News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by jessehorne on Friday May 01, 2020 @11:18AM (#23042842)
Lead developer here. Ameelio is a non-profit that's building free technology to transform corrections and criminal justice. We've recently launched Letters, our first application that lets loved-ones of incarcerated individuals send physical mail for free. Currently, the situation is that two corporations own communication throughout the prisons and jails in the U.S (Global Tel Link and Securus). They charge ridiculous amounts of money just so that you can stay in contact with your loved-ones. We're hoping to change that.

I actually discovered Ameelio last year through a Hacker News post (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21129557) that didn't gain much attention. Zo, the founder, had reached out looking for support and contributors through a hiring post. When I read the post, I decided to look more into the project. My first thought was just "Wow!". I really vibed with the concept because it's something that hits really close to home.

I've had friends and family that were incarcerated before so I know exactly what it's like dealing with the struggles that come from that experience. When someone is incarcerated, it's not just a punishment for them. It's an attack on their families, as well. In my experience, poverty is oftentimes a direct cause for incarceration. Mistakes are made and you get put into a situation, a system, that doesn't value reformation, but instead looks to profit. To communicate with a loved-one on the inside means spending money that you don't have. If your family is struggling financially, it means that you're out of luck. This shouldn't be the case.

I believe that a system focused on reformation would be much better for our society than a system based on profit. Why should a corporation be able to take control of communication between an incarcerated individual and their loved-ones meahwhile charging high prices knowing that it's their only option? Why have we allowed that to happen? Being a part of this project is my way of stepping up and making sure we can deliver an alternative option for those families that are struggling.

I've received amazing support from this community before and thanks to you guys I've been able to focus my efforts on projects like this. Any and all feedback is welcome. If you're interested in using our app then feel free to check it out. It's free and we'll do all that we can to keep it that way.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by flanbiscuit on Friday May 01, 2020 @06:15PM (#23047092)
"Currently, the situation is that two corporations own communication throughout the prisons and jails in the U.S (JPay and Securus)."

Did you experience any issues trying to get into this space? Any push back from the companies mentioned or from any of the state prison systems?

What a great idea! That testimonial from the blind person on your home page is very moving.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by jessehorne on Friday May 01, 2020 @06:24PM (#23047160)
First I'd like to thank you for the comment. You made me realize a mistake I made in mentioning JPay and Securus when I meant to say Global Tel Link and Securus.

As far as pushback from other companies, we haven't received any so far. There's nothing they can really do besides make their services more appealing. Currently, with Letters (our first app), it allows users to sign up, add their contacts (inmates), and then type out a letter and also are given the option to attach an image. Then we use a third party service, Lob, to print off the letter and send it. Given that we're just working with physical mail, there's absolutely nothing they can do to stop us.

One type of pushback we can receive is from facilities themselves. One facility returned one of our letters and said that you can't have anything in the letter that could be some form of encrypted message or symbol. In our case, that happened to be the bar code used by the third party service to manage their letters.

In the future, we'd like to also offer services like free video chat/messaging. In my opinion, we're not far from being able to offer those kinds of services. I can definitely imagine some sort of pushback happening in that space, but what kind specifically is TBD. I'm excited though, because if we can get to that point, we'll be literally transforming the system.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by hackermailman on Friday May 01, 2020 @09:56PM (#23048410)
You have to give wardens/politicians money to put any kind of technology in their prisons, so free video chat/messaging isn't going to happen unless some benevolent billionaire prince is funding you.

However you could do some kind of distance education via letters, remember math can be learned with just pen and paper and not the kind of shit we learn in highschool but the Terrence Tao Analysis from scratch kind. There's an old book called the Schemer's Guide by Iain Ferguson (spelling?) which is programming with pen and paper. Many opportunities here besides just communications, just an idea, I have no clue how it would work in practice.

Another idea is create social media or pen pal profiles for prisoners where they fill out a template and you just launch it for them, so they can find other people to talk to, many people inside have nobody on the outside, this is why facebook groups like Jail Mail exists and the like. Of course legal problems here, if some maniac uses your service who should be in jail.

Wikipedia search is also something I've always thought should exist via snail mail. 'What is <subject>' should return the entire wikipedia page or other encyclopedia page for convicts.

A marketplace for anonymous convicts would also be interesting that nobody has done, many of these guys/girls are experts in fitness since there's nothing else to do inside, they should be able to make some kind of money (again, depending on societal heinousness of crime) by being a motivational coach or something. I have plenty of other ideas, many of them require money/political connections which I don't have but just things I observed while in lockup wondering why are these petty criminals just rotting away in here when there's so much opportunity not just for them, but people they can personally effect to make amends for whatever they have done. I even met a few hundred song writers inside that wanted to be 'producers' and sell their rhythms or lyrics with no way to do this. Anyway good luck

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by HideousKojima on Friday May 01, 2020 @11:23PM (#23048874)
>You have to give wardens/politicians money to put any kind of technology in their prisons, so free video chat/messaging isn't going to happen unless some benevolent billionaire prince is funding you.

Having done a decent amount of IT work at prisons, this isn't really the case. What I did often see, however, is that various vendors would give a very long free trial and free hardware to the prisons I worked with, with the basic idea being to lock them in when the obscenely high normal rates kick in after the free year or however long the trial was

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by Nextgrid on Saturday May 02, 2020 @11:56AM (#23052470)
An offline Wikipedia by mail could be a good idea. When a page is printed and sent, every link should be numbered and they can mail back a letter with link numbers and get back the Wikipedia pages for those links, allowing them to browse it that way.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by grahamburger on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:10PM (#23047447)
Honest question, because I have no idea how this all works: if people can just send letters for the cost of a stamp then why do they use Global Tel Link or Securus?

Really great thing you're doing here, I hope it all works out.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by gavinray on Friday May 01, 2020 @08:38PM (#23047985)
If you think the letter prices are bad, try:

- $3.15/15 mins for a domestic phone call

- $15/20 mins video call/teleconference if your jail/prison has them and you/someone else are willing to fork out that much (You may be there a while and so have to stretch whatever money you have left as far as possible)

- I don't even want to know how much for an international call

- $1 for a single pack of ramen

- $5 for a 5oz bag of freeze-dried coffee

And even if you have the money, you'd better hope someone picks up when you get your phonecall and/or that you know people's addresses or phone-numbers offhand.

US Justice system is a nightmare.

Gotta love JPay, Bob Barker, and Aramark.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by syshum on Saturday May 02, 2020 @08:19AM (#23051305)
>US Justice system is a nightmare.

I would stop calling it a justice system, we have a legal system for which any "justice" is by pure coincidence

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by garrettgrimsley on Friday May 01, 2020 @10:43PM (#23048672)
Not OP, but I spent 11 months technically in US Federal custody, but in practice I was incarcerated in various county jails [0] that they contract with. I have experience with PayTel and Securus. At the facilities I housed in the digital > printed letter systems were not offered [1], everything was through USPS or your standard parcel carriers for packages. Books from outside were allowed. Global Tel Link, Securus, and PayTel have a very literal captive customer base when it comes to phone communications. While almost everyone wrote letters, a phone call is a much different form of communication. You can actually have a live conversation with a loved one! You can hear their voice, and respond in real time. For this reason, we paid the price demanded by the companies. In my state of North Carolina, the maximum price of a local call through PayTel was $.40/minute. The long-distance rates were cheaper, and so people would get Google voice numbers to get the cheaper rate.

[0] Wake County Detention Center, Edgecombe County Jail, and Albemarle District Jail.

[1] I could absolutely see these systems being utilized. They could take the roundtrip latency of text-based communication down to a day if the facility had a kiosk from which we could send replies. I was told by people on the yard that this is how CorrLinks works.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by tyingq on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:33PM (#23047594)
They use jPay and similar because it's faster. Typically in the incarcerated person's hand in a day or two.

USPS takes longer, then the prison contraband checking process, etc.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by bdcravens on Friday May 01, 2020 @08:17PM (#23047837)
I believe jPay letters are printed out at the facilities and then distributed
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by tyingq on Friday May 01, 2020 @08:40PM (#23048006)
Yes, that's correct.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by jessehorne on Friday May 01, 2020 @07:31PM (#23047583)
The benefits of using those services are that communication is much faster when you can just write up a message on your phone or computer and click "send". If you can afford it, it's the preferred way to go. It's better than having to wait for days upon days, and even weeks for your letter to arrive. Even though from what I've heard, a letter is much more personal and very much appreciated.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by FpUser on Friday May 01, 2020 @10:06PM (#23048470)
"One type of pushback we can receive is from facilities themselves. One facility returned one of our letters and said that you can't have anything in the letter that could be some form of encrypted message or symbol. In our case, that happened to be the bar code used by the third party service to manage their letters."

Here is example of bad scenario which I sincerely hope will never happen. Anything containing image (letter itself included) can be considered as encrypted due to a tech like steganography. They can get really creative there.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by zrm on Friday May 01, 2020 @11:09PM (#23048815)
You can do the same thing with text as well, or any message that contains any entropy whatsoever.

There isn't one type of message where this is possible and another where it isn't. If you allow two parties to communicate at all, they could really be communicating about anything.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by syshum on Saturday May 02, 2020 @08:21AM (#23051319)
The steganography your talking about really only works in digital formats, not printed

in this case "code messages" can be just as easily hidden in the text of the letter (in fact probably easier) then in the printed out image

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by FpUser on Saturday May 02, 2020 @03:36PM (#23054292)
You are wrong. There is a printable steganography along with the pure digital.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by rhizome on Saturday May 02, 2020 @03:10PM (#23054115)
I love this idea and I'm sure the only reason I overlooked their job ad here was because they were only looking for front-end'ers, but this is what I can't figure out (or find anywhere): what is the basis for disruption?

The incumbent providers have contracts, long-term ones with revenue shares for the management of the facilities, so what is Ameelio's route around that? Is it the ubiquity (to whatever degree) of Internet access? Is it the savings of digital letters printed locally? I can't tell.

There are relatively set-in-stone relationships here, and I would love to know what their chisel is. I would also accept that it's a trade secret or other special sauce, which I accept as a legitimate strategy when dealing with bribe- and kickback-driven institutions.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by nyxtom on Friday May 01, 2020 @10:39PM (#23048660)
Speaking from personal experience in my family, this hits close to home as well. The for profit system is an absolute travesty and horrible circumstance. Thank you for spending your time working on something to fight back against this gross system.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by f-securus on Saturday May 02, 2020 @03:13AM (#23049983)
The prices charged by Securus and other 3rd party services provided to jails are ridiculous and predatory. Competition would be great but I’m not sure they will allow it to happen without a fight.

They make so much money and portions of that money are shared with the jails the pessimist in me doesn’t see there ever being a free option for instant communication. I appreciate the effort and I think this space has a lot of room for improvement. Godspeed!

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by kruzerkc on Saturday May 02, 2020 @03:44AM (#23050133)
What do you think are the best strategies to win that fight?
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 03, 2020 @11:10AM (#23059439)
Lobbying Congress to use federal statue to prevent predatory behavior. What that looks like would be up to a domain expert. Price controls on communication services, prohibiting kickbacks to prisons, requiring comms be free and subsidized by government, or some combination of the above.

If you can show how inexpensive it is to provide the service, it becomes straightforward to punch holes in the story predatory for profits are using to profiteer from the situation.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by everfree on Saturday May 02, 2020 @01:19AM (#23049468)
The letter to the inmate on the front page says "I really enjoy the work we are doing, I could see myself staying here for a long time."

Is it just me or is the specific wording of this not in the greatest taste?

The letter also has some grammar errors.

Not to detract from the good this company is doing.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by jessehorne on Sunday May 03, 2020 @12:23PM (#23059977)
I've passed on that feedback and I agree. We'll get that changed!
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by pkphilip on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:04AM (#23049678)
Amazing work! More power to you and others involved in this. I can imagine this is a huge blessing to the people involved. Thank you for doing this.
Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by tsjq on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:28AM (#23049792)
>I believe that a system focused on reformation would be much better for our society than a system based on profit. Why should a corporation be able to take control of communication between an incarcerated individual and their loved-ones meahwhile charging high prices knowing that it's their only option?

fantastic points. I totally agree with you.

Re:Show HN: Ameelio.org – Free Prison Communication Platform by FpUser on Friday May 01, 2020 @10:02PM (#23048442)
Thank you people for being human and trying to fight that horrible for profit prison system which I think is a crime on its own.