Literally nobody knows more about what's happening at Tesla than Elon Musk does. If he thinks it's too high, that's incredibly material information.
It's entirely rational to think it's equivalent to "I saw the non-public reports of sales projections and turns out they're plummeting" or something similar.
And therefore that Tesla is overvalued and you ought to sell, and buy back again only when it's at a price that takes that into account.
It's Wall Street's job to react to all publicly available information at the moment it becomes available. Statements by a CEO are very much included in that.
What the heck do day traders or swords have to do with it? Stock prices are determined mainly by large funds, like the ones that invest people's pensions.
But if one tweet is worth 1/9th as much as all the other public information you've used to arrive at that estimate, then I don't have a whole lot of faith in your number.
128 ETFs have Tesla in them and 55 have it as a top 15% position. Those ETFs likely have rules based on the sort of drop we saw today.
It’s easy to speak personally about not being an active trader but a careless tweets like this have consequences and can hurt people. The only argument to be made is that Elon doesn’t understand the effects of a tweet like this but I think we all know he’s a pretty smart guy.
* General counsel quit
* Board no longer has insurance, Musk is "insuring" with . . . Tesla shares
* The Q1 financials are extremely suspicious
* Musk's meltdown during the ER call
* Musk's actions in the NASA conference
* Musk's meltdown on Twitter
* Musk's meltdown basically guaranteeing another SEC investigation
As a professional, you really have to check if it's in your client's best interests to continue to be exposed to this.
Sometimes I wonder if this is just an attention-seeking thing. People feel lonely, and then they say dramatic things to get attention. "Tesla is overvalued" -> stock tanks -> "hey people notice that I exist".
I have a lot of friends that I met playing games and this is a super common tactic. Instead of messaging me with "hey, want to play?" I get "i'm thinking about killing myself". The end result is the same, we play the game. I personally find it more enjoyable to play as a fun way to kill some free time, but they must get better results when their friends think they're distracting them from a suicide attempt. So they use what works.
I have to think that Elon Musk is up to something similar. I wonder if he has a therapist. It could help.
Or maybe he wants to sell the company and thinks it needed to drop X% before a buyer would emerge.
There is nothing absurd about the fact he's an insider, and has access to the vast amounts of information, that people have trusted him with billions of dollars and that the flow of information is governed by rules, and it's an issue if integrity.
It's a lot of money and responsibility, it's not a joke.
Nobody is concerned that he Tweets weird things about his GF, that's fine, but he can't tweet things that need to carefully communicated, it's just irresponsible.
He also said it's too high when the stock was around 200
Koch Industries, for example, is privately held.
It has to do with insiders and public information regarding a publicly-traded company worth many billions of dollars.
Musk has an agreement with said investors and is bound by a bunch of rules he has agreed to.
He's a fool and it could really hurt him someday.
He really needs to stop tweeting about the stock.
He's not permitted to tweet anything that may materially impact the stock without prior board or general counsel approval, per his contempt agreement.
Obviously Jay Clayton is going to let him get away with it just like his prior violation of the Consent Decree, but for the brief period of time that the market forgets the SEC is toothless when it comes to Musk, this is nominally a big deal.
Isn't the actual SEC agreement a lot more specific than that? This first article [1] I found in a quick search from last year has a specific list, he has to have it cleared for including any of:
• any information about the company’s financial condition or guidance, potential or proposed mergers, acquisitions or joint ventures,
• production numbers or sales or delivery number (actual, forecasted, or projected),
• new or proposed business lines that are unrelated to then-existing business lines (presently includes vehicles, transportation, and sustainable energy products);
• projection, forecast, or estimate numbers regarding Tesla’s business that have not been previously published in official company guidance
• events regarding the company’s securities (including Musk’s acquisition or disposition of shares)
• nonpublic legal or regulatory findings or decisions;
• any event requiring the filing of a Form 8-K such as a change in control or a change in the company’s directors; any principal executive officer, president, principal financial officer, principal accounting officer, principal operating officer, or any person performing similar functions
Were there other more general terms? If not, does pure opinion of "lol it's up too high" actually violate the letter of any of those? I guess it could be argued that maybe he's saying that due to information he knows that other people don't, but it's not itself disclosing anything at all.
May get an investigation, but if internally there has been nothing of material impact (and he didn't benefit in any way) and it's just Elon Musk going off I'm not sure it's a matter for the SEC vs the board and shareholders. But his genius/drive and crazy/lack of control are pretty well known quantities at this point and tied together. If he's not violating any actual laws and a majority of shareholders are fine taking the bad with the good vs other mixtures of bad and good (safe and conservative but low vision for example) that seems like it'd be up to them?
----
1: https://techcrunch.com/2019/04/26/elon-musk-sec-agree-to-gui...
It's also absolutely "any information about the company’s financial condition or guidance".
I don't see any way this doesn't fall in the list of bullets. Saying the stock price is too high is nothing but a guidance as to the company's financial condition.
That was my first glance interpretation, but I genuinely was curious if people with more legal knowledge would know if it was a correct one. Is the stock price actually part of "Tesla's business" in this context or a reflection of Tesla's business, with the actual numbers about that being the kinds of things that go into company guidance and reports. Additionally, "it should be lower" doesn't seem like it's at all literally a "projection, forecast, or estimate" but a statement of opinion. If said opinion isn't based on undisclosed fact is it a violation? Or is there precedent (seriously) that anything a CEO says inherently is going to be an issue because they can't possibly avoid knowing private info? Normally CEOs at big public corps are more careful by default so I'm kind of curious where it's come up before. That'd tie into the "guidance" aspect too it seems.
Anyway, to be clear this isn't meant to defend him per se it's just that I find law and how the specificity of language in it plays out interesting, so I was curious about other readings.
I'm sorry, whose fault is it that Wall Street react to tweets? I mean really, If I'm long on Tesla (I'm not, I own none of their stock unless it's somehow tied up in my 401K) am I selling all my stock because Elon said he thinks it's too high? No, that would be stupid. Sounds like day traders/HFT's are the ones that choose to react to this stuff and then get burned and I have zero compassion for that. Live by the sword...