> Imagine that Jerry Seinfeld wrote a book about politics and governance strategy, and sent it to Hillary Clinton, because he wanted to get hired as an aide. Everyone is fascinated by this book, and it somehow becomes an important work in political science. Five hundred years later, Seinfeld is mostly forgotten, but people still call things "Seinfeldian".
That's Machiavelli.
A better modern example might be: imagine a mid-level office worker at the New York Office of Public Records writes a book about politics and sends it to the mayor, hoping to get a job. He uses examples from contemporary NYC and past political history to illustrate his points. Years after his death, his book becomes read across the world and NYC is simply seen as a temporary setting for the broader ideas.
This is just wrong!
He was Florence's ambassador to the Vatican (the major power in Italy), then ambassador to France (the major power in Europe) and Spain.
After this he trained and led a Florentine army to victory against Pisa, and then lost to a Papal and Medici funded army and was banished from Florence.
It was at this point he wrote his book.
It's more like if Henry Kissenger had been a Marine as well.
A better modern example might be a high-level office worker in the police department that was sent to other states. In either case, at some point, the comparison becomes stretched.
But yeah, you’re probably right in saying that my statement was wrong.
How does being a writer of popular satirical plays and novels not count?
Machiavelli was the chief diplomat of Florence. He negotiated treaties with France (the superpower of the time) and with the (crazy!!) Borgias, and dealt with their fall.
[1]https://publicdomainreview.org/essay/machiavelli-comedian
That said, he was also an experienced diplomat, military commander and politician, so the comparison to Jerry Seinfeld is a bit off (unless there is also things about Seinfelds career I don't know about). He wasn't just a comedy writer who out of left field wrote a treatise on government.
sounds legit.
Machiavelli doesn't seem to actively promote wrongful behavior nor engage in morality evaluations, mostly keeping a neutral, objective perspective throughout his writings.
Nevertheless, his objectivism is commonly, and wrongfully, interpreted as malignity.