News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On WD Red NAS Drives by j45 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:25AM (#22935730)
As an owner of Red drives, it’s surprising WD would trot out a new acronym for in device features to a group already literate in acronyms.

It just makes me wonder how easily they believe their customer base can be placated.

Had I known I was not receiving what I thought I had purchased, I would have likely purchased a different drive.

The least WD could do is unilaterally extend the warranty of these misrepresented drives to easily deal with any fears, if they really believe in their products as such.

It will be interesting to see if the MTTB on these drives is in a smaller spectrum of time.

Re:On WD Red NAS Drives by spartas on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:50AM (#22936043)
Extending the warranties on SMR drives does _nothing_ to solve the performance issues. The drives were marketed for use in NAS RAID systems, but the abysmal performance (due to the drives' SMR) in many cases will cause the NAS or RAID system to kick out the drive as a bad drive.

Given that RAID rebuild times are increasing as the size of the drives are increasing, and SMR exacerbates the longer rebuild times, these drives should not be used in the NAS or RAID systems for which that they were marketed.

By obfuscating the use of SMR in their WD Red line, WD willfully and intentionally harmed their customers.

Re:On WD Red NAS Drives by j45 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:47PM (#22940902)
I agree that it was completely misleading and that extending warranties solves nothing SMR related specifically for performance.

An advance ship program to swap drives with SMR is what should happen.