Re:Ask HN: Name one idea that changed your life
by elliekelly on Friday May 08, 2020 @11:33AM
(#23115904)
I had a boss who used to say there was always a “good reason” and a “real reason” for doing something. A person will tell you the good reason but they won’t often admit the real reason. Sometimes not even to themselves.
Example: Health Care
Visible goal: Improve Health
Hidden goal: Show how much we care ("kiss the booboo")
This explains why much of health care is devoted to high-cost high-visibility interventions (like bypass surgery) and much less to lifestyle interventions (like diet/exercise).
It also explains why many obvious changes that would improve the stated goal keep failing to be adopted - they hamper the hidden goals.
Software example: Why do people keep estimating development task size assuming nothing goes wrong? And why do their managers not hold them responsible for continually slipping the schedules?
Visible goal: Accurate estimates
Hidden goal: Brag about how fast we are
If accurate estimates were the only goal, then when schedules slip there would be a strong feedback loop to improve future estimates. My experience has been the opposite - the slip is blamed on something "no one could have foreseen" and everybody keeps estimating as before.
To be clear, it's always a mix of the visible and hidden motives. Much of health care is actually about improving health. But acknowledging the hidden motives is vital to understanding how much of society works.