Speculating, but the kind of fund I would imagine buys their product would be in the 5bn+ AUM range, who has broad exposure to a bunch of mark-to-unicorn venture backed startups in their book.
It'd be like %2 Universa, %60 index funds, and %20 buying sand hill dead dogs and F rounds as the price of admission for participation in their next fresh funds, %10 unicorn, %4 on something socially earnest and backed by someone politically connected for social climbing, a management fee, and spoilage. How close is that?
Universa being the tool that offsets the tide rolling out on those other bets.
So if you have a 4b portfolio, they're charging fees on the 4b.
But seriously, not charging SOME sort of fee on capital that is likely to be uninvested on a short-term horizon is giving investors a pretty valuable free option. I'm assuming they have a flexible mandate and are able to invest more given some sort of market conditions. Gauging that capacity and properly modeling trade sizes is extremely important for a strategy like this and is not free.
It seems necessary to make a point here since these models haven't changed for decades even though they have clearly failed many times.
... and get bailed out - which means that they are using a perfectly rational and profitable investment.
> these models haven't changed for decades even though they have clearly failed many times.
They may have failed you and the economy at large, but with very few exceptions (e.g. Lehman), they have not failed the people who are running them, which is why they keep using them.
Of course there is also a deeper culture here. For instance that students in big name universities learn standard macro economics. And then when they come to the institutions this is their default mode of thinking, even though they don't directly benefit from this. But it might be hard to reach to top of many of these institutions as a contrarian, so longterm there is not much incentive to go against established norms.
isn’t that like saying my $1 billion portfolio had a 3600% return because I invested $100 on a penny stock that went up 3600% and the rest of it was in cash.
It's like randomly picking a penny stock each year and then suddenly it's up 3600%. That's not some investing magic, it's just you doing the same thing and suddenly being right.
That's the whole premise, that inevitably they will be right.
That seems very, selective.
i would not be surprised if it much worse. if they truly had a good strategy why tell everyone?
There is also ego and prestige, and Taleb seems to desire both to a great degree.
Remember, the dotcom crash had huge drops across almost all of the tech sector for a few years straight.
Plus, 9/11 happened in that time frame and took out travel stocks.
It is those huge drops that Universa counts on.
So he would had done well - probably on the level of a Bobby Axelrod (yes, I know Bobby is fictional, but he's a great composite character of raw trading instinct based on his 9/11 trades).
They can only report results on the period of time they've been in business, but so far their strategy seems to have held up for about 15-20 years.
They seem to know what they're doing, and given the stakes, have likely thought about any pitfalls you or I could imagine, along with many others we couldn't imagine.
References:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Spitznagel
https://www.wsj.com/articles/triumph-of-the-market-pessimist...
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-09-22/how-fund-betting-e...
They guy has written 5 books about exactly what he does.
It's not a secret.
Even the Medallion fund doesn't do anything secret, they just win 50.7% of a lot of bets.
lol no comparison between the two. Medallion has the strongest NDA in exsitance. After 30 years no one knows anything about it. Taleb writes books because more money in books than his method. Simons will never write a book about his method because his method actually works. It is possible that Taleb has a secret strategy but the method he is selling to the public is not going to make you rich, nor will it generate alpha.
The returns are on the premium paid for options (or margin), not the notional (which is where fees are paid). That $4bn fund is counting its performance on only $40 million of invested capital (of the $4bn). So they are up 3600% on $40 million.
Universa’s model is they take 3.5% of a portfolio value per year and use it to buy puts over the course of a year. So at any time, maybe they have 30-60 basis points of the portfolio in puts. So they are up 3600% on 30 basis points or like 12%.
"Spitznagel included a chart in his letter showing that a portfolio invested 96.7% in the S&P 500 and 3.3% in Universa’s fund would have been unscathed in March, a month in which the U.S. equity benchmark fell 12.4%."
"The same portfolio would have produced a compounded return of 11.5% a year since March of 2008 versus 7.9% for the index."
2.6% per annum is a lot of outperformance, albeit not quite as eye popping as 3600%.