What does this have to do with immigration? The US already has a restrictive (and arcane) immigration system. You've just thrown an assortment of right-wing talking points together.
> social policy academics from the countries with higher social safety nets, they will tell you the same thing
You pulled this straight from your ass.
The great thing about the way large corporations control Europe is that you never hear about it (Germany is the classic example of this, massive wealth inequality, large number of billionaires, they are basically invisible). But the social security system in Europe was designed by large corporations ().
Immigration has everything to do with social policy. It also has everything to do with politics generally.
Nope. I have an MSc in Politics and studied comparative European social policy. I have met these academics. To cut a long story short: Esping-Andersen's Three Worlds Of Capitalism determines the context of this debate. And the key point of that book is: historical context is everything, you can't understand the totality of social policy by looking at one thing in isolation, and you certainly can't look at what another country is doing and say "we need to do that"...it just makes no sense (a good example of this is the changes that Sweden has made: despite the severity of their crisis, they worked out what they did well and built on that). I know expertise isn't fashionable rn, but you should read what people who have studied this their whole life are saying...as opposed to just believing what you feel.
I love HN. I don't think there is any other place on the internet that has so many people who are both totally ignorant but believe they understand almost everything very very well. Classic engineer mindset.
Also, please stop posting smug putdowns of others. Those are usually examples of the thing they're complaining about, and unsurprisingly they evoke worse from the others, who take the unfairness in them as an excuse to lash back.
We've had to ask you this kind of thing several times before. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
How obtuse are you? Of course I'm talking about working life. Survey data just reflects peoples' indoctrination anyway and getting anything through a dense American's head is nearly impossible if it involves imaginary 'freedom'. Makes sense when you fuck the whole world with imperialism, gotta justify it somehow.
> as opposed to just believing what you feel.
I've spent plenty of time reading 'serious' academics across all kinds of ideological lines. Esping-Andersen is not an absolute authority. America is still pathetic and broken no matter how you twist it. And yes, Europe is bad and we should off their billionaires too, not sure what you expect from me there.
> I love HN. I don't think there is any other place on the internet that has so many people who are both totally ignorant but believe they understand almost everything very very well. Classic engineer mindset.
And you're a bootlicking shit that is throating a combination of right-wing immigration policy and neoliberalism, so?
It also routinely ends up with poison like "How obtuse are you?" and, god help us, "you're a bootlicking shit". Since you're participating regularly here, I assume this is not the kind of place you want HN to be, so please don't make it so. The GP comment shouldn't have posted that smug and supercilious putdown, and you shouldn't be responding with even worse.
I don't want to ban you because you've also posted good comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22123132 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21818850. Unfortunately those are mixed in with personal attacks, petty swipes, and political boilerplate, and at this point the bad stuff grossly outweighs the good. You're doing a lot more damage than you're adding value at this point, so means we're going to have to ban you if you don't fix it. Please fix it.
The most effective way to move people out of poverty is to create jobs. Whatever system you have, the only way it goes wrong (as it did for Europe through most of the 90/2000s) is when you cannot create jobs. There is no other option. America has got it 95% right.
And the main issue in the US is: are people willing to accept significant intervention into their working life from the govt? Are people willing to accept living in a society that is run for large corporations (it is funny that most Americans think they live there already, not even close)? Can the US bring immigration down significantly? Can the economy still function with lower immigration? Can the US still function with high prices of basic goods? The answer to almost all of those questions is no. America has a system that suits America...that is why they have it (and btw, if you talk to social policy academics from the countries with higher social safety nets, they will tell you the same thing).
Maybe this is controversial now but it is far easier to suggest that we should tear everything down than work out how to make progress with something that is mostly working.