News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by credit_guy on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:37AM (#22916576)
Summary for those who didn't click on the link to the actual article [1]:

- a car may need 5 kg of hydrogen for a range of 500km (bbc's claim, I'll take it at face value)

- the new "sponge" material can offer "deliverable hydrogen capacities (14.0 weight %, 46.2 g liter−1) under a combined temperature and pressure swing (77 K/100 bar → 160 K/5 bar)."

- so for 5kg of H2 you need about 100 l of this material, at a weight of about 35 kg. Not too shabby.

- however, note the conditions: you store the H2 at 77k and 100bar. So you need liquid nitrogen and quite high pressure to hold this. That might add substantial weight to the 35kg of sponge

By the way, about one year ago, there was quite some big noise on HN about a different breakthrough from Australia, where some researchers showed economic ways to store H2 in ammonia. Not sure if that got anywhere.

[1] https://science.sciencemag.org/content/368/6488/297

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by jessaustin on Sunday April 19, 2020 @05:19PM (#22918889)
Liquid anhydrous ammonia is already the obvious way to store and use hydrogen. It contains lots of hydrogen but doesn't have the embrittlement issues that elemental hydrogen does. Agricultural regions have extensive storage and distribution capacity due to its use as fertilizer, so no new technology is needed for handling ammonia. Common internal combustion engines can burn ammonia as fuel with minimal modification.

The only thing holding back the use of ammonia as energy storage is the fact that fossil fuels are still the most efficient feedstock. Once solar is more efficient, ammonia will see widespread production and use.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by mhandley on Sunday April 19, 2020 @07:14PM (#22919598)
The Royal Society's policy briefing report on Green Ammonia goes into all this in detail, and makes the case pretty well:

https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/low-carbon-e...

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by m463 on Sunday April 19, 2020 @05:27PM (#22918934)
Also it's a dangerous material to spill.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by entee on Sunday April 19, 2020 @06:21PM (#22919277)
Very much so. Would be hard to breathe at any accident site with a leak.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by rstuart4133 on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:06PM (#22920234)
But not quiet as hard to breath as 60 litres of petrol, going up in a ball of flames.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by CamperBob2 on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:47PM (#22920434)
Which doesn't happen in the real world because of the way fuel tanks are constructed. Meanwhile, anhydrous ammonia is one of those things that give experienced hazmat workers nightmares.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by jessaustin on Sunday April 19, 2020 @10:28PM (#22920618)
Most of the people who safely use anhydrous ammonia on a regular basis are farmhands, not experienced hazmat workers. The training and equipment that allows them to do that would also be available to e.g. municipal bus lines or delivery companies. Any firm that hires people to refuel its vehicles could afford this. Eventually more fool-proof nozzles and storage tanks might be developed so that regular people with personal cars could safely handle this fuel, but it will be practical for other uses long before then.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by CamperBob2 on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:00PM (#22920741)
Interestingly, the last time I heard an argument like this, it was being put forth in favor of using butane or propane as a replacement for CFC refrigerants in cars. That idea never caught on, but it's not clear if safety concerns in accidents were the reason.

At any rate, unless Farmer Brown regularly drives his fertilizer sprayer around on the farm at 70 MPH, I'm not convinced your analogy holds much more water than the anhydrous ammonia does.

Hydrogen is best thought of as an energy transfer mechanism -- an extremely lossy one at that -- not an energy source, and I don't see that changing anytime soon. It's hard to believe that ammonia-based storage is the missing factor in the hydrogen equation that we've all been searching for.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by jessaustin on Monday April 20, 2020 @06:13PM (#22929318)
You have inconsistent fears. Presumably you mention 70mph because you're afraid of explosions from vehicle collisions. Yet ammonia is much less flammable (NFPA 1) than gasoline (3), and much much less flammable than elemental hydrogen (4). Ammonia is regularly used as a refrigerant and has been for longer than CFCs have existed. It is poisonous, but no more so than many gasoline additives and less so than tetraethyllead, which was a common additive until quite recently. More to the point, when burned in an engine it produces nitrogen and water, which are much safer than ICE exhaust.

No one is proposing hydrogen or ammonia as an energy source. There are no underground deposits. They will only make sense once solar generation is efficient enough that electrolysis becomes competitive with fossil fuels. We'll know that's coming soon when hydrogen hype artists are drowned out by engineers talking about ammonia.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by dicknuckle on Monday April 20, 2020 @08:46PM (#22930632)
Side note: common air duster can be used as refrigerant in old R12 systems used in cars until the early 1990s. there's a cheap "clamp" available online that punctures the duster can to tap it for the refrigerant. As far as i know, no modifications are needed to the old R12 system besides vacuuming out which any professional air conditioning technician can do.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by kube-system on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:46PM (#22920924)
The difference being that anhydrous ammonia doesn't need to be ignited to be extremely hazardous to health.

Gasoline spills are not uncommon, but most of them go unignited.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by entee on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:24PM (#22920305)
Perhaps, though I once broke a 1L bottle of ammonium hydroxide (a strong solution of ammonia) in the lab. We literally couldn’t go in the room for 15 min. That was just 1L of not 100% ammonia, and we had a door where we could get out. Even if the ammonia isn’t flammable, you might kill occupants of a car with what is effectively a poison gas.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by greglindahl on Sunday April 19, 2020 @05:02PM (#22918763)
The main utility for ammonia is to transport energy long distances at industrial scale, not for individual vehicles.

So, for example, you'd build a huge solar farm where it's very sunny, or a huge wind farm where it's windy. And instead of running power lines, you'd ship ammonia.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by rstuart4133 on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:03PM (#22920212)
> The main utility for ammonia is to transport energy long distances at industrial scale, not for individual vehicles.

Which is exactly how it was pitched in Australia, by the government agency responsible for developing it. It was the reason it was funded.

As I recall, it was "it solar continues current downward trajectory, it will be cheaper make than it is to frack natural gas". They seemed pretty convinced of it.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by jessaustin on Sunday April 19, 2020 @05:21PM (#22918894)
Power lines are cheaper and more efficient than pipelines, and they always will be. Ammonia will be a storage medium.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by Hypx on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:23PM (#22920302)
Only for short distances. At long distances, they lose power due to resistance in the wires. Underwater power lines across oceans are also extreme expensive.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by simonebrunozzi on Sunday April 19, 2020 @07:03PM (#22919527)
Sometimes you don't have the luxury of a power line, e.g. in developing countries. Similar thing (larger scale though) happened with oil: there are still tons of oil tanks sailing around the world because a stable pipeline network is hard to build.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by greglindahl on Sunday April 19, 2020 @05:23PM (#22918905)
So, for example, a power line from Algeria to Europe is cheaper than a ship-based ammonia scheme? Or northern Australia to China or Japan?

Power lines are a winner for short distances. Pipelines some longer distances. And ships for the longest distances.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by brownbat on Sunday April 19, 2020 @07:00PM (#22919514)
You're right that there's a reason we constantly transport so much liquid fuel around the world.

But the Europe and North Africa connection is already a relatively serious proposal precisely because of the efficiency gains. It's definitely an ambitious project, but more from the politics than from the technology. Electrons are just easier than atoms, even underwater. HVDC has made long distances realistic for cables.

China's Anhui to Xinjiang HVDC link will be around 2000 miles. There's a planned HVDC submarine cable from Lincolnshire to Denmark that will be 472 miles.

So for Australia to China, we might be able to pull off Darwin to Jakarta, then Jakarta to Hong Kong within 10-20 years, if you really wanted to. Would break some records, but it's not crazy impractical.

Though with the most efficient transfers you're taking some percentage hit per mile. Closer generation is generally going to be smarter, especially if you're running cables through what would be really viable offshore wind fields.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_super_grid

https://www.power-technology.com/features/chinas-mega-transm...

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by greglindahl on Sunday April 19, 2020 @08:02PM (#22919867)
I totally agree that power lines have improved recently. That fiddles with the details, and doesn't change the fact that even if these advances pan out, there will be (very long) distances that you'll want to ship energy that will be more efficient with ships than power lines.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by brownbat on Monday April 20, 2020 @11:07AM (#22924445)
You're right to point out that tankers are phenomenally efficient, but that's _for oil_. Just as LNG is much more expensive to ship than oil, because of the increased handling complexity, any shipping of hydrogen is going to lose that advantage completely to electrification.[0]

> there will be (very long) distances that you'll want to ship energy

This is probably the real crux driving the difference in how we see this.

The main reason we have to ship hydrocarbons long distances is because those resources are so concentrated. Wind and solar aren't perfectly distributed, but they are so much more distributed that local generation would be much more efficient than transporting anything much beyond what current HVDC projects can easily handle.

So, sure, we're not going to stretch a cable for 12,000 miles. But we're also not going to build a solar farm in Saudi Arabia to generate hydrogen to ship to Canberra. We're just going to put a solar farm in the outback instead.

[0] "Relative costs of transporting electrical and chemical energy" by Saadi, Lewis, and MacFarland, studies this very question.

Even in that report, you could quibble with a lot of their assumptions that I think bias it against HVDC, project lifespans, ignoring loading and unloading costs for tankers, etc. But it's not a crazy starting place, and HVDC still beats hydrogen on $ per mile per Joule. My takeaway from it was that if we're stuck with a carbon economy, sure, we'll keep using tankers. If we're talking about going carbon neutral, the difficulties of working with hydrogen relative to oil and LNG will probably tip us back towards electrification and local generation, except in the most highly specialized of situations (fueling Antarctica or something).

The report was a good reminder why we have an oil-based economy though. It is so obnoxiously practical and well suited to everything we want to use it for. Ditching carbon will be hard.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by greglindahl on Monday April 20, 2020 @12:13PM (#22925248)
The article you mention has no discussion of ammonia, just hydrogen and LOHC. That plus your mention of shipping energy into Canberra makes me wonder if we're actually communicating with each other at all.
Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by brownbat on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @12:24PM (#22947280)
Since ammonia and LOHCs face some overlapping constraints I don't expect an order of magnitude difference in cost. But you're right, it would have been more useful with an explicit comparison.

If you are seeing stuff that suggests ammonia will get very close to parity with oil, that's really fascinating, I hope it pans out that way. The IAE is more optimistic than I am about ammonia transport, while still listing some significant hurdles:

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036031991...

I think it's a good report, and you could read it to be more convinced of either of our positions.

Sorry we're talking past each other. You did actually change my mind a bit, if it's any consolation. Agree it's too hasty to say electrons are always better than atoms, though I'm still optimistic about more supergrids. My main remaining concern is just that, as you change your power mix away from oil to generate more ammonia, or electrolytic hydrogen, or whatever, the case for shipping fuel erodes significantly, because you can just move generation closer instead.

Sorry we couldn't get to ground on this one. Thanks for your points all the same.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by rstuart4133 on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:16PM (#22920276)
Grrrr. It's efficiency is based on using a fuel cell. There seems to be a few ways around of storing Hydrogen in clever ways - this just adds to the list. But until we discover unobtainium that's as efficient as platinum in fuel cells but common and a fraction of the price, it's all a pipe dream.

Had they burnt it in an ICE, and come up with those figures then OK. As it is, when using technology that exists now it won't be 5 kg per 500km, it will 25 kg at best, and 500l of this material will be required.

Re:'Bath sponge' breakthrough could boost cleaner cars by clouddrover on Sunday April 19, 2020 @09:39PM (#22920384)
> a car may need 5 kg of hydrogen for a range of 500km (bbc's claim, I'll take it at face value)

It is about 1kg for 100km range. The Hyundai Nexo Blue has better than 600km range on 6.5kg of hydrogen:

https://www.drivingelectric.com/hyundai/nexo/1005/hyundai-ne...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyundai_Nexo