News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by cgrand-net on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @10:04AM (#22813033)
My bank used to reject scans but accept faxes... bureaucratic reasons.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by recursive on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @10:51AM (#22813430)
I don't know directly, but I've heard that there are special laws regarding fraud via fax. Even though fax has no technical protection, it may have legal ones, that might give the counterparty some recourse if things went bad.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by Xylakant on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:23AM (#22813703)
In Germany, a fax is legally considered an original copy, a scan/print is not, despite a fax often being a scan that’s then transmitted via fax protocols. Law hasn’t caught up with technology yet in that area.

You also get a confirmation from the recipient when using fax.

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by detaro on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:26AM (#22813734)
All the while we actually have a pretty good law about digital signatures since basically forever, but ~nobody supports those. (and they missed the chance of using the new ID cards to establish them more widely, which was really stupid)
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by derefr on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:40AM (#22813897)
> despite a fax often being a scan that’s then transmitted via fax protocols

...what's the alternative to that "often"? What is a fax machine, if not a scanner attached to a modem?

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by mrighele on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @12:30PM (#22814422)
Dialup modems speak the protocol, or at least they used to, so it was possible to send or receive a fax without a physical copy of the document. Just by "printing" from word to the modem and entering a phone number. I remember writing an excel macro to iterate over a list of customers and send a personalized word document to them. (This was 20 years ago I think and not all of our customers had an email)
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by chipsa on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:39PM (#22815669)
VoIP fax services. Webpage allows upload, sends the fax over voip, which ends up at another voip server, decodes back into a fax. Never turns analog.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by anonymfus on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @12:21PM (#22814305)
Conventional fax machine transmits document while it scans it as it has (almost) no memory. Like analog TV camera, just much slower.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by derefr on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @01:08PM (#22814814)
Sure, but that's still "a scanner attached to a modem." Nothing about a scanner implies that it must buffer the input, just like nothing about a printer implies that it buffers the output.

There are/were "line printers" doing "latch a character from the input line, print the character, unlatch" serial output (which were so common that Unix pipes are designed around the foibles of outputting to such devices.) Most POS thermal receipt printers are still line printers!

I don't know as much about scanners, but I can't imagine that the original (digital, attached to a computer) scanners weren't also "serial scanners"—i.e., rather than a 1D scan head with a long CCD strip that could latch an entire line at a time into a shift register, they would have had 2D scan-heads that would scan one pixel at a time, in a "read brightness, signal ready, wait for return line to unlatch" serial loop. No memory required, just terribly slow.

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by Xylakant on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:38PM (#22815667)
When the relevant laws were made, fax machines were purely analog devices, not a scanner attached to a modem. And once fax was legally privileged, it stuck around exactly because it was legally privileged - despite the change in technology.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by derefr on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @03:01PM (#22815899)
Again, my question:

> fax machines were purely analog devices, not a scanner attached to a modem

Why would an analog scanner not still be a scanner? I'd call whatever component that's in even the oldest fax machines "a scanner." Even if it is "enitrely analog" (continuous brightness intensity read, like a tape head or record-player stylus) you'd still call the process of converting light from a sensor passing over a document, into electricity, scanning, and you'd still call the component that does that "a scanner." Just like speakers and microphones are still "speakers" and "microphones" whether they're just transducers attached to wires, or have a whole ADC+USB/Bluetooth signal path leading out of them. Am I wrong?

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by verall on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @09:24PM (#22818978)
Yes, in the same sense that an analog telephone is recording you by translating your voice into electricity. But, at least to me, if it is voice -> electricity on wire -> speaker, it feels much less like recording than saving a buffer of voice in memory, packetizing, and then sending, even if they are both just electricity on a wire.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by LocalH on Thursday April 09, 2020 @10:44AM (#22822989)
Everything has Colour, not just bits
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by wayoutthere on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:24AM (#22813713)
Sounds like their document management system was tied to a fax line and they didn't want to bother upgrading. IT departments at banks have like, zero budget.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by qubex on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:36PM (#22815645)
I read on NH yesterday (or perhaps the day before) that in the USA HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability & Accountability Act 1996) carves our a special exemption to consider faxes ‘secure’.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by loeg on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:49PM (#22815771)
It does.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by dd36 on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @10:33AM (#22813269)
Faxes are considered secure.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by somehnguy on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:45AM (#22813951)
I'm declaring myself as considered a Triceratops . Doesn't make it true.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by cortesoft on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @05:07PM (#22817149)
If you pass a law stating you are a Triceratops, it would become 'true' in the legal sense... and since we are dealing with legality, it being declared 'secure' does matter
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by swixmix on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @11:58AM (#22814087)
It depends on the threat model. If I need to prove to a court in the US, then I'm signing paper and faxing it. To do it differently would be more expensive to prove.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by somehnguy on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @12:47PM (#22814614)
Right, the legal system considers it secure.

I'm talking about the technical sense. Where there is no encryption at all, anyone with a phone line splitter can listen in, and the machines are usually not in a secured area so anyone could just pick up the fax and walk away. Not secure at all.

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by monkpit on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @01:32PM (#22815058)
I don’t think you need to argue that fax is not technically secure on HN. Pretty sure we are all on the same page there. What matters is legal precedent and existing policy in various countries.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by loeg on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:51PM (#22815785)
> I don’t think you need to argue that fax is not technically secure on HN. Pretty sure we are all on the same page there.

dd36 and swixmix seem to be taking the other side of that argument.

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by dd36 on Thursday April 16, 2020 @12:39AM (#22886124)
If I were taking that side, I wouldn’t have qualified my statement. Gov’t and courts consider it secure. HIPAA compliant, etc.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by jkaplowitz on Thursday April 09, 2020 @12:30AM (#22819792)
It depends on what your threat model is. The attacks you're talking about are real, absolutely.

For the threat model of a physically local attacker with either the right timing (for grabbing an incoming fax) or the right knowledge (for the phone system equivalent of tcpdump), you're quite right that fax is insecure. Likewise for state sponsored adversaries or certain organized crime groups.

But if you just want to make it hard for people scanning the internet to see what juicy corporate espionage they can find and resell, without specifically targeting you, fax is probably less vulnerable to that threat model than, for example, an undermaintained email server. Likewise if you piss off script kiddies somewhere on the internet with botnets and exploit kits, your website is probably a bigger risk than your fax machine.

Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by bcoates on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @02:44PM (#22815729)
They're secure in the sense of being low-risk for active content shenanigans and a small surface area for vulnerabilities. Attacking a network through a .tiff of a fax is a lot harder than attacking it through an email, pdf, word doc, http session, etc.
Re:Show HN: FalsiScan – Make it look like a PDF has been han... by yourapostasy on Wednesday April 08, 2020 @04:41PM (#22816839)
Behold...the power of lobbyists. Fax industry sure got their money's worth that year that passed.