News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by mistermann on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:48AM (#2309486)
That's supposedly what my headhunter does for me on my behalf (part of how they try to justify their $10 to $25 per hour cut), but I've never seen them do this successfully. It makes no difference to them, they get paid the same either way.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by capstone on Thursday March 10, 2011 @01:05PM (#2310036)
My experience has been the opposite. A few observations based on 7+ years consulting in NYC, some through headhunters, some direct:

- Companies that hire through recruiters have deep yearly budgets; companies that hire direct have shallow project budgets. I have never not gotten a higher rate through a recruiter.

- Companies that hire through recruiters pay on time; companies that hire direct pay late and usually after repeated prodding; sometimes they don't pay at all.

- Companies that hire through recruiters pay for hours worked; companies that hire direct fight for upfront concessions and then fight some more when the bill comes.

- Most recruiters make a percentage and not a set fee, although yes, it's usually capped at around $25/hour. However that means that you need to be making upward of $100/hour to hit that cap. Which means that for the majority of people, the recruiter does make more when you make more.

All in all I never understood the customary programmer/recruiter animosity. Making more and never having to deal with collections is awesome. In my book, recruiters' cut is well-deserved.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by mistermann on Thursday March 10, 2011 @09:14PM (#2311841)
My experiences are the exact opposite of yours....not that you're wrong, more likely because of different industries. Here, headhunters add almost no value to the equation. More than 50% of them don't have the remotest clue what the technologies they're screening for are. It's really a sad state.

Whenever I work direct for a company, I always make way more (basically, my cut, and the headhunters cut).

Despite this, companies seem to always work through headhunters...I've never seen any manager ask any developer "do you know any good ____ people that might be available?" It's really bizarre.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by metageek on Friday March 11, 2011 @10:16AM (#2313582)
At the past few companies I've worked at, managers have definitely tried to get employees to recommend people, and have offered substantial referral bonuses. (Less than a recruiter would get, but still a nice chunk of money.)
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by smanek on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:58AM (#2309521)
In my experience, head hunters usually get paid a fee equal to N months of your salary (where, most often, 3<=N<=6). If they negotiate my monthly salary up to 12K instead of 10K they'll probably make 6K-12K extra, so they do have an incentive to negotiate.

Of course, their incentive is much smaller than mine, since an initial 2K/month salary boost might translate to 50K in extra salary over my tenure with that company and, conceivably, extra hundreds of thousands over my career.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by andrewf on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:23AM (#2309630)
If it would take a recruiter more than 20% more effort to get your salary up by 20%, they are better off putting their time into placing as many people as possible.

Because they can increase their total commissions by 20% if they increase their number of employees placed by that much.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by natch on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:37AM (#2309693)
True if they can find a pool of candidates that don't care about getting better compensation. Many people, like me, are not in that pool. If they can't get me the compensation I ask for, they won't place me. Someone else will place me instead. So by not doing that 20% of work, they are losing not 20%, but 100% of what they would make from my placement. But yes, perhaps they can make it up by finding people who don't care about compensation.

But really my take on this is different. If it takes an extra 20% of work, then the hiring company is probably not for me. I'd rather work for companies where good compensation is a given, because they tend to do other things better as well.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by prostoalex on Thursday March 10, 2011 @02:04PM (#2310254)
Exactly, they could spend next day negotiating on your behalf to get extra 10% for you and 2% for themselves, or placing another candidate, and boosting their revenue by extra 100%.