In a viewer-contributed system, only creators that have a good audience worth paying into would receive donations, but those lesser known videos would essentially have to be subsidized by those donations since those videos wouldn't bring donations in themselves. YouTube's cut, 50% as you suggest, would probably be better spent making the platform better for those creators than hosting videos that brings in no donations.
Also only a very very small subset of the audience will donate. Platforms that have been predicated on donating or subscribing to receive content are struggling to lift off (besides Patreon, which is effectively a marketplace for content, merchandise, behind the scenes stuff, etc rather than just a video hosting platform).
There are 2 Youtubes, one for embedded viral clips you discover around the web and one for professional content that viewers subscribe to.
I think Youtube has issues shoe-horning both systems into one monetization scheme. I think this is mostly a problem of inertia but either they need to make things more stable for their professional creators or someone else needs to build a better platform for these pros.
There’s a whole ecosystem of niche review channels that have decent but transient viewership.
For instance some chromebook reviewing channel posts reviews of almost every chromebook coming out to market. There might be some people subscribing to that, but the bulk of the views will be from search results, and only for 3 or 4 videos per viewer (once they make their buying decision they’re done).
That’s an example I could think of on the spot, but there are many many facets of youtube that have a decent traffic with no allegiance from the viewer. They also survive by managing in-content ads themselves, having affiliates or any other system external to youtube, but youtube ads must still represent something to them.
This situation is also true on Twitch. For every big streamer pulling >1k viewers per stream, there's thousands of small streamers with <10.
Youtube has already made a token effort to mimicing this with the 'join' button, but right now that more patron-centric revenue model looks to be a short- and medium-term winning formula. Youtube would likely benefit from pursuing it.
To monetize your video you need to have 1000 subscribers and 4000 hours of watch time in the past 12 months.
Twitch is primarily an ad platform. That's where they make most of their money, and why they're making changes to increase ad impressions. Subscriptions used to give you site-wide ad-free. Now it's only for that channel.
See Devin Nash streams for insight into the business of Twitch. It's not public info, so it's a lot of reading between the lines and anonymous first-hand accounts, but I imagine it's accurate.
The direct-pay model is vastly preferable because it keeps advertisers from controlling content, and Twitch certainly has shown greater success here than I've seen before. But it's not happening on Twitch. At least not like it should.
Twitch since acquisition has made some changes (e.g. no longer hiding ads for prime members, forcing pre-roll ads on channels) to increase the amount of adverts seen but content creators hate adverts.
Twitch is live and not episodic which means that it relies on people watching and staying to watch. Pre-roll ads cause a noticable bounce rate, where someone clicks on a channel and because an advert starts playing thinks "nevermind" and clicks a different channel. Adverts during streams are suitable for some games with natural pauses but for others just interrupt things and any time creators have a break (which they should have more often for their health), they will lose a significant part of their audience.
Most games don't have a natural cliffhanger or other hook to get people to wait for "after the break", so the audience will just think, "I wonder what x is doing" and click through to their channel instead. In fact they don't need to wonder, it's present on their sidebar as a constant reminder of what other channels are showing.
So there's this weird situation where Twitch is reliant on both content creators and want advertising revenue but adverts actively harm content creators so resent being forced to play adverts.
I love the direct-support model as a consumer/viewer, but I have significant doubts that it competes with ad dollars nearly as well as people would like it to.
Buying things for daily needs, and advertising for them is still normal.
Unless you're willing to turn Youtube into a 'Developed western countries only thing'(which already exists - it's called Youtube premium), advertising is a better option.
If only it was possible to pay for the true hosting and bandwidth cost, with discovery/search mechanisms either open source or on a separate service (decentralized and smaller in scope), and again a separate platform to support individual creators.
Not disagreeing with you, just pointing out that the Twitch model might still suck on some level.
> [...]
> Just let me make small, monthly donations to the creators I like. In exchange, spare me the ads. YouTube can even take 50% of the cut or whatever.
I'm confused. Isn't that exactly what YouTube Red (now called YouTube Premium) is? $12/month, no ads, creators you watch get paid out of the monthly subscription instead. (A payment which was, last I checked, significantly more money per-user than ad revenue is.)
I've used the word "donation" a few times, but I don't really see it as a charity. They're providing me a service and I'm simply allowed to pay whatever I want for it.
To that end, YouTube Premium is a disappointment to me. It's fixed at $12/mo for everything. I can't donate more and I can't pay less in exchange for removing ads on only a few specific channels. On top of that, there is no transparency over how much money is taken by Google and how the remainder is split across the channels I watch.
YouTube Premium is a service for people who can't or wont setup ad blockers, are already paying for Google Play Music, care about the exclusive content, or want to download videos with the YouTube mobile app.
I use a PiHole and have no problem using a VPN to connect to my home network if I want to block ads on my phone. I still buy my music, so I don't care about the Google Play Music subscription. I don't care about the exclusive content and I can just use youtube-dl if I really want to download a video.
The only reason I would get YouTube Premium is to support YouTube itself. But the questionable actions YouTube has taken to stabilize its ad revenue (coupled with the many problems of its parent company, Google) alleviate any guilt I might have otherwise felt. At this point, I only use YouTube because of their content monopoly.
Maybe they should just let creators monetize their own channels by having, as you said, a subscription service similar to Twitch as the main monetization.
The model used by Twitch seems far more reliable. I thought they were going that way with YouTube Red, but that ended up being a huge disappointment. After about a year I switched to just donating to my subs on external platforms.
Just let me make small, monthly donations to the creators I like. In exchange, spare me the ads. YouTube can even take 50% of the cut or whatever. It's more stable that way for both YouTube and its creators.