Re:The SF Anti-Mask League of 1919
by em500 on Monday April 20, 2020 @03:22AM
(#22921867)
Indeed, the actual numerical results in the article table shows that masks are very effective, so it's puzzling where their narrative conclusions came from.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The SF Anti-Mask League of 1919
by mixmastamyk on Monday April 20, 2020 @04:07AM
(#22922077)
Lower numbers may not have enough of an effect on transmission rates.
A log-reduction of around 0.5 isn't much. "very effective" would be like 3-4 which even this n=4 study is enough to rule out
0.5 log-load reduction is a 66% decrease. A 1.5 reduction is 96%, which is N95 standard. Starting from 2.56, a log reduction of 3-4 is impossible.
In any case, the large number of NDs (not detected) everywhere in the table, but especially inside the masks after the patient just coughed in them (which the authors struggle to explain), makes this entire experiment very suspect. (Just look at the reported results for patient 4, which make no sense at all!)
No offence you might want to brush up on your Maths and how log scales work.