Re:Rock-Paper-Scissors: You vs. the Computer
by lkozma on Saturday March 05, 2011 @04:31AM
(#2291179)
There is, but you are not taking advantage of it as long as you choose randomly.
Imagine the other tries to exploit your imagined human non-randomness and plays rock all the time. You play totally random, so on the long term you win/lose/tie roughly same number of times.
You would be taking advantage if you played paper all the time.
Re:Rock-Paper-Scissors: You vs. the Computer
by Natsu on Saturday March 05, 2011 @04:52AM
(#2291214)
> There is, but you are not taking advantage of it as long as you choose randomly.
You're right. I was just thinking that 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 was the Nash equilibrium and not really thinking the whole thing through. Once I gave it a little more thought, I came up with the same rock example you gave.
Re:Rock-Paper-Scissors: You vs. the Computer
by heyitsnick on Saturday March 05, 2011 @05:25AM
(#2291254)
In most toy games you would be right; playing the GTO/nash equil. solution would naturally benefit from an imbalanced/exploitive style on an opponent. It's only in games like rock-papers-scissors where this isn't the game.
Re:Rock-Paper-Scissors: You vs. the Computer
by kronusaturn on Saturday March 05, 2011 @04:29AM
(#2291176)
Yes, you're misunderstanding the statistics a bit. If you're choosing your moves randomly, your win rate will always be 1/3 no matter how non-random the computer's moves are... even if it keeps choosing the same thing over and over.
But maybe I committed a statistical fallacy somewhere in that line of reasoning, because it sure didn't win.