The solution is for everyone to use encrypted email, where the decrypted data only exist on your hard disk. Governments and powerful people can still get at it, but to do so they have to burgle your house, which costs them time and money (so they can't do it to everyone), popularity (in states that have to care about what the public thinks, they can't burgle everyone), and also alerts the suspect.
So why don't people do this? I use gmail because it's convenient. The solution to this problem is obviously to make locally-stored email as easy to read as gmail.
As it happens, I'm working on a project ("Shout!" is the current working title) that aims to do just that (among other things).
If you have the power to issue subpoenas, you can find out a lot of things assuming you know which people to ask.
"[email protected] was registered to Brian McCarthy at the same Deer Park address Comcast had revealed."
So either the account had information (maybe ip logs but article clearly states name + home address) or it was in the emails.
The name that Google gave for the email address was found out to be same as the one given by Comcast. Also the guy seemed to be located at Deer park as revealed by the info from Comcast (not Google).
Does that make the story clearer? Or am I the one misinterpreting?
Gmail has information including his name and address? Really?
Anyhow, another con to using one email account for everything.