You can’t go on a TV channel repeatedly and then try to pretend that it doesn’t affect your reputation in one way or another.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ALittleLight on Saturday May 09, 2020 @11:31AM (#23125523)
"Because he didn't accept his mistreatment in silence, that proves his mistreatment is justified."
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ashtonkem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @11:43AM (#23125645)
That’s a nonsense argument.

Humans will always be judged by the company they keep. You can be angry about that, but you’ve got to rage against human nature. He decided to repeatedly go on conservative outlets and be associated with alt-right figures; he should have been aware that he’d be judged by that.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ALittleLight on Saturday May 09, 2020 @12:21PM (#23126023)
It seems like you're judging Damore for being willing to share his considered and evidenced based beliefs with other people, because you don't like the ideology of those other people. That strikes me as a very anti-intellectual and anti-philosophical position.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ashtonkem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @12:37PM (#23126147)
I don’t really care about Damore or what he thinks.

I’m just saying that if Damore continues to associate with alt-right figures, he shouldn’t be surprised when people start assuming that he’s an alt-right crank, because that’s how people work.

[dead]
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ashtonkem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @12:50PM (#23126251)
Combining a bad faith reading with a personal insult is quite the combination. Maybe don’t do that?
[dead]
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ashtonkem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @03:51PM (#23127767)
Fine, since you’re going to be persistent about insulting me, I’ll take the bait and explain this carefully.

Humans don’t have the time, energy, or interest to evaluate every scrap of information about other people. Instead humans regularly use heuristics when meeting people for the first time, to save time and mental energy.

One of these heuristics involves making assumptions about people based on the company they keep. If someone is a friend of a friend, you probably make positive assumptions about them based on your shared friendship and a belief in your friends good judgement (I hope). Similarly you’re likely to initially dislike someone who is close friends with someone you dislike, for very similar reasons.

Another heuristic is group membership. We regularly assume that people hired at prestigious companies or enrolled at elite universities are more intelligent or hard working than the average person, and we make similar negative associations about someone who has been to prison. It might not be true every time, but it’s a decent heuristic to evaluate people quickly.

You may or may not like these heuristics, they can occasionally have some extremely negative consequences, but this is a pretty well studied area of human psychology. We all do it.

Now, back to the subject at hand. Obviously if you know Damore or a lot about his essay, you should judge him based on that. But if the first exposure you have to him is that he’s constantly going onto right or alt-right shows, it’s a reasonable assumption that he’s an alt-right figure.

You might not agree that Damore is alt right, and you might have extremely good evidence for that, but to the casual observer that doesn’t matter. Assuming that he’s alt-right based on the company he visibly keeps is a pretty reasonable assumption given the shows that he goes on. Hence, my original point.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ALittleLight on Saturday May 09, 2020 @06:59PM (#23128934)
You're conflating going on a talk show to share your story and being friends with people.

I also don't really get your point. It seems like you're saying some people will incorrectly judge him because of the talk shows he went on. Okay, so?

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ashtonkem on Saturday May 09, 2020 @07:05PM (#23128968)
You didn’t read fully. I made it clear that group membership is one thing that people will judge on. Group membership would plausibly include those who go onto specific TV shows.

And yes, literally my entire point was that people will judge him for going on talk shows.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ALittleLight on Saturday May 09, 2020 @07:59PM (#23129225)
Ok, I agree. Some people will judge him for going on talk shows.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by brendoelfrendo on Saturday May 09, 2020 @05:14PM (#23128372)
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, and is loved and lauded by ducks, you have to consider that it might be a duck.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by convery on Saturday May 09, 2020 @08:28AM (#23124176)
My first thought as well. You see liberals invited onto conservative outlets for genuine debates / opinions. Rarely see liberal outlets do the same as guilt by association, causing anyone who's ever been in the same room as an 'alt-right' to be tainted, seem to be rampant.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by ausbah on Saturday May 09, 2020 @01:17PM (#23126510)
"genuine debates" on conservative outlets, like what? Fox News? talk radio? a dingy YouTube channel?
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by manigandham on Saturday May 09, 2020 @10:18PM (#23129807)
Can you give examples of what you consider "genuine debates" then?

I care more about the content than where it's hosted.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by crowbahr on Saturday May 09, 2020 @09:02AM (#23124376)
Most news agencies besides Fox struggle to get Republicans to agree to appear on the show.

CNN famously lambasted Republican lawmakers for refusing to appear after the shootings in Dayton and El Paso last year.

What you have described is that liberal lawmakers are willing to face adversarial news coverage while conservatives are unwilling to do so.

Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by convery on Saturday May 09, 2020 @10:47AM (#23125111)
The comment was not about lawmakers though, plenty of conservative pundits / people like Damore that want to share their stuff but are treated like they're radioactive.
Re:James Damore and three others end Google suit by fzeroracer on Saturday May 09, 2020 @04:32PM (#23128083)
Damore was invited to share his thoughts by the media. By his own admission, he turned them down.

So what exactly is your point in this scenario?