News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Mess with Texas by wolco on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:13PM (#22940691)
In fairness the Canadian army doesn't really need you and to get combat you really need to put in your time and volunteer for the post. In the US army depending on the timeframe you could be through basic training and in a combat zone in less than a year.
Re:Don't Mess with Texas by munk-a on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:41PM (#22940873)
I'm not certain how easy it is in the forces to get cushy stay at home jobs, but Canada actually contributes disproportionately highly to armed conflict when compared to the US, it has participated heavily in quite a few recent actions[1]. Both armed forces have logistical and bureaucratic arms along but only the US (AFAICT) has a dedicated stay-at-home path via the National Guard.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_history_of_Canada#Pos...

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:18AM (#22942105)
> dedicated stay-at-home path via the National Guard

I thought last decade that dedicated stay-at-home path meant you ended up in Iraq or Afghanistan. In other words not so stay-at-home.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by blaser-waffle on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:54PM (#22948290)
Indeed -- many National Guard units have done 4+ deployments to Afghanistan or Iraq.

There was an article a while back about how the Guard used to be fat-ass weekend warriors with gear that was EOL or falling apart. After damn near 20 years of Afghanistan and Iraq most of those Guard units have been multiple times and are equipped and trained to something that resembles actually full-time line units. The Active Duty troopers still get better gear and training, but the Reserves & Guard are a completely different creature than a few decades ago.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by pwaivers on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:55PM (#22940951)
What source do you have that Canada has disproportionate contributions, compared to the US? The Wikipedia page doesn't say that.
Re:Don't Mess with Texas by wolco on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:49PM (#22941917)
Canada spends disproportionately low compared to the US. It's been a source of major compliants in NATO.

1.2526% vs 3+%

Canada does join many more conflicts than it should. But sometimes doesn't have the equipment to get there/back to survive (wearing green camo instead of brown in the desert is a major disadvantage).

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by claviska on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:26AM (#22942163)
There is zero guarantee as National Guard that you won’t be deployed. You can be activated at the state or federal level anytime.

Source: I’m an active duty Army veteran and have extended family in a guard unit that’s currently deployed OCONUS.

[dead]
Re:Don't Mess with Texas by TechBro8615 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:24PM (#22941399)
Funny, because Canada (and other countries) likely wouldn’t be able to get away with having such a small army if it were not for the protection afforded by US power projection. It’s easy to look at the large military in the US and feel morally superior living in a country with a small military. But most likely that country benefits from an alliance with the US. The fact that the US has such a large military is a major reason why many other countries do not need one.
Re:Don't Mess with Texas by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:49PM (#22941549)
I don’t think that is true, especially when you consider that if the USA didn’t project power, Russia might not either, and then the Canadian military is just exchanging bottles of liquor with the Danes.

The fact that the world is polarized around two or three superpowers creates its own problems for the other counties. The USA not projecting any power wouldn’t necessarily require its former allies to acquire bigger militaries. The size of the EU’s combined military is already comparable to Russia’s for example. Japan and South Korea would be in much harder spots, comparatively.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by TechBro8615 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:54PM (#22941573)
Well, yes, if no country had a military then no country would need a military. But that’s a rather moot point isn’t it? World peace would be nice but it doesn’t look to be achievable in our lifetimes, and arguably goes against human nature.

It’s also worth noting that the military does a lot more than perpetuate violence. It’s really a jobs program more than anything. And soldiers are often on the front lines of humanitarian disasters, as well. Just look at the hospital they built in New York for one recent example.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by mirimir on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @07:03AM (#22944279)
> Well, yes, if no country had a military then no country would need a military.

It's always seemed that way to me. Indeed, you could pretty much replace "military" with "national government" in that sentence.

But anyway, it'll likely never happen. Unless we get into a war with aliens, I guess.

I did love Vinge's "bobble" concept. Wherein individuals became as powerful as governments. Or at least, could escape from them across time. And send them across time, as well.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by MR4D on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:31PM (#22941817)
> The size of the EU’s combined military is already comparable to Russia’s for example

As an American, I’d bet on the Russians winning that fight every time. Size of force means nothing here. Likewise with the Israelis - they punch above their weight.

Not trying to put words in your mouth, as I don’t think you meant that at all, but I wanted to show that projection of power doesn’t necessarily equal headcount.

The French for instance, have nuclear weapons. If they were really about to lose their country, they could unleash some serious devastation.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by barry-cotter on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:56PM (#22941589)
> Funny, because Canada (and other countries) likely wouldn’t be able to get away with having such a small army if it were not for the protection afforded by US power projection.

Not true in the Canadian case. Over 90% of the Canadian population is within 100 miles of the US border and they'd have no chance in a conflict with the US. They could just straight up abolish their military like Costa Rica and it would have almost no effect on their security situation. Having an ocean between you and any potential enemies that you can actually defend against is different from genuine free riders like Germany.

Re:Don't Mess with Texas by t0mas88 on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @06:45AM (#22944178)
I think this is far less about violence vs non-violent nations etc. It is more a political and economical decision. The US spends huge amounts on military equipments that's made by their own national manufacturers, so all that money also creates jobs in the US and pays taxes. Others spend way less, because they're not getting jobs or taxes back for it, so they only consider the needs in terms of defending their country. With virtually no conflicts around most countries that amount just isn't very high.

Trump spouts a lot of hot air about Europe not doing their part, but that's more for internal politics to make him look tough and "America first" to the average American. On the European side of the water he is more and more just ignored, doesn't even make the media most of the time. Considering Trump is 73 years old, I'm sure he will be dead long before anything really changes in military spending by others. And deep down he also knows that, it's all political theater.