The dilemma is that equating absence of evidence with evidence of absence is actually a good long-term strategy in our day-to-day lives. Without this strategy we'd be paralyzed by our own ignorance; particularly, paradoxically, those aware of their ignorance. It's a meta-skill to be able to identify when the heuristic should be discarded in favor of more rigorous analytical thinking. A capacity for analytical thinking isn't sufficient by itself, thus making such an error in judgement doesn't necessarily imply an absence of strong analytical thinking skills. (At least, that's what I tell myself ;)
Anyone who knows about security understands that on a modern system there are so many layers of software / firmware, you never can be 100% sure (well I guess other than powering it off...).
If his judgment is that bad on a basic level, how bad must it be on a technical level?