Re:The pandemic is bringing us closer to our robot takeout f...
by Transfinity on Sunday April 26, 2020 @12:53PM
(#22988387)
Look at how much trouble NYC has had building new subways over the last few decades. That's a system that already works (pretty) well, that people trust and believe in and are invested in, and yet they can barely get enough fiscal buy in to do maintenance.
Re:The pandemic is bringing us closer to our robot takeout f...
by crazygringo on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:28PM
(#22988627)
Sure, but the subways did get built. The 2nd Ave line was built over the past decade and is running now.
Nobody's saying it's easy. But stuff gets built all the time. Saying it's too hard in principle and couldn't happen seems demonstrably... false.
Re:The pandemic is bringing us closer to our robot takeout f...
by fragmede on Sunday April 26, 2020 @01:40PM
(#22988709)
The system also doesn't have to go up all at once. Delivery app aren't going anywhere, but rather than try and implement an unproven system city wide, at impossible expense, build one residential skyscraper (which is still going to be O($100 million), mind you), and equip it with a building-sized set of dumb-waiters (public-private option, with the government providing incentives). Either to the apartment directly or even just to the right floor. See how that gets used. Delivery people still have to come to the premises, but can send the food up. Use this to figure out what level of security is needed and such.
But I believe you're being far too pessimistic as to organizing it. The "omnipotent creature" to organize it just... city government. Roads and utilities are already built/managed well enough. You're right it won't "self-organize" -- the city has to contract and build it. It's paid for, like other large projects are, out of bonds paid off over deacdes by taxes, and/or contracts to operate. Nobody has to "outlaw the old system".
You just build it gradually, and UPS/USPS/etc. will take advantage of it wherever it can (for all addresses supported) because it will be by definition cheaper.
Governments manage big infrastructure projects all the time. This is how major bridges and tunnels get built. All of your arguments apply to pretty much most big government projects.
> Nobody is signing up for those taxes so they can get their pizza or Amazon delivery via a tube instead.
My point is that yes they absolutely will if it's cheaper in the end. Making up numbers, if you spend $400/year on last-mile shipping and delivery, it's financed by bonds up-front, and the extra taxes are on average $200/year/person for the next 40 years (but with progressive taxation)... then of course people would be signing up for that. Vastly better delivery service for half the price? Why wouldn't they be?