Want to get into cryptocurrency-specific applications? If you used that proof-of-passport design and issued an inflationary currency around it such that inflation was issued one-coin-per-passport, then you have a currency that auto-taxes the rich and auto-distributes a UBI (parameterized however you like). Could be governed via online voting. Would need to have considerable penalties (or bounties) to those who are found with fake passports though. This currency could be quickly substituted with effectively no usable difference to most people for anything currently purchasable with Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc. It could also be used as a decentralized asset registration system for non-cash assets. If enough people simply held and used this currency as opposed to other crypto or USD/etc, and enough started requiring buyers/sellers to use it (for political reasons at first, then later practical reasons) then its price would quickly stabilize and make it a reserve currency, and there's not much any other party could do to stop it. Participation in the economy could then effectively require use of this currency, which means effectively registering your assets and your accounts under a single identity and exposing those assets to automatic taxation in their effective value due to inflation. It is simply built into the system at that point. Though this inflation relationship could be set to be a net benefit users up to a net worth of e.g. 2 million USD equivalent.
This also opens the doors for automated anonymous auditing of assets, anonymous proof-of-ownership, etc.
Enter "but we could do this already without cryptocurrencies!" - sure, probably. But now you can do it without centralized control of the system by anyone.
Europe stands out somewhat and we can argue that cryptocurrencies don't bring much improvement onto the table. Banking fees are already very low and Europe is currently rolling out instant credit transfer. I can open a bank account for free and without any recurring fees, and make up to 5000 payments a month for free to anyone in Europe, arriving in less than 20 seconds, available 24/7/365, automatable through APIs. But the rest of the world... my God what stone age you're living in, people with paper checks and overdraft fees imagine they're "informed skeptics" against modern settlement systems. Feels like early 1990s with people saying that email is pointless and they'll never use it.
Whatever the solution we end up with, it won't be decentralized. No one wants to lose their money because they lost some token or paper, and their computer broke.
It will be great new distributed world -- but it would also be licensed, insured, centrally approved, KYC'd, and free of chinese cryptominers and people stealing your passport numbers.
Even the basic requirement of all transactions being digitally signed is a huge step forward, especially when paired with hardware wallets[1]. It's crazy that we're still typing plain-text credit card numbers into inherently insecure computers, hoping that we'll be charged the correct amount (I recently wasn't), and that no keylogger or sketchy merchant steals or accidentally leaks the information.
Sure, dealing with digital keys and long hex addresses is clunky like sending email in 1984[2], but I feel there's a lot of real innovation thrown out with the bathwater when the whole sphere is called pointless Ponzi and so on, which is particularly odd to see in a forum dedicated to startup culture.
I think it is a terrible idea to keep any significant amount of money in any place where it is easy to lose, like a cryptocurrency. And if you are recommending cryptocurrency as a safe storage to someone who is not an expert, you should feel bad, because you are lying to them.
And the worst part of all, is cryptcoiners _never_ _listen_. In fact, directly in the message you are replying to, I wrote: "No one wants to lose their money because they lost some token or paper, and their computer broke." And what was your response? You point me to hardware wallet.
The hardware wallets are great if you are a crypto expert. If you are a regular person, you are going to be lose your recovery words and forget your password after vacation, and then you'll (almost) lose $30K like Mark Frauenfelder did [0]
Telling people to use crypto for significant amounts of money is like encouraging them to juggle live grenades. Yes, it looks cool and pretty safe if you know the trick. But if everyone starts doing this, someone will get killed.
[0] https://www.wired.com/story/i-forgot-my-pin-an-epic-tale-of-...
https://www.wired.com/story/i-forgot-my-pin-an-epic-tale-of-...
But at the end of the day it's just a negative-sum solution in search of a problem, riddled with holes big enough to drive a dump truck through, wasting the world's resources, likely created by a Bond-villain-esque racist narcotics trafficker to move his money around [1]. And all the "pricing" of every single coin is controlled by a giant fraud perpetrated by Bitfinex and Tether that bagholders are intrinsically disincentivized from exposing -- all to avoid anti-money laundering / AML/KYC regulations.
It's twelve years of solution in search of problem, with nothing legal to show for it. Except Sia, I guess, I dunno, that's what some people have told me, but that still seems better solved by AWS to me.
[1] https://www.wired.com/story/was-bitcoin-created-by-this-inte...
Some of your assertions could even be correct (who invented it, problems with architecture, energy consumption) and you would still be out of line with the wholesale dismissal of all its concepts.
> decentralization
Decentralization of currency is provably less efficient than centralization. Trust is a huge optimization, as you can see by the sheer overwhelming inefficiency of proof of work algorithms. It's tens of thousands of times less efficient. With reference to [1] a single BTC transaction releases 332 KILOGRAMS of CO2, consumes 700kWh of power and generates 87 GRAMS of e-waste. That's enough to drive a Tesla Model S from San Francisco to New York, and throwing half an iPhone out the window en route. And that's without paying for the fill-ups on the way.
Then there's the pragmatic: every stumble down the timeline winds up with all coins lost. We're at 20% of BTC lost already, since there's nobody to appeal to, you're just SOL.
> anarchism
Anarchy is not an effective way to ... anything. If there are some proven successes of anarchy at scale please do cite them.
But without that, the entire "anarchist" crypto space has shown as soon as you open the door to the architecture, scammers and schemers follow through immediately. [2] The entire pricing structure of all cryptocurrencies has centralized thanks to anarchy and is centrally controlled via Bitfinex' totally oversight-free generation of billions of dollars in fake money in Tether. This is just the tip of the iceberg.
> applied cryptographic research
Doesn't matter if they're pointing in the wrong direction.
> real-world improvements to banking and the exchange of currency
Everything crypto does can be done better, faster and cheaper with traditional currency since it's not boat anchored to the inefficiency of decentralization.
Not to mention, it fails at even the most basic aspects of modern currency theory by being deflationary.
[1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption
[2] https://www.newyorker.com/humor/daily-shouts/l-p-d-libertari...
Is there a need it fulfills, or some advantage over one of the thousands of existing ones?