I think it’s a great model, but it breaks down when the new version is a feature/usability regression vs the old version.
Once that started happening more often than not, the “aas” models came out, where the vendors started force upgrading users instead of trying to compete with version N-1.
This is worse for the users, but better for deadline-focused middle management, so it’s become incredibly popular.
Important customers could get a hotfix. For anyone else reporting bugs was pointless.
I'd also add that Microsoft used to be notoriously bad at security, such that even Mac owners would make fun of them. We're still dealing with the design decisions made during that era. It's only since XP SP1 that security was taken more seriously and it wasn't until Vista that they truly started to grapple with the whole mess from the ground up.
Although, in reality, Mac owners really only were secure by way of being too few and far between to bother writing malware for.
Just this past year, Apple essentially implemented UAC into OS X.