News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:35PM (#23119141)
Sure, it's definitely an argument in favor of lockdowns — and I don't necessarily disagree with that.

What I disagree with is the argument that even entertaining the counterargument (that the deaths are some how "worth it") is tantamount to daylight murder. We have the right to entertain that tradeoff, and we also have the right to exercise it if society decides to.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @04:47PM (#23119271)
No, we don't have the right to entertain a tradeoff that sacrifices people for profits.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:02PM (#23119428)
First of all, we absolutely have the legal right — it's well within the confines of the Brandenburg test, so I have no idea what you're on about there.

Second of all, we entertain this tradeoff all the time.

If we just all stopped driving cars, we would save about 35,000 lives per year. It would likely cripple the economy (until we can find alternatives), but we all just decide that it's worth it to not cripple the economy. It's an example of us sacrificing lives for economic activity (or in your words, "profit").

Maybe the tradeoff is actually wrong (and it could be!), but it's by no means illegal to make that tradeoff...

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:11PM (#23119504)
Who said anything about "legal"? 200 years ago, slavery was legal. Do you think we have the right to re-implement slavery if it would stop this pandemic? Or even that we should entertain a plan to re-implement slavery if we believed it could stop the pandemic?
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:36PM (#23119771)
Ah yes, very good, the "slavery" argument.

In your own words, "legality" isn't everything. Moral rights aren't absolute, nor are they objective — different people have different morals.

There is probably no moral framework in which slavery can be justified.

There are LOADS of valid moral frameworks in which economic vs number of lives cost/benefit tradeoffs are made.

Many things can be true at the same time. The world isn't as simplistic as you seem to make it out to be.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:42PM (#23119816)
Provide one such framework that justifies the certainty that innocent people will be harmed, in exchange for imaginary numbers in a computer being incremented ("economic activity"). If there are LOADS of them, it shouldn't be that hard. Yet, you have not done so.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:46PM (#23119866)
The same framework that justifies the collective driving of automobiles for personal transportation which results in the deaths of about 35,000 innocent people per year, in return for measurable improvement to "economic activity", as told by the imaginary numbers in my computer.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @05:56PM (#23119970)
As I said, that analogy is false. The magnitude of the damage is so much higher for the coronavirus, and the people endangered are already those most vulnerable in society.

Let me put it to you this way: my parents are in no danger from you crashing your car. They are if you go out and start resuming "normal activity" to increment your fake numbers in a computer. Is scoring imaginary points really worth endangering my parents?

You seem to have an inordinate amount of trouble finding a single justification for endangering people at this scale, even though there are apparently LOADS of frameworks that would say it's okay. Why is that?

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:20PM (#23120178)
The analogy is not "false", it's used to show you that we all decide how many lost lives we find to be acceptable for modern society to function.

Your parents have a non-zero statistical probability of dying from a car crash, the same way that they have a non-zero statistical probability of dying from COVID due to "normal activity". The probability of the latter is undeniably higher than that of the former, and you appear to consider the former to be acceptable.

I mean no disrespect to your parents, but you have to accept that for some people, they draw the line differently, and the probability threshold is within their limit.

> You seem to have an inordinate amount of trouble finding a single justification for endangering people at this scale, even though there are apparently LOADS of frameworks that would say it's okay. Why is that?

I'm going to emphasize "At this scale", in your statement, because you're implicitly arguing that THIS scale is unacceptable. I'm simply arguing that, while that may be true for you — and for the record, it's also unacceptable to me — you have to understand that different people have different acceptable thresholds. You think that one loses the moral right to entertain the deaths of innocent people at some arbitrary threshold. But it's arbitrary, and unique to you.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:24PM (#23120218)
Again, I have not stated that I accept 35,000 deaths per year so capitalism can continue on its merry way. I again invite you to quote where I have said so, if you don't believe me. I have simply stated that the difference in scale means that an argument that justifies 35,000 deaths cannot justify 5,250,000+ deaths.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:26PM (#23120231)
> I have simply stated that the difference in scale means that an argument that justifies 35,000 deaths cannot justify 5,250,000+ deaths.

at some point the number of deaths is high enough that you decide that "the scale is different and this can no longer be justified". I'm simply stating that this limit is arbitrary, and debatable.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:34PM (#23120289)
I never said that any number of deaths was acceptable. Try again.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:45PM (#23120354)
Okay, so you might hold an absolutist position on the acceptable number of deaths, that the acceptable number of deaths is exactly 0.

Assuming that is the case, do you really believe that people don't have the moral right to entertain any amount of deaths for "economic activity"?

If so, this is the least enforceable violation of your version of "human rights", possibly in the history of humanity.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:54PM (#23120428)
Since when does enforceability have any impact on whether something is a human right or not? One aspect of "human rights" is that they are universal. They apply to both me, you, and everyone else on the planet equally. And, it is entirely reasonable to believe that nobody has the right to end my life but me. So, yes, I believe 0 is the correct number of lives to be sacrificed for economic activity, even though we don't come close to that practically.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @07:01PM (#23120475)
And it’s totally fine for you to have that point of view.

You have to accept that I and the majority of others have a different point of view (I’m not an absolutist about it).

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by Johanx64 on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:50PM (#23121145)
Your whole argument relies on the faulty notion that the lockdown prioritizes "saving lives" over the economy.

This simply isn't true, and I'd argue that lockdown will directly or indirectly kill more people than it will "save".

In other words, saving economy is about saving lives, and less to do with "profits".

And then it becomes a matter of who gets to decide which set of people dies - "the old and the weak" or - in arguably greater numbers - everyone else (while their liberties get stripped away in the process).

Mind you, lockdown doesn't solve the problem, but only slows it down, namely the amount of people it will save is arguably rather small compared to numbers of people who will die from the economic damage.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:53PM (#23121167)
Where is your research paper showing this?
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by Johanx64 on Friday May 08, 2020 @09:07PM (#23121242)
Do you question the premise that:

a) economic depression will directly or indirectly kill people

b) lockdown doesn't "solve the problem" - it merely slows it down

We can argue all day about exactly numbers of how many people will get killed by the economic damage, but if you want to take away rights and opportunities for people to provide for themselves and their families, the onus is on you to prove that the lockdown will save more people than it will kill.

And at the end of the day - it's still a question of which set of people is going to die - whatever those numbers might be.

Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by username90 on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:10PM (#23120901)
You sacrifice people for people, not people for economy. Quality of life takes a huge hit during lockdowns, not being able to see friends and family matters a lot. Most of the world decided that grandma living another month is worth more than the entire childhood of a kid. Sweden decided that it wasn't, so it didn't shut down schools. Simple as that.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @08:57PM (#23121188)
We don’t sacrifice lives for your “quality of life,” full stop. People may choose to sacrifice themselves, but you don’t get to make that choice for them.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working by username90 on Saturday May 09, 2020 @05:03AM (#23123207)
We do, all the time. What we don't do is sacrifice thousands of others quality of life just to slightly extend your expected lifespan.