Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by yesenadam on Friday April 17, 2020 @06:05AM
(#22897648)
The popup after 10 seconds stopped me reading. But it was refreshingly different at least..
"Are you a human interested in humans?" with the choices "YES, I LOVE HUMANS" or "NO, I AM NOT A HUMAN".
I went with C. Back button. I don't like (presumably? no indication what clicking Yes would get me into) subscription popups that stop me reading after 10 seconds on your site!
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by s_gourichon on Friday April 17, 2020 @05:14PM
(#22903031)
What popup? I didn't even imagine there was such an annoyance.
I probably have to thank uMatrix for improving my browsing experience. It is sometimes overkill, sometimes insufficient, I wouldn't recommend it to my mom (because of the need to understand how the web works to customize it via a few clicks here and there), but for geeks like us it's great. Added benefit: when configuring I get to see the domain names of those web actors that get filtered.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by yesenadam on Sunday April 19, 2020 @06:11AM
(#22914747)
Gee dangus, I thought your (sibling) comment was both on-point and very funny, I did my best to upvote, vouch etc but it was evidently a losing battle.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by mirimir on Thursday April 16, 2020 @09:27PM
(#22895365)
For the most part, there's nothing surprising here. Because we know so little, and searches for evidence have been driven by preconceptions, and outright superstition.
This jumps out as the key observation :
> By contrast, Mina Weinstein-Evron, an archaeologist at Haifa University who co-discovered the Misliya Cave jawbone suspects that the recent findings are H. sapiens but agrees that the story of anatomically modern human dispersal is still far from clear. “We know nothing. We have a dot of evidence here and a dot of evidence there,” she says. “And then we use these big words like ‘migration’ and ‘dispersal.’ We talk as if they bought a ticket. But they didn’t know where they were going. For them it was probably not even a movement, maybe it was 10 kilometers per generation.”
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by mc32 on Thursday April 16, 2020 @09:46PM
(#22895473)
I guess that would point to generational territoriality driven by pop growth, i.e, each new generation has to expand into new territory with occasional infill when the initial settler generation fades out.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by WalterBright on Thursday April 16, 2020 @11:12PM
(#22895879)
Tens of thousands of people have literally walked across the US continent. Ancient people walking across Eurasia doesn't seem that worthy of surprise, on the contrary, it would seem surprising if they didn't.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by goatlover on Friday April 17, 2020 @04:20AM
(#22897180)
It's a little bit easier to walk across a continent if there are already known human establishments along the way to get supplies, existing roads or paths, and maps. It also helps to know what kind of competition to expect from other wildlife or hominids who might already live there.
Let's ask a question. Is it known whether anyone walked across North or South American in the 1600s? Native or European?
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by numbsafari on Friday April 17, 2020 @06:13AM
(#22897684)
Consider the travels of the Narvaez expedition[1], which landed in Florida in 1528, traveled a small distance by land, rebuilt their boats, then went to roughly where Galveston is today, then a handful of survivors wandered what is today the lands along the US/Mexico border, until finally rejoining the Spaniards who hand conquered the Aztecs in what is today, Mexico City around 1536 or so.
They covered a tremendous amount of ground and, out of about 600 who started, only 3 or so survived. The most famous is Cabeza de Vaca, who would return to Spain, write a book, then be sent to what is now Paraguay and Argentina, where he governed for a while before being sent back to Spain again.
He did all that without cars or planes, or motorboats. These people could go very far.
My favorite from the expedition was a Morrocan named “Estevanico” [2]. His story is pretty amazing.
My guess is that lots of humans traveled like this, over great distances. Some went far, some not so much. The North American tribes took slaves, traded them amongst each other, or sometimes seemed to accept strangers with open arms before nicely sending them along. Other times they would just kill strangers, sometimes almost for sport or entertainment.
Traveling back then wasn’t easy, and encountering other humans could just as easily accelerate your progress as it would stop you dead in your tracks.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by pjc50 on Friday April 17, 2020 @04:51AM
(#22897328)
Lewis & Clark are usually counted as the first, in 1803; as for natives, there's a huge documentation problem - if someone had it is quite likely we wouldn't know about it.
But for nomadic hunters, there seems no reason why it wouldn't be possible in theory provided they didn't have to cross a desert or impassable mountain range. Which are serious problems for walking across all the continents.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by Bayart on Friday April 17, 2020 @03:35AM
(#22896989)
That was within the context of an organized migration promoted by the US government. It seems reasonable people wouldn't have nearly the same impetus to move without such support structures.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by WalterBright on Friday April 17, 2020 @05:42AM
(#22897562)
The '49 California Gold Rush was hardly organized or promoted by the US government. Later, something like 20,000 died on the Oregon Trail. Doesn't sound very organized to me.
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by ryanmjacobs on Friday April 17, 2020 @03:54AM
(#22897073)
Yeah, to be honest, without seeing your comment I was going to skip on this article. I figured it was going to be an anti-China COVID article. Nevertheless, happily surprised with the article's contents on anthropology
Re:Will Asia Rewrite Human History?
by Hamuko on Friday April 17, 2020 @06:29AM
(#22897766)
I figured it was just going to be an article about China. You don't really need to have a COVID angle for combining "China" and "rewriting history". Tiananmen Square anyone?
"Are you a human interested in humans?" with the choices "YES, I LOVE HUMANS" or "NO, I AM NOT A HUMAN".
I went with C. Back button. I don't like (presumably? no indication what clicking Yes would get me into) subscription popups that stop me reading after 10 seconds on your site!
I probably have to thank uMatrix for improving my browsing experience. It is sometimes overkill, sometimes insufficient, I wouldn't recommend it to my mom (because of the need to understand how the web works to customize it via a few clicks here and there), but for geeks like us it's great. Added benefit: when configuring I get to see the domain names of those web actors that get filtered.
This jumps out as the key observation :
> By contrast, Mina Weinstein-Evron, an archaeologist at Haifa University who co-discovered the Misliya Cave jawbone suspects that the recent findings are H. sapiens but agrees that the story of anatomically modern human dispersal is still far from clear. “We know nothing. We have a dot of evidence here and a dot of evidence there,” she says. “And then we use these big words like ‘migration’ and ‘dispersal.’ We talk as if they bought a ticket. But they didn’t know where they were going. For them it was probably not even a movement, maybe it was 10 kilometers per generation.”
> US out of North America now!
Let's ask a question. Is it known whether anyone walked across North or South American in the 1600s? Native or European?
They covered a tremendous amount of ground and, out of about 600 who started, only 3 or so survived. The most famous is Cabeza de Vaca, who would return to Spain, write a book, then be sent to what is now Paraguay and Argentina, where he governed for a while before being sent back to Spain again.
He did all that without cars or planes, or motorboats. These people could go very far.
My favorite from the expedition was a Morrocan named “Estevanico” [2]. His story is pretty amazing.
My guess is that lots of humans traveled like this, over great distances. Some went far, some not so much. The North American tribes took slaves, traded them amongst each other, or sometimes seemed to accept strangers with open arms before nicely sending them along. Other times they would just kill strangers, sometimes almost for sport or entertainment.
Traveling back then wasn’t easy, and encountering other humans could just as easily accelerate your progress as it would stop you dead in your tracks.
[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narváez_expedition
[2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estevanico
But for nomadic hunters, there seems no reason why it wouldn't be possible in theory provided they didn't have to cross a desert or impassable mountain range. Which are serious problems for walking across all the continents.
Yet people did it anyway.
It's interesting to consider that there were several migrations out of Africa over some time period that's not really understood.