News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by DevX101 on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:43AM (#2309468)
Just throwing a crazy idea out in the wild here: Have a service where a professional negotiates salary on your behalf.

1. Is there interest in this? 2. Would this be feasible?

Employers sure as hell wouldn't like it, but I wonder if they'd tolerate it.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by jtbigwoo on Thursday March 10, 2011 @01:53PM (#2310205)
Almost everybody in the entertainment business has an agent or manager that does the negotiation for them and tracks down additional opportunities for personal appearances and endorsements. Even the producer on the local talk radio show has an agent negotiating her pay and looking for additional revenue opportunities.

It probably wouldn't work in other industries without a huge shift in expectations, but it really does work at thousands of employers.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by brk on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:05AM (#2309561)
This would only work if you did it in scale. It would be hard to have someone negotiate just on your behalf, there is more strength in numbers.

If you could get a unified group of employees to all sign an agreement to be represented as a group, then you would have collective bargaining power...

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by ohyes on Thursday March 10, 2011 @12:05PM (#2309824)
The only problem with this is that then you would be negotiating on the merits of the entire group of employees, rather than the merits of your own work.

If we take the 'order of magnitude of productivity' difference in programmers seriously, it seems that the best programmers would have a serious incentive not to join the union, were they actually able to negotiate proportional to their ability level. (Granted, they don't and it is unlikely you will find an employer willing to pay you 10x as much as one of your coworkers, so maybe it does make sense).

Also, the governor of Wisconsin wouldn't stand for it, and the company would likely fire the lot of you as soon as you decided to unionize.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by jedsmith on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:27AM (#2309650)
United Computer Nerds Local 0x55AA?
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by krakensden on Thursday March 10, 2011 @04:04PM (#2310766)
Something about that name suddenly makes me want a union. Or maybe a t-shirt.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by Natsu on Friday March 11, 2011 @01:20AM (#2312360)
Should get out the list of hex words that was posted to HN a while back. There have to be more interesting hex strings than 0x55AA.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by metageek on Friday March 11, 2011 @10:14AM (#2313574)
0xDEADBEEF
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by sethg on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:47AM (#2309744)
The two routes to that kind of arrangement would be to either organize your immediate co-workers into a union (http://www.cwa-union.org/pages/how_to_organize_a_union) or to get together with colleagues and form a contracting firm.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by tptacek on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:35AM (#2309686)
They would not tolerate it and it wouldn't work. The only way to negotiate effectively is to come armed with information. As an employee of a company, you have no authority to delegate your confidentiality agreement to other parties (very few people in real companies actually have any signing authority). At most companies, you'd also be violating the unspoken norm that salaries are private. You can disagree with the the reasonableness of those two points, but the simple fact is the "service" would get you fired.

A far better idea for a service would be for negotiation counseling. This service actually already exists, but is so touchy- feely- that it isn't taken seriously by hard-nosed tech workers, who as a result get rolled by their employers.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by khafra on Thursday March 10, 2011 @12:41PM (#2309960)
For clarification: "Negotiation counseling" sounds different from "negotiation class." Is the difference that a counselor studies your portfolio and credentials and tells you how much to ask for, as well as how to ask for it? Or is it just a variation on learning to negotiate?
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by ScottBurson on Thursday March 10, 2011 @03:35PM (#2310663)
I think the idea is that the agent would negotiate the terms of the initial offer, i.e., this would happen before the tech worker joined the company. Certainly, once you're in, an agent is unlikely to be able to do anything for you. So the question is not whether it would get you fired but whether a prospective employer would negotiate with your agent. It depends on the circumstances, I'm sure, but in Silicon Valley, if you have skills that are in great demand, we just might be at a point where this could begin to work.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by dabent on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:54AM (#2309506)
A recruiter can do this to some extent, but the recruiter is driven by a need to get the deal closed, so they can get their fee from the employer. In other words, the recruiter will get you the minimum amount needed to get you to sign on. I honestly don't think it would even work that well if you were paying the fee, either. The third party would still have a strong incentive to get you to sign on quickly, rather than extracting the N+1th dollar from the employer.

To complicate matters, I've worked with many BigCo HR departments, and really doubt that they'd deal with a third party that they didn't have on their approved vendor list. In fact, a third party would probably be a deal breaker.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by Peroni on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:46AM (#2309740)
* the recruiter will get you the minimum amount needed to get you to sign on.*

Rubbish. Why would we compromise our bottom line for the sake of getting a deal done? Sure I could push you in at your absolute minimum salary but if you get a better offer in the mean time then I lose my fee. It's in my best interests to get you as high a salary as I can possibly get you.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by sethg on Thursday March 10, 2011 @12:02PM (#2309807)
It’s not a question of getting the absolute minimum salary, but of getting less than the absolute maximum.

If I recall correctly, the authors of Freakanomics discovered that when real-estate agents sell their own houses, they sell for a higher price than comparable houses where a non-agent used an agent as a middleman. This confirms the hypothesis that agents are willing to compromise on price to close the deal sooner.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by dpritchett on Thursday March 10, 2011 @05:00PM (#2310994)
More specifically, an agent working on commission gets proportionally less reward for a price increase than does someone negotiating on their own behalf.

- Real estate agent negotiates 8 hours for an additional $10,000 on the sales price: 5% commission gets him $500 for an hourly rate of $63.

- Real estate agent negotiates 8 hours for an additional $10,000 on the sales price of his own home: he keeps all $10,000 for an hourly rate of $1250.

- Recruiter negotiates for 8 hours for an additional $5000 salary: he gets a 20% commission for $1000 or $125/hr.

- Job hunter negotiates for 8 hours for an additional $5000 on his own salary: he gets $5000 for $625/hr. plus compounding effects for every future salary negotiation that is based off of his current salary.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by Peroni on Thursday March 10, 2011 @12:20PM (#2309882)
This confirms the hypothesis that agents are willing to compromise on price to close the deal sooner.

Correction:

  This confirms the hypothesis that ESTATE agents are willing to compromise on price to close the deal sooner.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by achompas on Thursday March 10, 2011 @01:56PM (#2310220)
The Freakonomics result only applies to that sample of real estate agents. Even then, the sample is only taken from a population of real estate agents.

In other words, results don't extrapolate to all agents.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by URSpider94 on Friday March 11, 2011 @01:33AM (#2312401)
Nonsense.

For your argument to be true, you'd have to assume that there was something special about the sample population chosen by the authors. That flies against the laws of statistics. Further, there is a clear explanation of the behavior that aligns with the economic incentives of the parties.

In buying and selling homes multiple times, I have always casually mentioned the study to my agents, and they have vehemently denied that it is true. However, in every transaction save one, the agents have eventually acted in ways that would close the deal quickly for a loss to me, yet get them their (slightly reduced) commission sooner.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by achompas on Friday March 11, 2011 @12:57PM (#2314204)
Of course there's something special about the sample Levitt chose: it's all real estate agents.

If the statistical results are sound then we can infer some characteristics about the population. But in this case, the sample came from a population of real estate agents. There is a fixed effect found across the whole sample: they're in the housing business, not the headhunting business. No recruiters in that population, so we can't infer anything about recruiters in general.

Sorry to argue semantics, but this is a basic sampling concept that people forget about.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by chollida1 on Thursday March 10, 2011 @03:14PM (#2310557)
For the same reason a real estate agent wants to get a deal done.

After a while negotiating for an extra few thousand gets the recrutor an extra few hundred. If it takes 2 days to get this much more then the recruiter has lost money.

However to the employee, this takes none of his/her time and compounds onto top of each additional raise so it's in their interest to get the most they can no matter how much time, with in reason, it takes the recruiter to get the deal done.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by deong on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:59AM (#2309794)
Because you have more than one person you're working with at a time. You get X% of their offer. If they get a higher offer, you get (X+delta)%. If that delta% of the offer that makes up your difference is lower than the value of your time spent doing other things (finding someone else a job), then it doesn't make sense for you to spend the time.

That's the basic issue. If you're getting 5%, then by definition you should care 5% as much as the candidate what the final salary ends up being, and thus care much less if it's a little bit lower than it could have been.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by Peroni on Thursday March 10, 2011 @12:23PM (#2309904)
Firstly, our percentage is a lot higher than 5% so we have more invested than you may think.

Secondly, negotiating an offer is the quickest and easiest part. It hardly consumes any time at all by comparison to the amount of time and effort invested just to get to the point where there is any offer at all.

If I've invested a massive amount of time and effort into getting a candidate through the process to the point where the employer wants to make them an offer, believe me, I am going to fight tooth and nail to squeeze every penny from the employer that I can get.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by metageek on Friday March 11, 2011 @10:14AM (#2313571)
>Secondly, negotiating an offer is the quickest and easiest part. It hardly consumes any time at all by comparison to the amount of time and effort invested just to get to the point where there is any offer at all.

I'll buy that; the recruiters I've worked with have certainly put in a lot of time getting me to the point of having an offer.

The point of serious mismatch is when you're working with more than one recruiter (at different agencies). Some years back, I was almost at the offer stage from company X through recruiter A; recruiter B pushed me to apply at company Y, too. Problem was, X and Y were founded/funded by the same people, and had an agreement (possibly illegal) not to compete on candidates. B somehow convinced me to go ahead anyway; I talked to Y, and X dropped me.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by mistermann on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:48AM (#2309486)
That's supposedly what my headhunter does for me on my behalf (part of how they try to justify their $10 to $25 per hour cut), but I've never seen them do this successfully. It makes no difference to them, they get paid the same either way.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by capstone on Thursday March 10, 2011 @01:05PM (#2310036)
My experience has been the opposite. A few observations based on 7+ years consulting in NYC, some through headhunters, some direct:

- Companies that hire through recruiters have deep yearly budgets; companies that hire direct have shallow project budgets. I have never not gotten a higher rate through a recruiter.

- Companies that hire through recruiters pay on time; companies that hire direct pay late and usually after repeated prodding; sometimes they don't pay at all.

- Companies that hire through recruiters pay for hours worked; companies that hire direct fight for upfront concessions and then fight some more when the bill comes.

- Most recruiters make a percentage and not a set fee, although yes, it's usually capped at around $25/hour. However that means that you need to be making upward of $100/hour to hit that cap. Which means that for the majority of people, the recruiter does make more when you make more.

All in all I never understood the customary programmer/recruiter animosity. Making more and never having to deal with collections is awesome. In my book, recruiters' cut is well-deserved.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by mistermann on Thursday March 10, 2011 @09:14PM (#2311841)
My experiences are the exact opposite of yours....not that you're wrong, more likely because of different industries. Here, headhunters add almost no value to the equation. More than 50% of them don't have the remotest clue what the technologies they're screening for are. It's really a sad state.

Whenever I work direct for a company, I always make way more (basically, my cut, and the headhunters cut).

Despite this, companies seem to always work through headhunters...I've never seen any manager ask any developer "do you know any good ____ people that might be available?" It's really bizarre.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by metageek on Friday March 11, 2011 @10:16AM (#2313582)
At the past few companies I've worked at, managers have definitely tried to get employees to recommend people, and have offered substantial referral bonuses. (Less than a recruiter would get, but still a nice chunk of money.)
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by smanek on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:58AM (#2309521)
In my experience, head hunters usually get paid a fee equal to N months of your salary (where, most often, 3<=N<=6). If they negotiate my monthly salary up to 12K instead of 10K they'll probably make 6K-12K extra, so they do have an incentive to negotiate.

Of course, their incentive is much smaller than mine, since an initial 2K/month salary boost might translate to 50K in extra salary over my tenure with that company and, conceivably, extra hundreds of thousands over my career.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by andrewf on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:23AM (#2309630)
If it would take a recruiter more than 20% more effort to get your salary up by 20%, they are better off putting their time into placing as many people as possible.

Because they can increase their total commissions by 20% if they increase their number of employees placed by that much.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by natch on Thursday March 10, 2011 @11:37AM (#2309693)
True if they can find a pool of candidates that don't care about getting better compensation. Many people, like me, are not in that pool. If they can't get me the compensation I ask for, they won't place me. Someone else will place me instead. So by not doing that 20% of work, they are losing not 20%, but 100% of what they would make from my placement. But yes, perhaps they can make it up by finding people who don't care about compensation.

But really my take on this is different. If it takes an extra 20% of work, then the hiring company is probably not for me. I'd rather work for companies where good compensation is a given, because they tend to do other things better as well.

Re:Salary negotiations for techies by prostoalex on Thursday March 10, 2011 @02:04PM (#2310254)
Exactly, they could spend next day negotiating on your behalf to get extra 10% for you and 2% for themselves, or placing another candidate, and boosting their revenue by extra 100%.
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by pushingbits on Thursday March 10, 2011 @01:53PM (#2310206)
You mean like... a union?
Re:Salary negotiations for techies by ulrich on Thursday March 10, 2011 @10:55AM (#2309512)
I was thinking about this a lot of times. Having some person to handle the kind of work I dislike. But in the end, I guess it's too hard to realize. Headhunters are supposed to help you with it, but they never do. There had to be a different, employee-friendly incentive for them. However, I'd love to be proved wrong.