Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working
by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:24PM
(#23120218)
Again, I have not stated that I accept 35,000 deaths per year so capitalism can continue on its merry way. I again invite you to quote where I have said so, if you don't believe me. I have simply stated that the difference in scale means that an argument that justifies 35,000 deaths cannot justify 5,250,000+ deaths.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working
by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:26PM
(#23120231)
> I have simply stated that the difference in scale means that an argument that justifies 35,000 deaths cannot justify 5,250,000+ deaths.
at some point the number of deaths is high enough that you decide that "the scale is different and this can no longer be justified". I'm simply stating that this limit is arbitrary, and debatable.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working
by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:34PM
(#23120289)
I never said that any number of deaths was acceptable. Try again.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working
by bhupy on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:45PM
(#23120354)
Okay, so you might hold an absolutist position on the acceptable number of deaths, that the acceptable number of deaths is exactly 0.
Assuming that is the case, do you really believe that people don't have the moral right to entertain any amount of deaths for "economic activity"?
If so, this is the least enforceable violation of your version of "human rights", possibly in the history of humanity.
Re:Sweden’s Relaxed Approach to Covid-19 Isn’t Working
by pmiller2 on Friday May 08, 2020 @06:54PM
(#23120428)
Since when does enforceability have any impact on whether something is a human right or not? One aspect of "human rights" is that they are universal. They apply to both me, you, and everyone else on the planet equally. And, it is entirely reasonable to believe that nobody has the right to end my life but me. So, yes, I believe 0 is the correct number of lives to be sacrificed for economic activity, even though we don't come close to that practically.