Re:Microsoft offers $100k to hack its custom Linux OS
by duxup on Friday May 08, 2020 @01:05AM
(#23111578)
More specifically I'd question the abilities of anyone who thinks they know about security who then exposes actual work material to some sort of uncontrolled test as described and honestly claims to be sure it is secure.
Anyone who knows about security understands that on a modern system there are so many layers of software / firmware, you never can be 100% sure (well I guess other than powering it off...).
The dilemma is that equating absence of evidence with evidence of absence is actually a good long-term strategy in our day-to-day lives. Without this strategy we'd be paralyzed by our own ignorance; particularly, paradoxically, those aware of their ignorance. It's a meta-skill to be able to identify when the heuristic should be discarded in favor of more rigorous analytical thinking. A capacity for analytical thinking isn't sufficient by itself, thus making such an error in judgement doesn't necessarily imply an absence of strong analytical thinking skills. (At least, that's what I tell myself ;)