News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by pathik on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:13AM (#2288510)
Patent troll!
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by pavlov on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:22AM (#2288538)
Alternatively, he's a guy who did a physics PhD when he was 23, did cosmology post-doc studies under Stephen Hawking, founded a software company and sold it to Microsoft when he was 27, and later created Microsoft Research at the ripe age of 31.

But maybe that counts for nothing when an emotional topic like patents is involved. Look, an ugly troll, let's throw some rocks!

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by TomOfTTB on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:28AM (#2288567)
OK, here's a challenge to you. What has Nathan Myhrvold actually ever created. He didn't make any great contribution to physics or cosmology. His software company made a product that was a clone of another product. Microsoft Research has been a money drain since its inception (having never created a revolutionary advance). And now he runs a company that does nothing but file patents.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by sp332 on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:35PM (#2288906)
Microsoft Research has been a money drain since its inception (having never created a revolutionary advance).

I can only assume you don't know anything about MS Research. They've been producing more published CS papers than anyone else for years now. They conducted the user studies that went into region-specific handwriting recognition on their tablets, and the Office Ribbon. They also developed the vision system in the Kinect. http://research.microsoft.com/ They're doing an amazing amount of research there.

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by lukeschlather on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:49PM (#2288978)
Given the amount of money Microsoft has to throw around, I don't think the amount of research is in any way remarkable. Though there are definitely some amazing products coming out of MS research.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by kenjackson on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:54AM (#2288697)
Some say one of the best cookbooks ever created.

But also they have done some really cool stuff. Like they have this device that uses laser to shoot down individual mosquitoes, but not just any mosquitoe, but uses technology to see how the blood is flowing in the mosqitoe (as its flying through the air) to decide which mosqitoes are carrying malaria, and only shoot those.

He also has built a portable refrigeration unit that can store vaccines (and other meds) for long periods of time with no power. Besides the cookbook though, I don't think he's created anything you'd buy at a store. Most of his work is focused on environmental and 3rd world issues.

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by bitwize on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:11PM (#2288800)
He's an amazing business-model innovator (though probably all credit goes to Jerome Lemelson for the original implementation; too bad Jerry wasn't aware of business-method patents!).

Yes, tongue firmly planted in cheek.

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by qohen on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:30PM (#2288891)
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by rudiger on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:05PM (#2288760)
This is a tired argument. Why don't we all go and work the fields? Maybe then we can "actually" create something (whatever that means).
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by DuncanIdaho on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:33AM (#2288585)
Seems like he read Putt's law and really took maximum out of it.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by bediger on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:27AM (#2288558)
To be fair, the revenue is all from licensing, right?

That makes Intellectual Ventures a Non-Practicing Entity, right?

I think we can rationally judge Myhrvold to be a troll at this point. We don't need emotional responses.

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by Tycho on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:52PM (#2288990)
But if they were licencing, then their patents were actually being 'practiced,' just not by them, so the net effect is the same. Can you support on one hand the patenting of ideas companies develop while working on a product, but on the other hand complain when those patents are traded to someone else? Further, what about when a company does some difficult research, solves a problem, gets a patent - is that really 'Non-Practicing' ? Some trolls have got no intention of licencing anything, or researching anything, they just launch surprise lawsuits and ignore licencing requests.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by bediger on Friday March 04, 2011 @01:02PM (#2289034)
First, it's not the patents that don't get practice, it's the entities doing the patenting. If you hld a patent, but don't actually use the technology yourself, you're an NPE, approximately.

Second, patent law doesn't have an independent invention excuse. One can invent something, not patent it, and use it for years without running into trouble. A Non-Practicing Entity can get a patent, and sue you into oblivion. How many cases of "patent holder sues 10 tech giants" have you seen in the news? Do you suppose that every one of the 397 companies (http://fosspatents.blogspot.com/2011/03/microsoft-and-google...) sued by GeoTag, Inc. filched the idea behind the patent? Do you suppose that any of those 397 companies copied the idea from GeoTag, Inc's product(s)?

Do you think that Intellectual Ventures has any intent of producing product(s) with any of it's large number of patents?

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by Tycho on Friday March 04, 2011 @01:20PM (#2289115)
I don't know, one wonders why GeoTag filed ~400 patents at the exact same time, but the basic idea of an R&D only company that makes money by licencing its discoveries, or even of a company that makes money by buying other peoples patents, seem to be logical extensions of having any agreeance with the patent system. Bad patents, of course, are another matter (or being sued for something you 'invented' - isn't that supposed to be impossible?)
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by bediger on Friday March 04, 2011 @01:44PM (#2289232)
Independent invention is definitely not a defense in a patent infringement suit: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=903521

That's certainly consistent with the current, US Constitution basis for patents, to encourage general progress by giving a limited monopoly to an inventor.

It's not consistent with any kind of "ownership basis" for patents, which gives someone a monopoly on an idea because of the exceptional, very special nature of the invention. If we grant ownership of an idea to someone based on the incredibleness of their invention, then surely an independent inventor deserves the same, or maybe even more, privilege on the idea.

Patent cases don't consider whether the alleged infringer "stole"/copied the idea, or thought of it independently. The one study that has been done on this appears to support independent invention in almost all cases: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1270160

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by Tycho on Friday March 04, 2011 @02:14PM (#2289358)
I thought you meant 'original' inventor, not just independant invention.

Also it makes sense that most cases would point to independant invention, as if a business stole it they'd have every reason to believe they'd get caught... maybe. My point is that if independant invention was a successful defence then perhaps 'everyone' would use it and most patents wouldn't work at all.

Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by rbarooah on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:28AM (#2288566)
Smart people can do ugly things.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by Tyrannosaurs on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:32AM (#2288580)
Yep, he's a clever patent troll.
Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date by drallison on Friday March 04, 2011 @11:26AM (#2288556)
Add to his accomplishments a serious cookbook. http://www.amazon.com/Modernist-Cuisine-Art-Science-Cooking/...