News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by kylec on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @01:33AM (#2300069)
"You have one identity. The days of you having a different image for your work friends or co-workers and for the other people you know are probably coming to an end pretty quickly … Having two identities for yourself is an example of a lack of integrity."

It's not a lack of integrity - what people say and how people act is always based on the context it's in. There are things you'd say to your friends that you wouldn't say to your family or even other friends. It's always been this way, and it's pretty arrogant for Mark and, consequently, Facebook to assume otherwise.

This has actually pretty much pushed me off Facebook, as the only stuff I post is what falls in the relatively small subset of stuff I'd tell to my family, coworkers, boss, friends, and people that I know online.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by tallanvor on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @02:56AM (#2300216)
The lack of understanding Zuckerberg has about image is rather amazing. I think the fact that he has never had a real job - one where he could easily be fired for messing up, has a lot to do with this.

You learn very quickly when you or someone else gets hell rained down upon them from a boss who decides they did or said something inappropriate - no matter what the context or meaning was. I know I've seen people get fired, or come close to it, for saying something that I never before would have given a second thought to, but I definitely did after that.

So when it comes down to it, there is no way I'm going to risk my professional career by letting my Facebook identity be my public persona. Hell, I even have a rule against having family members friend me on Facebook.

It's not about being a different person in each setting, it's about being able to act appropriately in each setting. --Being someone who is viewed as a dependable, professional expert at work, being able to have a serious discussion with my father about my mother's Alzheimer's at home, or being able to relax and let out my inner child a bit with friends. These are all parts of me, but there's a time and place for everything. Zuckerberg doesn't understand that.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by Vivtek on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:59AM (#2301320)
I have a nephew who works for Menard's. Facebook gives Menard's specific privileges and tools to monitor the accounts of their employees. One of their rules is that management and floor employees can't socialize. At all. Well, my nephew, a floor employee has a friend who is now a manager. By which I mean that the friendship predates the employment.

They're smart enough never to post anything on Facebook about anything they do together, but a few months ago they went out for an evening on their motorcycles, and the friend and my niece posted about riding bikes on the same day.

Management talked to both of them the next morning, and pointedly threatened my nephew's job.

That is the world Mark Zuckerberg is proud of. That is the world he considers to have integrity. Instead of decrying the spread of petty fascism, he figures he can get rich selling the tools. The man is a sociopath.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by awakeasleep on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @11:15AM (#2301389)
Do you have any more information or links referring to the Facebook-Menard's deal? That sounds scandalously interesting, but I can't find anything discussing it.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by Vivtek on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @11:31AM (#2301463)
A careful read of their terms of service reveals no such language - so perhaps (gasp!) my nephew is going a little conspiracy-theory on me on that point.

But while I wipe this egg off my face, allow me to reassert that Menard's definitely does do this monitoring, even if Facebook doesn't specifically enable it - and that's the basic problem with this notion of abolishment of all anonymity.

I made some comments last week pooh-poohing the "single point of failure" aspect of Facebook identity management - but Zuckerberg's ambition certainly seems to be the single point of failure of society as a whole.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by Duff on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @08:19AM (#2300743)
I'm sure Zuckerberg gets this -- it is a pretty blatantly obvious concept. But addressing this technically is hard to do, and likely to be unsuccessful.

Think about your own rules that you posted about. How is Facebook going to successfully deal with them? What happens when you decide that some friends get to see the "inner child" and some don't? There are probably ways to accomodate these things, but they are complicated, and 80% of the hundreds of millions of users will screw it up and blame Facebook.

So Facebook deals with it by pushing it down to you and making your problems your problem. Don't want your boss to see the pictures of you doing body shots on Spring Break? Don't want your parents to know your sexual orientation? Fine -- don't post it on Facebook, or don't invite people to read it.

It's not that Facebook doesn't get it -- they just choose not to get involved.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by pnathan on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:43AM (#2301245)
Sure, it's not 'simple', but Livejournal had that feature before I even heard of Facebook. Dreamwidth took that concept and made it even more sophisticated.

Which is part of why I use Dreamwidth. Under a pseudonym, of course. :-)

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by michaelchisari on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:23AM (#2301159)
What happens when you decide that some friends get to see the "inner child" and some don't?

In Appleseed, you create an "inner child" friends circle, and post it only to them. Nobody else would know that friends circle even exists.

It's a challenge, from a UI/UX perspective, but if I could fix it in a way that is generally intuitive, with barely any funds, working in my spare time, then surely Facebook, with all it's engineers and funding can do the same.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by Duff on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @09:46PM (#2303571)
I'm sure the engineers could hack something up, no problem. The problem is that Facebook's market defines mass-market -- the unwashed masses need to be able to figure out how to do stuff. That's hard.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by reemrevnivek on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @12:53PM (#2301820)
I tried to have a rule against having professional relations as friends on Facebook, and keep my profile for my friends and family. That failed: My school and professional relationships have a Facebook presence, and try to interact via Facebook.

Therefore, I deleted my Facebook account.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by PedroCandeias on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @05:45AM (#2300487)
This. All this.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by wisty on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @01:47AM (#2300094)
Anyone trying to beat facebook should read that quote every day.

People should, in an ideal world, behave with integrity. But it's not an ideal world. My boss shouldn't care what I'm doing in my own time, but he might. The military shouldn't care if a potential recruit once tried pot at a college party, but they might. No employer should care about sexual orientation, but they probably do.

It's not about integrity. It's about living in a hypercritically judgemental society.

Choosing to remain slightly anonymous is one way to maintain your integrity. It's better than treating every statement like a PR release. Like Mark does, if he has the integrity to say everything using his own name, like he tells us to.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by PakG1 on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @04:15AM (#2300341)
I think that's missing the point of how wrong it can be. That quote frames it as a moral issue. Different ways of acting in different contexts is not a moral issue unless you're deliberately going out of your way to hide something you don't want others to learn about you because you know it's immoral (or whatever). Most differences of behaviour in most contexts is not an issue of morality, whether or not other subjects in said contexts learn about those differences.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by jasonlotito on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @08:04AM (#2300708)
To play devil's advocate here for a moment.

You state a lot of things that people shouldn't do. Isn't it kinda sad that the one thing we shouldn't be doing, being ourselves, isn't on that list? That's what this discussion is essentially about. Freedom to think what we want, be who we are?

Maybe the goal shouldn't be to hide from everyone, but to expose everyone for who we all really are? Maybe if everyone realizes how messed up everyone really is, we'll stop being so judgemental? So maybe the best way to do that is have a single identity, a single being. Sure, how you act might be different between different social groups, but that doesn't change who you are.

Maybe this is an idealist outlook, but isn't it an ideal we should be working for, not hiding from?

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by statictype on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:46AM (#2301264)
Would you want every conversation you have with your spouse/child/parent to be available to every single other person you know?

Regardless of how sincere and honest those conversations may be?

If not, then this idea that "the days of you having a different image for your work friends or co-workers and for the other people you know" is very much not over.

The fact is, people have private interactions with other people all the time and they expect it to be private and society accepts that it's perfectly alright and natural for this to happen.

When I'm with someone else and they get a call from someone close to them, I excuse myself from the conversation in some way. That's just the polite thing to do.

This idea that all this is coming to an end is just wishful fantasy on the part of the owner of a site who's existence and popularity probably depends on this being true.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by jasonlotito on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @12:07PM (#2301621)
Again, playing devil's advocate...

The argument is valid, but doesn't apply in this case.

> Would you want every conversation you have with your spouse/child/parent to be available to every single other person you know?

No, of course not. However, this is forcing private stuff public. Nothing is being forced here. Certain sites will require you to log in with your Facebook identity. You choose to interact with them in this manner, or you choose not to. If you comment in Facebook comments, you are doing so in a public forum.

> The fact is, people have private interactions with other people all the time and they expect it to be private and society accepts that it's perfectly alright and natural for this to happen.

This doesn't change anything. The proposal isn't to share your private life. Simply to make public comments just that, public. If you want things to remain private, keep them private.

Basically, you're arguing for something that isn't a problem.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by narag on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @08:48AM (#2300808)
Often people are discouraged to talk their mind until they feel that enough people thinks the same way. Anonimity allows that. You first see that there's a lot of people of your same opinion, then you "come out":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abilene_paradox

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by jasonlotito on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @12:12PM (#2301649)
Still playing the devils advocate here...

> Often people are discouraged to talk their mind until they feel that enough people thinks the same way.

This is the case because people are so judgemental. As I posted in my original comment, eliminating the judgemental attitude of the majority of people would help with this.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by narag on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @03:59PM (#2302569)
Why do you call it "devil's advocate"? I agree! I agreed to your previous comment too. "Coming out" seems to has been very useful for gays' rights. Maybe the question is in which point a controversy is. Is the controversial option legal? Or even are there laws that protect it?

Current revolutions or cannabis are counter-examples.

I'd also suggest to think about the asymmetry of responses. You might express your opinions in public, but someone could choose to anonymously not to hire you because of them.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by camdykeman on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @11:53AM (#2301555)
Statictype, to be fair this isnt intended to post every conversation with your spouse/family/whatever online for every one to see...unless you happen to do those things on forums and product-review sections of online retailers.

This incorporation by Facebook, to my understanding, is just a way of legitimizing these mediums of communication. It will help keep spammers at bay and maybe discourage people from reviewing a product as "a stupid piece of shit" and instead contribute something of value.

I agree that the vision of Facebook becoming a worldwide identity database is unsettling, but this particular development makes some sense. Remember that not ALL conversations need to occur online and we can still use the phone or even gasp speak face to face. On what grounds should a person posting to a public space not be held accountable for what they are saying? Besides, in this case the only comments your boss would gain access to are ones like "The Toast-Matic is a fantastic toaster, and I like it for the following reasons: blah blah...". If my boss really wants to waste time sorting through that crap, party on.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by statictype on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @12:08PM (#2301627)
I understand what you're saying. My point was that the comment made by Mark Zuckerberg are clearly false (unless they were lifted out of context). There clearly are many situations where you do want to maintain different identities.

On the other hand, I agree with the sentiment that comments should have a public identifiable handle attached to it for the reasons you've said.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by michaelchisari on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:14AM (#2301123)
Anyone trying to beat facebook should read that quote every day.

I've printed it out and posted it on my desktop monitor with a trollface picture next to it.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by greyman on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @05:08AM (#2300436)
I think it is not even an issue of the society being judgemental. In the real world, if you say something, you always say it in a certain context (family, friends, coworker, etc...). It looks like Facebook is trying to remove that context.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by electromagnetic on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @06:39AM (#2300563)
Facebook is trying to be that douche' friend who takes something out of context you said in front of a couple of friends and goes babbling it to everyone they know you know.

I don't think FB is making itself a good app when it's actively trying to make itself the bottom of a social circle. Not the foundation of a social circle, but the scum sucking parasite that's only in your social circle because it just happens to be in everyone else's too.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by VladRussian on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @02:38AM (#2300179)
>People should, in an ideal world, behave with integrity.

any proof?

>Choosing to remain slightly anonymous is one way to maintain your integrity.

or just my personal choice to utilize such a freedom. The freedom to have multiple personalities. Internet provides the ability to have such virtual personalities, the ability the real world clearly lacks.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by wiredfool on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @01:44AM (#2300088)
Multiple identities are real, online and in meatspace. You all see a different 'me' than my wife or kids see, or my oarents see, or my coworkers.

I manage different identities online, depending on what I've got invested in the community. Some places, I'm the voice of reason, such as it is. Some places, I'm anonymous, because there are not entirely sane people and its a local forum, and people could know where I live. It's not dishonest, it's real. I do try to avoid having multiple personalities in one community though, since that's just rude.

So, I'm not using facebook's facet flattening system.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by natfriedman on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @02:11AM (#2300137)
Right, try telling that to the tour guide I met in Burma last week whose real opinions about his country's government could get him put into a work camp (and who is a facebook user, like almost everyone we met in Burma).
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by brlewis on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @10:59AM (#2301317)
Even your comment right there gives too much information. I think you should have withheld the person's line of work.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by billybob on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @08:27AM (#2300759)
Agreed. In fact, this is a big part of why I dislike Facebook: the public nature of conversation distorts it.

I have wonderful, deep conversations with my wife. I also have deep conversations with my best friend. I love them both, and I'm not hiding anything from either one. But the intimacy and tone of either conversation would be ruined by the presence of the other person. This isn't about duplicity; it's about the nature of friendship. The sense of humor between us, the shared memories, the references we don't have to explain - those are all different.

Public conversation like wall posts lacks all of that. It's not inimate; it's self-conscious. It inherently lacks depth because it's dumbed down to the lowest common denominator for everyone who will see it. It's more like performance art than real conversation.

That's why I'll take email over wall posts any day. I want to hear what you have to say to ME, not what you want everyone else seeing you say to me. It's not about secrets, it's about real, personal contact.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by benohear on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @02:15AM (#2300143)
That's especially true about humor. I can't remember the source, but "you can joke about anything, only not with everyone" rings true to me.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by nicolasp on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @05:49AM (#2300493)
French humorist Pierre Desproges originally made that comment ("On peut rire de tout, mais pas avec tout le monde").
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by bigiain on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @04:58AM (#2300417)
An interesting contrast to Eric Schmidt's view while he was CEO of Google:

"every young person one day will be entitled automatically to change his or her name on reaching adulthood in order to disown youthful hijinks stored on their friends' social media sites."

Possibly apocryphal or taken out of context if HoPo is the best reference I can find: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/08/16/google-ceo-eric-sch...

(conspiracy theory: I _did_ search Google - unsuccessfully - to try and find authoritative sources for that quote...)

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by eneveu on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @06:14AM (#2300525)
"It's not a lack of integrity - what people say and how people act is always based on the context it's in. There are things you'd say to your friends that you wouldn't say to your family or even other friends."

Exactly. Some people say "Google does not get social", but this Google UX researcher, at least, got it:

http://www.slideshare.net/padday/the-real-life-social-networ... (discussion at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1867807)

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by credo on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @03:03AM (#2300225)
I agree but would add that it is not just about context.

imo a desire for privacy is not the same thing as a "lack of integrity".

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by pasbesoin on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @01:23PM (#2301966)
Comments like these make me wonder to what extent Zuckerberg is a two-dimensional figurehead. Maybe not as incompetent as some of our politicians, but nonetheless now the focal point for a lot of significant activity that is, at the least, outside his domain of expertise.

(How much of it is still him, and how much (to what extent) is he, at this point, simply along for the ride?)

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by toptiger on Thursday March 17, 2011 @08:42AM (#2335925)
"Two identities = lack of integrity" is the kind of simplistic statement most often used by fascists, racists and other small minds. Unfortunately, this approach is often very persuasive for those who don't stop to think about what it really means.

Stop and look at some of the simple, dumb statements you see in a typical advertising or political campaign.

Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by stuartjmoore on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @09:22AM (#2300895)
Bad start-up idea: a website that lets people control multiple Facebook accounts as if they're one account with different "friend contexts". Or, something that makes lists on Facebook useful.
Re:New Facebook Feature Empowers the Dangerous "Comment Nazis" by Vivtek on Tuesday March 08, 2011 @11:02AM (#2301330)
It's a good technical idea, bad start-up idea. Facebook would nuke it on sight.