I've used the word "donation" a few times, but I don't really see it as a charity. They're providing me a service and I'm simply allowed to pay whatever I want for it.
To that end, YouTube Premium is a disappointment to me. It's fixed at $12/mo for everything. I can't donate more and I can't pay less in exchange for removing ads on only a few specific channels. On top of that, there is no transparency over how much money is taken by Google and how the remainder is split across the channels I watch.
YouTube Premium is a service for people who can't or wont setup ad blockers, are already paying for Google Play Music, care about the exclusive content, or want to download videos with the YouTube mobile app.
I use a PiHole and have no problem using a VPN to connect to my home network if I want to block ads on my phone. I still buy my music, so I don't care about the Google Play Music subscription. I don't care about the exclusive content and I can just use youtube-dl if I really want to download a video.
The only reason I would get YouTube Premium is to support YouTube itself. But the questionable actions YouTube has taken to stabilize its ad revenue (coupled with the many problems of its parent company, Google) alleviate any guilt I might have otherwise felt. At this point, I only use YouTube because of their content monopoly.
> [...]
> Just let me make small, monthly donations to the creators I like. In exchange, spare me the ads. YouTube can even take 50% of the cut or whatever.
I'm confused. Isn't that exactly what YouTube Red (now called YouTube Premium) is? $12/month, no ads, creators you watch get paid out of the monthly subscription instead. (A payment which was, last I checked, significantly more money per-user than ad revenue is.)