News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surface Go 2, Surface Book 3, Surface Headphones 2 and Su... by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @11:58AM (#23092511)
This is interesting as over in the WinUI thread people are complaining how the tablet features have ruined Windows on the Desktop.
Re:Surface Go 2, Surface Book 3, Surface Headphones 2 and Su... by GekkePrutser on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:23PM (#23092858)
Probably true too though.

One of the problems with MS' approach is trying to get a "one UI fits all" approach which just doesn't work, the usecases between tablet and desktop are too different.

Even Apple hasn't made this mistake and they're all about simplicity and consistency.

Re:Surface Go 2, Surface Book 3, Surface Headphones 2 and Su... by qzw on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @12:27PM (#23092925)
Yes, it’s all the more galling that they ruined the desktop experience without providing a good tablet experience. Yes, things are bigger and more tappable, but there’s more to a good tablet UX than that. They have only done the relatively easy part. The hard part requires redesigning behavior and workflow, which will take far more time and effort than just adding some whitespace and increasing widget size.
Re:Surface Go 2, Surface Book 3, Surface Headphones 2 and Su... by contextfree on Wednesday May 06, 2020 @01:04PM (#23093485)
Windows 8 was all about redesigning behavior and workflow, those were the aspects that were largely walked back in successive updates.

I was a big fan of Win8 (was fine with it on desktop as well) but tablet mode on Win10 was a major downgrade and I only ever use Surface in desktop mode, even on the rare occasions I tuck back or detach the keyboard. I still use touch a lot though, sometimes simultaneously with mouse or trackpad.