They'd have to crawl all incoming data, and compare it with you (I.e. identifying you) in order to know whether or not that picture they just slurped up was someone who had opted out. Opt-outs don't work by definition when what you are opting out of is a system of identification.
The fact of the matter is, the system shouldn't have been made in the first place,and the mere existence of it guarantees the capability for it to be abused.
I casually know the guys who made this, and they're, well, unorthodox thinkers in terms of ethics. I highly doubt that, say, government regulations would've prevented them from building this app (although it may prevent them from using it in certain regions).
It's very hard to put neural network and image recognition tools into public hands and also prevent anyone in the world from building something like this. Such is the Pandora's Box of technology.
You don't think people would pay serious crypto for access to this? Or that states with different "ethics" wouldn't pay for it?
But I think most people here would fight against those systems once discovered, and there's no reason to allow clearview to profit now.
We need laws. (Or just let everybody know everything: "Privacy is dead".)
Maybe it is you who should check the thesaurus and get a little more understanding of the world before posting dismissive comments.
The distinction is important because one can be very efficient (using resources carefully) while being ineffective (not achieving desired results).
In this context, the distinction is relevant because it is not clear that mass surveillance is a useful tool for preventing unlawful behavior (what most of us consider to be the desired result of law enforcement). Mass surveillance is effective at mass population control (e.g., subverting opposition political movements).
[1]: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/04/french-regulator...
When a person uploads a profile picture or appears in a security camera feed, they typically have an intent that doesn't match Clearview's use case, and an expectation that the stuff that Clearview.ai is trying to do with the image was humanly impossible. Historically, it has been impossible. True, some people are good with faces, and I'm sure some of them work in law enforcement or advertising, but no one can cross-reference 7 billion profile pictures to every security camera on the planet, and remember who went where at what time.
I'd argue that there's a fundamental difference in whether a right does or does not apply based on scale. A human looking at one data point needs to be approached ethically and legislatively differently from a machine looking at a million identical data points, because the use cases are different.
Clearview.ai is trying to make a land grab on human rights, asserting that because the things that they're trying to do have not yet been prohibited (because they're complicated, and because no one realized they were feasible) that they ought to continue to be allowed to do them.
For some reason open source licenses come to mind. You can use this code (or image) under terms XYZ and this license has to go with it too. That way, me letting github to show my code publicly doesn't give you license to do whatever you want with it. Or me letting linkedin show my picture doesn't give you license to do whatever you want with it. Maybe we need something like that.
Thus if I give a company access to my data it does not give them a carte blanche to use it however they see fit, instead I have allowed usage of the data for a set of purposes.
By your logic:
1. train a model with A-list actors' tabloid photos
2. make a CGI feature film
3. ???
Profit!
That’d be a fascinating case!
If these were people rather than computers, I don’t think you could ask them to forget a face. But they could be asked to destroy notes or derived work.
(edit: on further reading it looks like GDPR requires opt in, while CCPA seems to only require opt in for people younger than 16, and requires opt-out for people 16 or older, which is some bullshit)
Regardless, I should be able to say "I'm opting out" and the onus should be on them to figure out how to do it, rather than me submitting enough pictures for them to recognize and exclude me from their crawler. This seems against even CCPA.
(another edit since this pisses me off so much: The page linked says "Alternatively, you can email: [email protected]" so I'm just going to email them to tell them I opt out. They can figure out how to comply with my opt out)