Re:0.999...= 1
by lukifer on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:13PM
(#23009188)
My argument is that "noun" is a purely human abstraction, and that phenomena that act noun-like in nature are at best snapshots of iterative processes. Within the bounds of the noun abstraction, sure, I'll cede that point.
But if one eschews that abstraction and looks at it purely as a process (I want to render 1/3 in decimal notation, then multiply that decimal notation by 3), there is always that niggling 0.000...1 remainder at every snapshot. The "never stopping" bit is what smuggles verbiness into the "0.999..." noun, while simultaneously pretending it's a static value.
But if one eschews that abstraction and looks at it purely as a process (I want to render 1/3 in decimal notation, then multiply that decimal notation by 3), there is always that niggling 0.000...1 remainder at every snapshot. The "never stopping" bit is what smuggles verbiness into the "0.999..." noun, while simultaneously pretending it's a static value.