Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by kbrosnan on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:55PM
(#22815840)
Mark Surman is the Executive Director (CEO)[1] of the Mozilla Foundation.
[1] - An executive director is a chief executive officer (CEO) or managing director of an organization, company, or corporation. The title is widely used in North American non-profit organizations, though many United States nonprofits have adopted the title president or CEO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_director
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by mintplant on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @06:19PM
(#22817827)
Uh, really? In my experience Chromium takes far longer than Firefox to build, especially from scratch. Not to mention all the steps and bespoke repo-management tools involved in just checking out the code and bringing up a working build environment.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by geoelectric on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:34PM
(#22816200)
Without commenting on Mitchell's fitness as CEO, I think there are a few important points here that don't resonate unless you were at Mozilla.
The first is that Mitchell and Gerv probably were familiar enough with each other for her to speak to this. Gerv was very prominent inside the project, and Mitchell really did know everyone in the organization (at least in the triple digit or less days).
The second is that Gerv quite openly led with his religion, and this was incredibly controversial. It caused a lot of churn when Mozilla was working out community guidelines and that discussion was anything but private. I'm sure that led her to think that speaking to that publicly was essential.
The third is that Gerv was more or less impervious to criticism about his religion or his attitude of being open with it in all arenas, and probably wouldn't have blinked at any of her take. There was a lot of open conversation internally (and IIRC externally) about it. I suspect this led her to think that speaking as frankly as she might have to him or with the org internally was appropriate.
In total, I think she was wrong on a number of counts, the biggest being that the time after someone's death is about everyone else's reconciliation and they weren't coming from the same perspective Gerv would have. The optics were awful, and a combo of natural perception of position and her detached writing style makes it sound like a CEO crapping on the line from on high. The Mozilla "relationship" structure was much flatter than that, though, and with Gerv's community prominence and impact they were closer to peers than one might imagine.
Honestly, this shouldn't be the incident that colors her legacy. It was a pretty ill-advised blog post, but I don't think it's as malicious or even harmful as people make out, knowing the names involved. It's really hard to get across exactly how unshakably comfortable Gerv seemed to be with his faith and exactly how much that colored his relationship with the org.
I can't imagine how she could have acknowledged his impact without at least touching on some of that--even if I do think saying nothing at all would've been the winning move.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by orra on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:54PM
(#22815823)
I thought it was a good obit:
> To memorialize Gerv’s passing, it is fitting that we remember all of Gerv — the full person, good and bad, the damage and trauma he caused, as well as his many positive contributions. Any other view is sentimental. We should be clear-eyed, acknowledge the problems, and appreciate the positive contributions.
Yes, let's remember the good. And let us be polite. But we should not sanctify the dead, by pretending they never caused others hurt if they did.
Again, I thought the obit got this balance just right.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by glaslong on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:10PM
(#22815994)
It definitely runs up against social taboos to speak so frankly of the departed, but I find it refreshing personally. I can’t speak for anyone but myself, but were I to die tomorrow I would actually prefer that the whole of my life is remembered:
- Accomplishments recognized, good and bad.
- Loved ones given space to grieve.
- And anyone I may have hurt allowed their feelings of relief.
Our legacy is what we leave behind, not just net change, or the parts we wish it to be.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by throw7 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:30PM
(#22816182)
It's just poor taste to talk smack about a dead guy. Her "eulogy" came off as a kind of personal grievance even, which just made it worse... she should really know better being in a supervisory/executive level.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by glaslong on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:51PM
(#22816375)
I didn’t read it as smack talk. Though I agree most will probably see it that way, so it is poor taste by definition.
I never knew the man, but personally I feel like I have a greater appreciation for who he was than if the In Memoriam had only mentioned positive contributions. It makes him feel more real and human to me.
It‘s certainly bad form for someone in leadership, but in the same way that I appreciate leaders who break from PR spin to acknowledge and explain the nuance, I also appreciate a more balanced remembrance.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by DavidVoid on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:22PM
(#22816108)
I've always hated how as soon as someone dies, people pretend that they never did anything wrong. And if anyone dares to bring up the bad things they did then that person usually gets strongly criticized and told to be more compassionate or whatever. I definitely think people should be polite about their grievances ofc, but ignoring the bad stuff a person did throughout their life is more damaging than acknowledging it.
Westworld actress Evan Rachel Wood, herself a survivor of rape and sexual abuse, got a lot of shit recently for her tweet about the late Koby Bryant for example.
"What has happened is tragic. I am heartbroken for Kobe’s family. He was a sports hero. He was also a rapist. And all of these truths can exist simultaneously"
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by ianbicking on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @05:54PM
(#22817614)
So far my experience of her as a CEO is that she is very frank and direct. She's not as reassuring as Chris Beard was (the previous CEO), but personally I prefer the direct, sometimes openly unassured communication that I think more honestly expresses what she thinks and where Mozilla is at.
When she started as interim CEO she herself noted that she has been warned that her directness has been interpreted as negative in ways that she has not intended, and asked us to take account of that. I have, and I feel okay about that. I prefer it to the bland opaqueness that is the norm for executive communication.
It is very easy to read that obituary in her voice. I had not read it before, but it doesn't surprise me. I'm sure I wouldn't write an obituary the same way, but if I was going to be memorialized with either something bland and impersonal (sadly the norm), or something like this, I would prefer the latter.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by kamikaz1k on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:54PM
(#22815818)
> To memorialize Gerv’s passing, it is fitting that we remember all of Gerv — the full person, good and bad, the damage and trauma he caused, as well as his many positive contributions. Any other view is sentimental. We should be clear-eyed, acknowledge the problems, and appreciate the positive contributions. Gerv came to Mozilla long before we were successful or had much to offer besides our goals and our open source foundations. As Gerv put it, he’s gone home now, leaving untold memories around the FLOSS world.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by neosat on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:51PM
(#22815784)
I read the full content in the link posted and the still agree with the original comment poster(not sure why they are being downvoted) . At best, the post seems like poor judgment in choice of what to say for that occasion.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by packetslave on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:52PM
(#22815798)
Definitely worth reading the entire thing instead of cherry-picking quotes from it (which I'm cheerfully about to do):
> To memorialize Gerv’s passing, it is fitting that we remember all of Gerv — the full person, good and bad, the damage and trauma he caused, as well as his many positive contributions. Any other view is sentimental. We should be clear-eyed, acknowledge the problems, and appreciate the positive contributions
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by hutzlibu on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:06PM
(#22815944)
Does anyone can tell anything positive about her?
I am not saying there isn't any, I don't know her. My limited knowledge about her, is that while she was chairwomen and interim ceo, Firefox marketshare dropped a lot, while her compensation went up a lot - and it seems she was responsible for firing 70 people from the mozilla workforce, while she never wrote any line of code of firefox.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by mjw1007 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @04:20PM
(#22816643)
I think a programmer might well do a better job than a lawyer.
Some years ago, Mozilla decided to relaunch their browser under the name "Firebird". That was a poor choice of name, because there was already a free-software database using it.
There was a kerfuffle about it for some time before Mozilla switched to the (much better) name "Firefox".
During that period, the Mozilla lawyer running the show (one Mitchell Baker) was insistent that there was no reason to change because their legal advice was that they weren't infringing on any trademarks.
A programmer might have realised earlier that trademark law isn't the only relevant consideration in a situation like this (consider, for example, what `apt-get install firebird` is going to do).
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by hutzlibu on Thursday April 09, 2020 @03:59AM
(#22820631)
Because Mozilla is (self declared) not just any company, but one with a very idealistic active community, involved in the development process of open internet technology?
And in this area, I believe, a focus on technical expertise might be a better fit, than a focus on legal expertise.
You surely need legal expertise as well, but maybe not primarily. Primarily mozilla needs a superior browser, to combat bad market share.
And the engineers at firefox surely are doing a great job (mostly), but then I really do not understand the connection of laying of technical people, who build the actual product and using this money to compensate the CEO which does not have technical expertise, if the goal is, to get relevant again as a browser.
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by e15ctr0n on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:48PM
(#22816350)
> Does anyone can tell anything positive about her?
She's the reason Mozilla exists today as an independent, non-profit organization.
On March 31, 1998 Netscape allowed the Mozilla code base to be open sourced under the Mozilla Project. [1][2] This was the result of an intensive year-long effort to
(1) remove proprietary source code that couldn't be open-sourced,
(2) release the source code under a brand new license called the Mozilla Public License. This license was written principally by Mitchell Baker whose formal education is in law, with input from ESR, Linus Torvalds, VA Research, etc. [3]
On July 14, 2003 AOL (which had acquired Netscape earlier) closed down the Netscape division and laid off almost everyone there, including Mitchell Baker. That very day Mitch Kapor [4] stepped in with funding and advice to help Baker and a core team of total 10 employees set up the Mozilla Foundation in an office in Mountain View that is today occupied by the Khan Academy. [5]
Wikipedia [6] has a good summary of her career.
The documentary Code Rush is required viewing, IMHO, to capture some of the excitement of that era. [7][8] Bonus points for spotting JWZ. :-)
Re:Mitchell Baker Named CEO of Mozilla
by lostmsu on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @07:45PM
(#22818402)
I understand that some people know more than others. But this was a perfectly legitimate question. Not everyone is following Mozilla leadership. We are genuinely curious.
I think they stopped with the wrangler title and changed it to chair woman though.
She now sits as the head of both the foundation and the corporation.
[1] - An executive director is a chief executive officer (CEO) or managing director of an organization, company, or corporation. The title is widely used in North American non-profit organizations, though many United States nonprofits have adopted the title president or CEO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_director
And I really LOVE using Firefox...when it works.
But I extra especially HATE building FF from source. I'll take chromium any day for that.
What problems did you run into building Firefox?
The first is that Mitchell and Gerv probably were familiar enough with each other for her to speak to this. Gerv was very prominent inside the project, and Mitchell really did know everyone in the organization (at least in the triple digit or less days).
The second is that Gerv quite openly led with his religion, and this was incredibly controversial. It caused a lot of churn when Mozilla was working out community guidelines and that discussion was anything but private. I'm sure that led her to think that speaking to that publicly was essential.
The third is that Gerv was more or less impervious to criticism about his religion or his attitude of being open with it in all arenas, and probably wouldn't have blinked at any of her take. There was a lot of open conversation internally (and IIRC externally) about it. I suspect this led her to think that speaking as frankly as she might have to him or with the org internally was appropriate.
In total, I think she was wrong on a number of counts, the biggest being that the time after someone's death is about everyone else's reconciliation and they weren't coming from the same perspective Gerv would have. The optics were awful, and a combo of natural perception of position and her detached writing style makes it sound like a CEO crapping on the line from on high. The Mozilla "relationship" structure was much flatter than that, though, and with Gerv's community prominence and impact they were closer to peers than one might imagine.
Honestly, this shouldn't be the incident that colors her legacy. It was a pretty ill-advised blog post, but I don't think it's as malicious or even harmful as people make out, knowing the names involved. It's really hard to get across exactly how unshakably comfortable Gerv seemed to be with his faith and exactly how much that colored his relationship with the org.
I can't imagine how she could have acknowledged his impact without at least touching on some of that--even if I do think saying nothing at all would've been the winning move.
I also note that that there are no edits/retractions/clarifications or similar on that post, about 1.5 years later.
So I stand by my statement of this disqualifying her from managing other people.
> To memorialize Gerv’s passing, it is fitting that we remember all of Gerv — the full person, good and bad, the damage and trauma he caused, as well as his many positive contributions. Any other view is sentimental. We should be clear-eyed, acknowledge the problems, and appreciate the positive contributions.
Yes, let's remember the good. And let us be polite. But we should not sanctify the dead, by pretending they never caused others hurt if they did.
Again, I thought the obit got this balance just right.
- Accomplishments recognized, good and bad.
- Loved ones given space to grieve.
- And anyone I may have hurt allowed their feelings of relief.
Our legacy is what we leave behind, not just net change, or the parts we wish it to be.
I never knew the man, but personally I feel like I have a greater appreciation for who he was than if the In Memoriam had only mentioned positive contributions. It makes him feel more real and human to me.
It‘s certainly bad form for someone in leadership, but in the same way that I appreciate leaders who break from PR spin to acknowledge and explain the nuance, I also appreciate a more balanced remembrance.
Westworld actress Evan Rachel Wood, herself a survivor of rape and sexual abuse, got a lot of shit recently for her tweet about the late Koby Bryant for example.
"What has happened is tragic. I am heartbroken for Kobe’s family. He was a sports hero. He was also a rapist. And all of these truths can exist simultaneously"
Context about the case for those unfamiliar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kobe_Bryant_sexual_assault_cas...
When she started as interim CEO she herself noted that she has been warned that her directness has been interpreted as negative in ways that she has not intended, and asked us to take account of that. I have, and I feel okay about that. I prefer it to the bland opaqueness that is the norm for executive communication.
It is very easy to read that obituary in her voice. I had not read it before, but it doesn't surprise me. I'm sure I wouldn't write an obituary the same way, but if I was going to be memorialized with either something bland and impersonal (sadly the norm), or something like this, I would prefer the latter.
Mozilla certainly had plenty of opportunity to cut the cord.
> Eventually Gerv felt called to live his faith by publicly judging others in politely stated but damning terms.
... in essence, kind of what the post is doing ...
> To memorialize Gerv’s passing, it is fitting that we remember all of Gerv — the full person, good and bad, the damage and trauma he caused, as well as his many positive contributions. Any other view is sentimental. We should be clear-eyed, acknowledge the problems, and appreciate the positive contributions
I am not saying there isn't any, I don't know her. My limited knowledge about her, is that while she was chairwomen and interim ceo, Firefox marketshare dropped a lot, while her compensation went up a lot - and it seems she was responsible for firing 70 people from the mozilla workforce, while she never wrote any line of code of firefox.
https://www.i-programmer.info/news/86-browsers/13394-mozilla...
So from my limited understanding as an outsider: she does not really seem the best fit, for the job.
She’s not someone who came in left field as an interim and started firing people left and right.
I’m not sure why you think a ceo should also be a programmer.
Some years ago, Mozilla decided to relaunch their browser under the name "Firebird". That was a poor choice of name, because there was already a free-software database using it.
There was a kerfuffle about it for some time before Mozilla switched to the (much better) name "Firefox".
During that period, the Mozilla lawyer running the show (one Mitchell Baker) was insistent that there was no reason to change because their legal advice was that they weren't infringing on any trademarks.
A programmer might have realised earlier that trademark law isn't the only relevant consideration in a situation like this (consider, for example, what `apt-get install firebird` is going to do).
And in this area, I believe, a focus on technical expertise might be a better fit, than a focus on legal expertise.
You surely need legal expertise as well, but maybe not primarily. Primarily mozilla needs a superior browser, to combat bad market share. And the engineers at firefox surely are doing a great job (mostly), but then I really do not understand the connection of laying of technical people, who build the actual product and using this money to compensate the CEO which does not have technical expertise, if the goal is, to get relevant again as a browser.
She's the reason Mozilla exists today as an independent, non-profit organization.
On March 31, 1998 Netscape allowed the Mozilla code base to be open sourced under the Mozilla Project. [1][2] This was the result of an intensive year-long effort to
(1) remove proprietary source code that couldn't be open-sourced,
(2) release the source code under a brand new license called the Mozilla Public License. This license was written principally by Mitchell Baker whose formal education is in law, with input from ESR, Linus Torvalds, VA Research, etc. [3]
On July 14, 2003 AOL (which had acquired Netscape earlier) closed down the Netscape division and laid off almost everyone there, including Mitchell Baker. That very day Mitch Kapor [4] stepped in with funding and advice to help Baker and a core team of total 10 employees set up the Mozilla Foundation in an office in Mountain View that is today occupied by the Khan Academy. [5]
Wikipedia [6] has a good summary of her career.
The documentary Code Rush is required viewing, IMHO, to capture some of the excitement of that era. [7][8] Bonus points for spotting JWZ. :-)
[1] https://www.cnet.com/news/netscape-sets-source-code-free/
[2] https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2018/03/31/mozilla-turns-twent...
[3] https://www.oreilly.com/openbook/freedom/ch11.html
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitch_Kapor
[5] https://blog.mozilla.org/press/2003/07/mozilla-org-announces...
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitchell_Baker
[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code_Rush
[8] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Q7FTjhvZ7Y